Is Stem Cell Research Ethical

Decent Essays
The University of Nebraska’s Medical Center describes stems cells as, “an unspecialized cell that has yet to “decide” what type of adult cell they’ll be,” (What Are Stem Cells). This idea drives the research of biologists and medical professions because it grants them the opportunity to improve degenerative diseases and aid to new finds of medicine. Although many doctors believe stem cells could potentially help solve many of todays medical mysteries, a vast number of the population believe that stem cell research is highly unethical. People find stem cell research to be unethical because its research involves destroying human embryos. Essentially, there are three types of stem cell research: Adult Stem Cells (ASC), Induced Pluripotent Stem …show more content…
James Till and Ernest McCulloch published, Radiation Research, “which proved the existence of stem cells: cells that can self-renew repeatedly for various uses,” (Timeline). Due to this discovery, physicians and researchers believed that they had found the tool to help them solve many of the medical mysteries. However, it wasn’t long until the U.S. government decided to regulate their practices. Human embryonic stem cells and government policy intertwined after the Supreme Court ruling of Roe v. Wade. After the court ruled that abortion was between a woman and her doctor, “the U.S. government banned use of federal funds for research on embryos, fetuses and embryonic or fetal tissue, while permitting largely unregulated research in the private sector,” (Wertz). Due to the lack of funds by the government, medical research was limited and was not able to progress forward in test trials or determining the researches capability. Congress went as far as even creating The Dickey-Wicker Amendment of 1996, which furthermore, “prohibited the creation of a human embryo to be destroyed, discarded or knowingly subjected to risk of injury or death,” (Timeline). Yet in August of 2000, the National Institutes of Health compiled its final guidelines for funding human embryonic stem cell research, explicating writing to, “promise new treatment and possible cure for debilitating diseases and injuries,” (NIH News). The establishment of these rules have caused for embryonic stem cell research to remain an issue under the federal level. Such as how California and New Jersey allocates funding for the project in 2005 but how reports distinguish that only a certain amount of trials under federal funding were ethical under Bush’s administration. In terms of politics, it shows how the federal government is lacking in its duty to come up with a common solution. The more involved the government gets, whether it favors the interest of some

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Stem cell research brings a lot of controversy because of the wide range of ways stem cells can be used in research. There are those who support and oppose stem cell research. Stem cell research is currently used to cure cell mutations that could lead to cancers; however, this research could potentially lead to dangerous, unethical experimentation. Using any stem cells to propagate differentiated human cells, tissues, or organs should be prohibited because these embryos are alive, and scientists do not fully know the effects of this research. Scientific background: According to the American Journal of Health Education, “Stem cells are template cells found throughout the body that can grow to become cells with specialized functions” (Eve,…

    • 2551 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Overview Stem cell therapies are not new; Doctors have been treating patients with bone marrow stem cell transplants since the 1970s. The controversy raised about 20 years ago when they learned how to remove stem cells from human embryos 1 Moral claims made concerning embryonic stem cells research relates to human rights, medical benefits, policies and laws, and religion’s opinion. Research councils support the stem cell research because of its great values and benefits from the expected resulting therapies. Policy makers were opposing it e.g. the Congress of United States stopped the federal fund , because destruction of the embryo was likened to the abortion which was banned in 1973.…

    • 1297 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The stem cells or embryonic cells “can be harvested for treatment use from the cellular blastocyst. The harvesting or “stealing” of these cells results in the end of life for the “innocent human beings.”’(Siegel, Andrew). When it comes to stem cell use and where they are acquired from is a big debate between many doctors, scientists and citizens. The real question is from who, what, why, and legal and many people believe that it should be legal due to a belief that conception is the creation of a life and using stem cells from an aborted fetus ruins that. ESCR (embryonic stem cell research) is argued to be a motive that is unfair as well as the debate on whether it should be declared illegal due to the possible death, pain and unfair treatment to all involved ("Ten Problems with Embryonic Stem Cell Research.").…

    • 1258 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This prohibition did not stop President George W. Bush and President Obama from relaxing this rule by funding research with newer stem cell lines. Those presidents had to distinguish between the un-fundable activities that actually create human embryonic stem cells and the fundable activities that use those cells (Power, C., & Rasko, J. J., 2011). The stem cell controversy is still as heated as ever because each side claims the moral high ground. One side defends the rights of the most vulnerable and the other promotes research that may one day help to save countless lives, a real compromise is not possible.…

    • 1057 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The debate from the public is normally more for the NO side of things, saying that it’s unhuman or against nature or its going to become cloning. Professor tony Perry has a debate saying that “there are diseases coded in DNA that are cause by cloning”, some parents will say “I don’t want my children to have these defects”. The UK Medical research council has many spokesmen that are saying testing the embryo at IVF for diseases could be the best way to prevent the Designer babies from getting the disease. The government in the UK are going in deep to decide what to do about the designer baby problems and the positive points also. Hugh Whitehall told the BBC that“.…

    • 1424 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Planned Parenthood Essay

    • 1072 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In an article discussing the videos it’s stated, “Many, including Planned Parenthood, have said the video was heavily edited and is misleading. They say Nucatola was discussing a standard, legal procedure for providing fetal tissue for scientific research, for which clinics are often reimbursed for costs associated with procuring the tissue (as opposed to selling tissue for a profit).”(Carroll). As stated in the quote, the use of fetal tissue for research is perfectly legal with the patients consent, and why not use the otherwise wasted human life, to procure some good in using it for medical research? The out roar over these doctored…

    • 1072 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It is not right to defund an organization that does much more than abortions, but also helps control the spread of disease, does breast exams, pregnancy prevention, and STI testing and treatment as well as pap smears, which is something that no one disputes. In defense of Planned Parenthood abortion seller’s tried to change the subject with a new talking point, which was the values of research that is done on the remains of aborted babies. According to the Lozier Institute, this is also is a controversial topic because they…

    • 1057 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Medical research has reached a point where it causes controversy and this is not the first time that a controversy revolves around medical research. Animal research has and still causes arguments within the medical field as to know whether or not it is morally correct to use animals as test subjects in medical research. The latest debate in the field is about whether or not embryonic stem cell research is morally acceptable. As the name implies, embryonic stem cells come from embryos. Stem cells can be described as blank cells, which means that they have yet to be assigned a purpose; they can become any kind of cell.…

    • 1238 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In conclusion, there have been a vast amount of research and many test performed to find a cure for genetic disorders. A positive conclusion on this type therapy is how gene disorders can be stopped in passing them to the offsprings. But At the same time, there are many individuals who do not understand how important the knowledge of gene therapy actually is and also feel against changing who we are at the genetic level. Personally, I'm neutral in this topic and feel like this type of therapy would not be an option for me because I would not want my genes to be…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    These downfalls are considered to be religious sins and/or (IS THIS A THING?) opinions that deem the use of these regenerative cells unethical. There are three types of stem cells used in medical treatments today that display negative problems, which include Fetal Stem Cells, Cloned Human Embryonic Stem Cells, and Embryonic Stem Cells. The most common argument against the use of stem cells is that these cells are extracted from deceased fetuses, otherwise known as Fetal Stem Cells. The Texas Right to Life (2010) organization states in a study about different types of stem cells that, “Although fetal stem cell research does not cause the death of the unborn child (as the child is already deceased at the time of extraction), ethical consideration must be given to research that depends on the death of an unborn child (especially if that death is unnaturally induced)” (p. 1).…

    • 1543 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays