Embryonic Stem Cell Research: An Ethical Debate

Superior Essays
Ethical Examination
Overall, there is divergence in the opinions of the public, researchers, and politicians in regards to the ethics of embryonic stem cell research and the responsibility of policies in setting restrictions for what is legal and what is funded in this research. As already stated in this paper, the debate does not simple end with a simple explanation. Within the two sides of this debate there are six different ethical positions that are generally recognized. One, all utilization of human embryos for research is wrong (Greely, 2013). Two, surplus in-vitro embryos can be used, but additional ones cannot be made for the purpose of scientific research (Greely, 2013). Three, in-vitro embryos, but not cloned embryos can be made only
…show more content…
There are physical and psychological risks that are associated and are often overlooked. In caring for and educating these women, nurses play a vital role.
Physical risks that are associated in the process of acquisition of embryonic stem cells vary widely and have the potential to be life threatening. Ovarian stimulation is the most common way of obtaining the ova that are used and can result in ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome (Ellison & Meliker, 2011). This can result after utilizing hormone injections to stimulate the growth of ova in the ovaries. There are no preset doses of hormone that are used; instead, amounts of hormones used vary for every woman (Ellison & Meliker, 2011). An excess of the hormone can cause the ovaries to become painful and swollen. Complications can extend beyond the ovaries and can cause events such as heart attacks, strokes, renal failure, and potentially uterine cancer (Dondorp & De Wert, 2011). Although this is a rare disorder and only has an occurrence rate of 5 percent in women that undergo ovarian stimulation treatment, it still occurs and healthcare providers must still be prepared to care for this specific population (Ellison & Meliker, 2011). Additional complications are associated with surgical acquisition of the oocytes,
…show more content…
In any setting conducting thorough and frequent assessments are necessary and can make a difference in early detection of ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome and other complications. Monitoring laboratory diagnostic exams can give substantial information to nurses about the physical status of these patients. Building report with the patient can give insight on psychosocial status. Establishing nursing diagnosis along with nursing outcomes/planning help to give responsible and competent care. Educating women prior and during initial stages of in-vitro fertilization can make patient privy to ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome and/or surgical risks. This can be achieved by providing these patients with verbal and/or written supplemental material with information on the process and the risks. This could be by recommending the patient to do additional research with physicians or consulting with other professionals about the risk. Educating the patient about her options in regard to her extra ova or embryos ahead of time can help her prepare with any ethical questions she may have. Being informed can help patients feel empowered about their health and lives, and patients can confirm this verbally. Most importantly, these implementations help patients feel safe and certain about their care and

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Embryonic stem cells, which are different from the iPSCs described here, have faced roadblocks in the form of government defunding their research and the general population raising concerns about the morality of using embryos for research. They also faced challenges when scientists became too optimistic, and hoped the stem cells would prove effectively therapeutic, rather than just a means to perform drug tests. So far these attempts have failed in…

    • 1720 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “So much of medicine is about maintaining the status quo, but reproductive medicine exists to diagnose and treat the cases of infertility. I love that the end goal is to help men and women become parents,” she…

    • 469 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hyun, Insoo. "III. Embryonic Stem Cell Research." Bioethics. Ed.…

    • 922 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    All great leaps in our society have first met with some moral conflict. Scientists today are facing the use of embryonic stems cells and if their use takes away a human life. It has been proven this small group of specialized cells can treat many diseases that we have battled for some time. In the case of the embryonic stem cell research, it is almost impossible to respect both moral principles of respecting the value of a human life and to prevent or alleviate suffering. These two principles are what have created the debate on embryonic stem cell research and use.…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While stem cell research could provide a possible cure to a number of degenerative diseases, it is not ethical to harvest stem cells from human embryos because, there are alternative ways to obtain stem cells, and it is not ethical to destroy the potential for human life. In Stem Cells: An Insiders Guide Paul Knoepfler explains that the very definition of a stem cell is argued by scientist because many thing appear to function like stem cells but do not have the same genetic markers and visa versa (2). Knoepfler describes two essential features that a cell must posses to be considered a stem cell. The first is that is self-renews, or that it can undergo cell division and retain the exact properties of the parent cell (Knoepfler 3).…

    • 1898 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He warrants that since the embryo has not been implanted in the uterus, it is not a human being yet, therefore he justifies that there is nothing wrong with practicing on a cell that is not a human yet. He strongly backs up his warrant by using the morning after pill as an example of something that people use that is justifiable for treating a cell that is not a human yet either. The author asserts the moral views of the people that do not agree with the research, various times throughout his essay he uses morality and human rights to argue against the practice. Watts utilizes credible sources such as The National Bioethics Advisory Committee, to state their opinions on the rights of embryonic stem cells. They believe that the "blastocyst must be treated with respect appropriate to early human embryonic tissue, but is justifiable if it's used in research that aims to save or heal human life" (Watts, 460).…

    • 1069 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    While the scientific community often raves about the possibilities that embryonic stem cells pose for treatment of disease, most of the studies that have been performed using them have only shown minimal effectiveness. In fact, since these cells are totipotent and have not differentiated for any tissue type, these cells may not be good at detecting the environment they are placed in to know what kind of cell to become. Some researchers fear that these cells could actually be harmful if they do not become the correct cell type or if they do not stay in the location they were placed into (10). While these might simply be due to the lack of research using stem cells, it is not certain that these cells are actually as beneficial as they seem on first glance. If it turns out that these cells actually are not useful for treatments in the clinical setting, it would mean that numerous potential human lives were wasted for nothing.…

    • 1754 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How scientists gain access to stem cells is often a major concern to some of the general public, some of whom may erroneously believe that human embryos are grown specifically for the purposes of research; this is not the case, most embryonic stem cells used for research are donated from embryos that have been fertilised in vitro via in vitro fertilisation clinics and are no longer needed. The donors have to give their informed consent for their embryos to be used and the embryos are never taken from eggs fertilised within a woman’s body with no financial incentive being offered to the donor (Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research, 2006). These guidelines show that, the donor will know what is happening to their spare embryos, give consent and not be financially coerced into…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    That is to say, an embryo has interests and rights that must be respected by donors. Health practitioners, in the biotechnology field in general and medical laboratory science field particularly, are constantly under fire for ethical issues. Therefore, it poses a great challenge to innovate new solutions to combat the need to destroy an embryo for stem cell research and serves as motivation for scientists to think…

    • 433 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Nurses are part of health care in all the stages of life from preconception to death. Scientific advances in embryonic stem cell research have introduced new techniques of screening and diagnosis. These could affect us at any age and therefore nurses will be involved as care takers and patient advocates. Nurses will have to understand the ethical dilemmas and be prepared to help those involved with difficult decisions. Nurses represent all parties and act as advocates for every patient group…

    • 1830 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ovarian Remnant Syndrome

    • 644 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Everlasting Estrus “Sterilize”, “fix”, or “spay” are all synonyms to the seldom-heard term, ovariohysterectomy. As the name suggests, during surgery, the ovaries, along with the uterus, are carefully detached from the body wall (Flnk, 2014). This common procedure is performed on patients to aid in overpopulation as well as reduce the risk of uterine or mammary cancer (Why you should spay, 2014). Likewise, it is implemented in some instances to regulate behavioral issues, naturally seen throughout the estrous cycle. However, occasionally, the misconduct persists post-operation, which characterizes a disorder known as Ovarian Remnant Syndrome.…

    • 644 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Embryonic stem cell research is an ongoing controversial topic that is still a major issue today. It is a subject that starts a debate every moment it is brought up. This topic will continue throughout time to be a controversial subject. There is one thing that will not change in this topic and it is the facts that go along with it. Each side has an argument that has information to back it up but there are important factors that will remain the same.…

    • 1795 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Kaylen Silverberg, MD, was consulted by Forbes to help patients make informed and data-driven choices about IVF One of the goals of Texas Fertility Center is to help patients make informed decisions about IVF. As part of this goal, Kaylen Silverberg, MD, from our Austin fertility center spoke to Forbes contributor David Sable. The result of this conversation was an article about how to be a data-driven, informed IVF patient. There are several considerations that IVF patients must…

    • 476 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Aromatase Synthesis

    • 527 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Ovarian hyperstimulation, higher risks of multiple pregnancy, and the expence and frustration associated with cancelled cycles usually can be avoided by using a “low-slow” treatment regimen involving low doses (37.5-75 IU daily), small increments, and a longer duration of stimulation. HCG is administered to trigger ovum release, it leads to maturation of the oocyte, rupture of the follicle, and formation of the corpus luteum. The step-down regimen starts with the maximum recommended dose (150-225 IU daily), which is reduced gradually in order to promote continued development of only the more sensitive dominant follicle. Insulin resistant women may be less sensitive to gonadotropin stimulation. In such women, metformin treatment before and during gonadotropin stimulation can help to improve response, limit the number of smaller developing follicles13 and reduce the likelihood of cycle cancellation for excessive…

    • 527 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    These long-standing lines have accumulated multiple mutations, including several that can develop cancer (Lo and Parham). The research on these cells may cause deadly side effects if they are injected into humans for treatment purposes. Research on stem cells has been a continuing controversy since the first derived stem cells in 1998. Within less than 20 years, this field of study has faced numerous obstacles, including questionable moral values, money problems, and serious side effects. Stem cell research should not be conducted, and scientists should attempt to find cures and treatments by using other less harmful and costly…

    • 1520 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays