Iphone Ethical Dilemma

Decent Essays
Guan Wang
Business Forum
Business Ethic Assignment

Case1: Building a “backdoor” to the Iphone: An ethical dilemma
1 How to Recognize • Define the ethical dilemma from all perspectives. Is this an ethical dilemma? It is an ethical dilemma because the U.S. government and the FBI sought and demanded Apple’s help in unlocking the iPhone of a terrorist involved in a terrorist attack. FBI think Apple provide vital insights into the motives of the attack, as well as to provide crucial evidence regarding terrorist networks and activities. The FBI think that the new IOS software can help agents unlock the phone and access the information on it as a one-off case. However, the CEO Cook of Apple refused to acquiesce to the government’s demand, citing
…show more content…
3: pros: Without Apple’s company, FBI still can get terrorists’ information and get each location that they shown or trade.
Cons: Terrorists may find similar people to fake them or use different card to trade.
5.Decide the Implement Decision • Describe which alternative you will put into action and why. This should be well thought out In my point of view, I prefer the third one. Apple do not need to worry about customers’ privacy and still build their core value, they can keep a trust climate between customers and the company. On the other hand, FBI can obtain the information legally. In addition, it is easier for FBI to directly locate terrorists information rather than check a large Apple data. FBI also can obtain terrorists trading information and not only limited online activities. Thus, this is a better way to solve this problem.
6. Evaluate Consequences • Describe what you think was the outcome of the alternative you put into action. This should be well thought
…show more content…
In my alternative solution, it is a good way to solve because FBI can use this way like” God’s eye” to locate terrorists’ all the information. Thus, I think it is perfectly solve the ethical issue.

Case2: Maynard leigh Associates: Consultant Preneurs’ Dilemma of purpose or profit
1. How to Recognize • Define the ethical dilemma from all perspectives. Is this an ethical dilemma?
It is an ethical dilemma issue. The MLA company have faced a problem that either they compromise on their values or lose their current and potential business from their clients. They have problem on facing sacrifice their profits for reputation or make money more important than company core value.
2. Clarify the Facts • Describe four or more known facts in this case
Vipul Malhotra, an MLA employee, had delivered a workshop on presentation skills, telling Gupta and Arora that the workshop participants did not need the training and that the client has wasted its money.
MlA’s recruitment process was very rigorous. The firm hired people only when the candidates exhibited the organization’s values.
Gupta and Arora were caught off guard when they realized that the primary roadblock to the organization’s success was none other than the CEO

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Guessing the code incorrectly ten times is believed to erase the data on the phone (Lichtblau). The government has reached out to Apple INC. asking for their help. The government needs apple to create a back door into the iPhone so that they can take down the security wall and access the information on the phone safely. Apple has been reluctant to assist in this task stating that creating the software…

    • 571 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Pros And Cons Of Hacking

    • 434 Words
    • 2 Pages

    And my evidence is that only about 51% say that is should be unlocked and about 39% people say that they should not unlocked the phone. But the Apple company is like they should not give the software to the FBI but if they lose the case they will have to unlock the phone. But then the Apple company is have trouble with the FBI but the Apple company has some rules so that they will not unlock the phone. I wonder if the Apple company will still make a updated phone so that the FBI will not get in people phone any more. But I hope the FBI will leave the Apple compon alone and just find some hacker to open it.…

    • 434 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    With the FBI being professional, Apple could develop a technique that could be shared to enhance personal security while balancing private security. If those that are serving our country isn’t allowed to fully operate, unnecessary conflict will occur which will not only affect the U.S but become a worldwide problem. Terrorist are viewed as people that have given up their rights, therefore obtaining their information shouldn’t be questioned unless the company supports…

    • 1810 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Terrorism has been a threat to mankind, since many years. So, unlocking Farooq’s iPhone might definitely help the FBI team, to solve the Farooq’s case to some extent, in finding the true culprits responsible for the slaughter, at San Bernandino. 2. Unlocking an iPhone, which no one ever thought could be unlocked, could be considered another advancement in science. 3.…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Apple was resilient against the federal government for the protection of their users. The FBI unlawful overstepped boundaries as a government official. Vivek Wadhwa was quoted in “Apple-FBI battle over San Bernardino terror attack investigation: All the details” saying “Apple is obstructing law enforcement’s [investigation] and effectively aiding terrorists [since] they changed [their] technology” to purposely limit the access of the FBI. Apple has the right to change their intellectual property. Apple was enhancing their security to meet the growing demands of their users and to protect their information.…

    • 1293 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The FBI operates so they can get whatever they need from a company, whether it 's an encryption key or any additional needed information, they fail to keep in mind that these demands will deteriorate a majority of these companies customer’s privacy. In addition, the FBI has seemingly been aware that any backdoor operating system created would not only operate for this particular suspect 's IPhone. Source D, states “ Once created(backdoor operating system), the technique could be used over and over again, on any number of devices.”this means that once he FBI obtains this new IOS system, they would not have to ask for it again in another situation similar to…

    • 1143 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Iphone Ethical Analysis

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Opportunities and Threats that Apple Faces in the iPhone Privacy Fight According to a March 17, 2016 news article in the New York Times, “Apple Encryption Engineers, if Ordered to Unlock iPhone, Might Resist”, written by JOHN MARKOFF, KATIE BENNER and BRIAN X. CHEN, engineers of the Apple Company may refused to assist the F.B.I to unlock an iPhone, which used by a terrorist who attacked and killed in the San Bernardino, Calif., last December. The article emphasized Apple employees’ opposition to develop any software that weakens the security system of the iPhone because of data privacy concerns. The author believes that Apple employees’ personal value reflects the company culture, a belief that law enforcement authority should not over civil…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The attackers had an IPhone that the FBI believes should be unlocked because it may be storing information valuable to investigators. However, the phone is locked by sophisticated encryption software that Apple is refusing to remove due to many reasons. Apple agreeing to unlock the IPhone would help the FBI get leads on the…

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The loss of privacy has provided many companies to help the public keep their PII safe such as Lifelock a company invented by a former FBI identity theft agent. The usage of cryptography is a viable way to extract secret or confidential information in the case of US vs Snowden cryptography is how he was exposed as the source of this extraction of information, and the decrypting of this information allowed the US government to name him as the source which will in time become the information to convict him. The loss of privacy for the normal citizen has been comprised in this digital era, but the gain far outweighs what is…

    • 2226 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    James Comey, the FBI director, discussed that this problem should not be solved by a company that sells phones or by an agency that protects citizens but rather by the people their trying to protect. It should be up to the American people to choose what means more to them, security or privacy (Willens, 6). On the contrary, Apple believes that creating a back door could potentially cause the FBI to use that backdoor for evil. They would be allowed into anyone’s iPhone whether they were allowed to or not. Also, they could allow spyware onto users phones at any time.…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays