High School Leon Botstein Analysis

Improved Essays
High school, it can be a place where bright young minds blossom and where happiness and memories are shared but behind this façade high school isn’t exactly a bed of roses. Students are constantly preparing for standardized testing and once the test comes around more than half the students fail. Is an irrelevant test really a way to get students to move forward in their lives? Leon Botstein, President of Bard College believes that high school should be taken out in all its entirety. Botstein thinks that clichés are the major problem and that’s why high school should be erased, but is that really the major issue in High Schools these days? All students in America are required to go to school until old enough to drop out with permission from a legal guardian; would the dropout rate would be so high if students didn’t feel like they were a piece of data for school administrators to collect? high school used to be a …show more content…
Yes, high school has its issues like Standardized Testing but it is not useless. High school is a vital part of people lives, it’s where students create more social skills and mature into young intellectual adults. Botstein may have a point when he pronounces that clichés like the jocks, the attractive girls and the nerds dominate high school agendas; if you’re not a part of a cliché than you’re a loner but after all these years’ clichés aren’t as important as they used to be. In my school we just all go with the flow, there aren’t any distinct clichés. High school’s now a place where AP kids can be friends with a star football players, there is no radical divide between students anymore. Botstein is looking at schools from a standpoint of 1999, high school isn’t exactly what you see in the movies

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    In America, a general consensus exists around the idea that education is imperative to a successful future. This idea falls in line with the achievement ideology, the center of the fabled American dream. The achievement ideology states that if you work hard and try your best then the world is your oyster. However, when analyzing Jay MacLeod’s novel “Ain’t No Makin’ It”, the film Rize, and government statistics, it is clear that there are multiple significant flaws within America’s education system and how it plays into the achievement ideology and social reproduction. MacLeod’s novel tells the story of two groups of impoverished teenagers, nicknamed the Hallway Hangers and the Brothers.…

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The New York City Teacher of the Year, John Gatto, argues in “Against School- How public education cripples our kids today, and why” that the school system is taking advantage of the students mind. Gatto states that not everyone has to go to school in order to be successful, but the school system is enforcing that everyone must go to school. Education can be accomplished anywhere, according to Gatto, but schooling is tearing down peoples ability to think, also “dumbing down” society. John Gatto argues in “Against School-…

    • 1277 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Paramount Issues of High School What assets, features, and rules would the perfect high school have? In Leon Botstein’s article Let Teenagers Try Adulthood, Botstein calls out the issues of modern high school and claims that high school needs to be completely reinvented, offering many ideas as to how schools can better the education and experiences of their students such as having teenagers graduate at sixteen and ending harmful high school culture. Although Botstein makes some good points, the most important issues that need to be corrected to make American high schools more ideal are hiring more caring teachers, removing cliques and social class, and letting teenagers have more responsibility. Teachers are to schools what blood is to the body; schools cannot be schools without them.…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Jared Korotzer Professor Grady Writing 1 31 October 2014 For School In John Taylor Gatto’s essay, “Against School,” Gatto draws on his extensive experience as a teacher to argue that the American public education system does not exist to make students their personal best, but rather aims to create a large, manipulable work force incapable of challenging its government. This, he argues, is achieved by forcing authority on students from a young age, and then proceeding to breed each student for his or her specific role in society. While “Against School” does present an intriguing view of the modern education system, Gatto severely underestimates the value of the academic and social skills students learn by attending school.…

    • 1350 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One issue in the U.S education system is students struggle with school, money, racial tension, family problems, and teachers. Those struggles impact their education so they don’t finish high school. In this website, ctpost.com said that in 2013, there was a law passed that teen over 16 can drop out of school. The students struggle with school, money, racial tension, family problems, and teachers. That why many young students are dropping out school because of those issues.…

    • 1490 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Every student can fit into the one-size-fits-all model of standards, but not every student can fit into The One-Size-Fits-All Model of Standards. Every student is their own model of standards because every student has his own highs and lows and minimums and maximums. Limits to a student’s education in any topic that catches his attention is the cause of eventual boredom and declining motivation, which Davidson believes is the cause of students dropping out of school. In “Project Classroom Makeover,” Davidson details her visit to a middle school and highlights her observation of a young green-haired girl who sat absentmindedly while the other students fussed about Davidson’s appearance, both literally and figuratively. The young girl showed no desire to participate and even “[looked] defeated by school,” (61) but by the time she began to draw that all changed.…

    • 1597 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Society has a perception that high school is all about silly crushes and math test once in awhile. That was exactly what high school was for me, carefree and enjoyable. I had the same views until Kozol opened my eyes to this reality that not everyone is as fortunate as i…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Against School,” John Gatto argues that the main purpose of public schools and the educational system in general is to produce a “manageable” populace. Gatto argues that the current educational system does this by slowly acclimating students into certain habits, confirming students to certain rules, and implementing a certain mindset into students that makes them respond well to authority. All of these things that Gatto argues adds up to make a system for training a complaint workforce. Firstly, schools achieve what Gatto states their purpose is by acclimating students to how factories are organized and what working in a factory is like. Secondary, schools also accomplish Gattos argument by restricting the class choices of students and…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Laurence Steinberg article, “What’s Holding Back American Teenagers?” Steinberg talks about the importance of education and how there is a big problem we all aren’t seeing. We think the problem is making school more affordable which is an issue but it’s not the problem. Throughout time, many kids have improved in elementary and middle school by challenging themselves but when they get to high school it goes downhill. Adults think that the problem in the education system is providing affordable education to their kids, so the government gives them charter and public schools.…

    • 1034 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    High school is supposed to be some of the best moments of a kid’s life. In Mike Rose’s “I Just Wanna Be Average,” he talks about his experiences he encountered during his time on the vocational track, and while during college prep. Rhetorical appeals are efforts to persuade the reader by making them feel certain emotions. Rose informs his readers that the way the educational system ranks students has a drastic effect on whether they succeed or not. In Rose’s “I Just Wanna Be Average,” he uses ethical, logical, and emotional appeals to advance his claim to his…

    • 99 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He truthfully communicates the plight of the unrewarding roles of both the instructor and the instructed, while painting the sad setting of an outcast student’s life in school. In doing so, Leon Botstein principally reflects on the veritable circumstance that students so often fail to find their time in high school either worthwhile or…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Perhaps the single, most common answer to the question of the purpose of school is that it is to shape young minds in preparing them for the future. For some, school is where they go learn skills and techniques useful in the work world. For others, they are just forced to go to school, to be hassled with the burdens of overwhelming assignments, which deprive them of their ever so fulfilling social lives and other salient priorities. However, for the students in Crenshaw High School, school was a sanctuary, a safe haven; the only place where they felt accepted, worthy and optimistic. School was their only outlet where they could openly express themselves, especially in their English classes.…

    • 1567 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Everything now a day is based off number, whether it’s ones SAT scores, standardized test scores, or most importantly, ones GPA. College students, and even High school strive to reach a perfect four point zero semesters, or even acquire high honor roll. Unfortunately, according to John Taylor Gatto, and his article “Against School”, achieving that perfect semester, or making high honor roll, doesn’t always translate to receiving a honest education, but rather just schooling. On the other hand, Kristina Rizga, the author of the article “Everything you’ve heard about failing school is wrong” paints the picture of a non-fictional, academically bright character that lacks when it comes to standardize testing. Using Gatto as a basis of comparison,…

    • 969 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Oliver Clarke Should Students be able to Shape the TDSB Curriculum September 28th, 2015 Highschool, a place teenagers to develop important skills that they need for their journey into adulthood, whether it be grasping life 's basic fundamentals, establishing a connection to the laws of our society, and most of all, the skills for their future career, whether it 's something as simple as a librarian or as complicated as a brain surgeon, highschool is where it all begins, or at least where it should be begin. Giving students the power over their own curriculum is a critical step forwards in creating a highschool experience that is not only considerably more useful in helping students leave highschool with a career goal in mind,…

    • 1397 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Students of all types can be found on any high school campus. There are so many distinct types of high school students for example, there are the jocks and the popular and nerds and so on but each of them share a common type. There are three most common types of students: the overachievers, the slacker, and finally the average student. Each different type of student has their own characteristics of their ability for the amount of work they put in school, study habits, and their altitude toward school. The students’ characteristics they pertain not only affect them throughout high school, it may stick with them throughout life, which may or many not help them succeed.…

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays