High Commitment/Best Practice Model

Great Essays
For over a decade there has been significant debate on the concept of high commitment/ best practice model of Human Resource Management (HRM).The idea conceived in US academics and later spread to Britain claims that a particular bundle of Human Resources (HR) practices have the potential to enhance worker attitude and behaviour leading to lower level of absenteeism and labour turnover, ensuring better quality and customer service, thereby increasing organizational performance. The ultimate goal is achieved in higher profitability level. The components of high commitment/ best practice HRM are Employment security and internal labour markets, Selective hiring and sophisticated selection, Extensive training, learning and development, Employee …show more content…
(Marchington, 1999) asserted that decision-making and matters such as quality are taken care by the team leader rather than team members. Team working may not be implemented in true spirit and has high degree of failure. Employers may not delegate authority in real terms. Sinclair (1992: 612) writes of the ‘tyranny’ of the team ideology, more threatening in her view because it appears to offer benefits for all. She argues that ‘teams are frequently used to cover-up coercion under the pretense of maintaining cohesion; disguise conflict under the facade of consensus; and give autonomous decisions a codeterminist seal of approval’. Concerning the area of training and development the type of training provided was different. Factors such as quality and delivering it in the right manner are important. Truss et al. (1997: 61) concluded that even in organizations where training was provided it did not contribute to the developmental HRM perspective, as it did not enhance employee’s skill-set or enlarged their experience. As training does not assure future career development hence it cannot be exactly termed as best …show more content…
The idea of implementing best practices, though presented in a simplistic manner has been rather challenging. While what is “best” remains illusionary. The high commitment HRM practice claims when the HR bundle is applied it has positive impact on organizational performance. The link between the two has been identified and it’s ability of making a significant impact on organizational success. The argument whether or not best practice HRM really can make a difference to bottom line performance in all workplaces has been analyzed in the above article. We observed these practices have often been in conflict with each other, are not universally applicable and do not take into consideration feedback from employees for employees benefit. (Mick Marchington & Irena Grugulis). There is no evidence if there is any gain from them other than organizations goals, hence the position of employees is uncertain, and the employees’ motivation for the HR bundle is in

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Case Study: Draingo

    • 1397 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Given that analysis, how could you make the proposed reward system work better? One of the major issues present in Cooper’s solution is employees must feel that the level of effort they put into their job will result in reaching their performance goals. While the monetary reward is enticing, without proper training, the order processing clerks will find difficulty attaining their goals, and will not be motivated if they feel they lack sufficient knowledge to drive performance based on their efforts. The primary issue the plumbers and plumbers assistants face is related to the misallocation of resources to jobs. Since this is not an activity they even contribute to, their customer service performance cannot directly be attributed to their efforts.…

    • 1397 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    However, the planner failed to organise the useful materials to present to the potential funders. Missing out the statement of need and conclusion has made the proposal less persuasive to readers; no matter how thoughtful and seamless the proposal is, as it is directly…

    • 1856 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mintzberg Adhocracy

    • 895 Words
    • 4 Pages

    However, it is doubted by contingency factor which is explained by contingency theory that there is no one best way to perform a task due to different situation manager confronts and no approach is applicable across unique situations (Kumar and Sharma, 2000, p.83). Reasonably, if an organisation confronts different environments and situations, in order to achieve efficiency as the overall objective of organisation, its structure or workflow must be changed, corresponding to the situation as mentioned and to again find the best method to preserve organisational efficiency. For instance, when an organisation is just a start-up, units are not many and large, little specialization, formalization and hierarchy may be involved, but in Minzberg’s explanation, when it grows larger, it should have larger size and more unit differentiation, more elaborated structure, specialization of tasks and administrative components (Mintzberg, 1980, p.327). One similar example of changing the structure due to contingency factor is IBM, because of highly competitive computer industry, IBM decided to decentralize the power to low level of organisation and reduced redundant tasks to react more quickly and efficiently (Kumar and Sharma, 2000,…

    • 895 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While the new system could still have an emphasis on individuals and their performance, an added emphasis on team performance could lead teams to develop more innovative products and have a focused mission to accomplish in which they could be evaluated. Additionally, the legacy performance management system’s compensation system was designed to keep top talent by offering competitive salaries yet did not motivate employees to be top performers due to unfair merit increases amongst others in the organization. While the new system attempted to address this issue by offering performance related short- and long-term equity bonuses, abuses by management in giving inaccurate ratings such as rotating employees into the top categories or not rating high-performing newer employees negated this solution. This fear of giving feedback was identified in the legacy system but not fully addressed in the replacement system. Managers were still afraid to give accurate performance appraisals to employees and despite having an accountability system that attempted to reward successful implementation of the performance management system by managers with stock options, managers still avoided using the system correctly, thus still not properly motivating high performance from employees.…

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Bp Swot Analysis

    • 3377 Words
    • 14 Pages

    However, the article fails to discuss how signature processes can be successfully implemented. It assumes that if a company has a signature process, it is fulfilling the role that management has mandated. BP’s signature process was well-known but not fully enforced. In some ways, the article’s authors were naive, since they took the signature process at face value and failed to account for its implementation and other factors leading to superior performance. They relied on secondary sources and interviews with executives to identify the importance of signature processes and did not consider the reality of company culture.…

    • 3377 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    System errors happened when performance management system was used only to detect if the list of individuals KPIs have been achieved. But there was no match done between individuals and the organizational goals. Unfortunately, the system only monitors the input individuals have made, but no mechanism is used to monitor the output for the organizations. Sadly, the output produced for the organizations are influenced by the factors beyond the input given by the individuals. So, the performance management does not effectively focus on individuals.…

    • 2688 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The availability of major factors causes raters to focus on minor re-occurring factors. The self-fulfilling prophecies or expectations can possibly interfere with adequately evaluation an employee by causing the rater to see what he expects to see. The fundamental attribution error can cause a rater to blame others and fail to give credit when credit is deserved. Organizations can tailor a performance evaluation system that can eliminate or reduce these types of biases by conducting appropriate training with…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Theory Y has expectations on others to be successful. For Theory X, managers do not have confidence in motivating, hiring employees, and do not have a role to play in the success or failure of an employee. Theory Y, on the contrary, the opposite is very true and…

    • 716 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These issues can seem very minuscule, and often are overlooked. These issues fall along the process of not having a real training program for new hire employees. The big issue for the company and especially managers lies with the efficiency and productive output of employees work. Without an effective training program many employees are left without a real understanding of their expectations and work to complete. Also, with a misunderstanding of the real work to complete and expectations, employees then don 't produce the level of work to their max capabilities.…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Narcissist behavior provides no benefit for the individual nor does it assist them in being a better employee. What will suffer is the organization moving…

    • 1345 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays