Derrick Robie Research Paper

Improved Essays
Look at whole picture when determining release status
The death of Derrick Robie, 4, shocked residents of Steuben County, New York in the summer of 1993. There is no doubt his death was horrific and violent; he was strangled and sodomized, which implies his attacker was filled with rage and hatred.
Eric M. Smith, now 24, was eventually charged and convicted with the crime that he committed at the age of 13. He was sentenced to the max sentence at the time for second-degree murder, which was a minimum of nine years to life in prison.
Smith is now up for parole — again.
We hope the parole board at Clinton Correctional will consider the totality of this young man’s life, and not just the crime, as they decide the fate of his parole status.
According to the Campaign for Youth Justice, studies have shown the brains of teenagers are still developing and that they function quite differently than those of adults. The brains of adolescents are still maturing and lack decision-making abilities, thought processing and the ability to understand the consequences of their actions.
…show more content…
Their brains are under construction.
Teenagers are trying to handle society, peer pressure, impulsiveness and maybe even a lack of direction; and in the case of Smith, he endured most of these things including bullying and other mental issues. This is why we don’t let 13-year-olds drive cars, join the military, get married, and register to carry a concealed handgun or even purchase

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Bloodsworth Case Study

    • 255 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In 1984 Kirk Bloodsworth, a former Marine who later transferred to becoming a local waterman was the first person to be sentenced to death then exonerated due to first degree murder, sexual assault and rape. A nine year old girl was found dead in a wooded secluded area, the evidence on the body suggested that she was sexually assaulted, raped, strangled and psychically abused with a rock. Bloodsworth, twenty two when he was wrongly convicted and served nine years in prison before he was released. Bloodsworth was arrested due to an anonymous telephone call stating the local police that he was seen with the nine year old girl, earlier that day, hours before her death. A witness identified the perpetrator by a sketch shown on television, the…

    • 255 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Frank Timmons Case Study

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Summary Frank Timmons lived in a large metropolitan city and was the second youngest of thirteen children. His parents divorced and some of his siblings say their dad Billy was strict but the house was peaceful, others say he was verbally abusive and an alcoholic. His mother, Loretta, died when he was 12. The older siblings, mainly Margaret, took care of the younger siblings, though Margaret has many issues mentally and emotionally from possible sexual abuse and could not maintain relationships and jobs and may have ended up like their father. Frank played sports in school but did not graduate high school.…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Juvenile crime is overwhelming throughout the country and most states have enacted laws allowing convicted juveniles to be tried as an adult and sentenced to death for serious crimes. This case addresses the issue of whether sentencing a youth to death for a crime he or she committed during the age of sixteen and seventeen is cruel and unusual punishment in violation On evening of January 7, 1981, in Jefferson County, Kentucky, Kevin Stanford, age 17 years and 4 months committed the murder of Barbel Poore. Stanford along with his accomplice constantly raped and sodomized Poore during and after their commission of a robbery at Checkers gasoline station located on Can Run Road. Afterwards Poore was driven to a secluded area where…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to the New York Times (2004) “On September 9, 1993, Christopher Simmons, 17, and Charles Benjamin, 15, broke into a trailer south of Fenton, Mo., just outside St. Louis. They woke Shirley Ann Crook, a 46-year-old truck driver who was inside, and proceeded to tie her up and cover her eyes and mouth with silver duct tape. They then put her in the back of her minivan, drove her to a railroad bridge and pushed her into the river below, where her body was found the next day. Simmons and Benjamin later confessed to the abduction and murder, which had netted them $6.” Simmons was tried, found guilty, and received the death penalty.…

    • 535 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Jalon Walker's Dilemmas

    • 227 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Eric Jalon Walker has been incarantaced for 2 years on December 29th 2017. This is Walker’s first time in prison. He acknowledges that it is his own bad decisions that has placed him the position he is in today. He is understanding that because of his decisions he will have to deal with the consequences that are life changing. He completely understands the pain he has caused the victim, their family and also his loved ones.…

    • 227 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example, Nathan Ybanez was 14 when he was sentenced for without parole for killing his mother because of years of sexual abuse. Nathan as stated, “I knew that it wasn't right, but I wasn't sure about my place in the whole area of what was going on with my family in the world in general. I'd kept apart from a lot of outside things,” Nate added. “These kind of things [sexual abuse] made me feel like I wish I could cut off my skin. That's how I feel.…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Merrefield may bring up good points, but he fails to address a huge problem. Where is the line drawn between juvenile and adult sentencing, and what psychological investigation is performed on these “delinquent” teens? The answer to that is unclear, and still is today. Many states have different laws and rules that decide where to set boundaries, and where childhood ends and adult criminal responsibility begins. For a crime like Sean’s, which if you read the article, you would know is not as severe or heinous as many other crimes, 10 years in prison is too much.…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This article is about whether or not a repeat juvenile offender’s history should be considered in a case now that he is an adult. Smith was sentenced as a four time offender in a breaking and entering due to the history he already had with the court system from his juvenile years; he did not think that this was fair due to the fact it was done before becoming an adult. I do agree with the court’s decision that Smith should serve current time plus what he is already been charged for previously while being an adult; the time should not be split, both sentences should be completed together. In my opinion, the major facts that lead to the judge’s sentencing decision were that Smith had twelve previous charges against him as a juvenile including seven felonies and three misdemeanors. This did not help him at all; all the judge could see was that he could not stay out of trouble and it seemed as though he did not learn from previous charges.…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Textual evidence indicates that teens cannot control their anger and it leads them to commit murder, an example can be found in an article published by Daily Mail where a “12-year-old boy murder his six-month-old baby brother by stabbing him 17 times… The mother told police the boy had not been at school that day as she had an argument with him” (Mail Online). The youngster also told police “I was in the room for a couple of minutes, I was among to her my brother by stabbing him 17 times” (Mail Online). From this article, it goes to show that juveniles are well aware of that they are going to do before they commit the crime, and the anger has control over him. This is true because Jennifer Jenkins wrote an article “On Punishment and Teen Killers,” where she stated, “As a high school teacher, I have worked lovingly with teens all my life and I understand how hard it is to accept the reality that a 16 or a 17 yearly is capable of forming such requisite criminal intent” (Jenkins, 4).…

    • 1533 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Teenagers are extremely susceptible, the people and environment they are around greatly influence their decisions. Many people make the argument that because research has proven that the brain is not fully developed until age 25 that is why juveniles should be given a second chance. In the article “On Punishment and Teen Killers” by Jennifer Jenkins, she states, “Both sides in the debate about JLWOP agree teens are being tried as adults and sentenced to prison for murder at alarming rates in the United States. But this actually disproved juvenile advocates’ reliance on the “underdeveloped brain” arguement. If brain development were the reason, then teens would kill at roughly the same rate all over the world.…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This becomes his opportunity to rehabilitate. However, he decides to continue murder, which only gets him caught, and qualified to life in prison. Further mental research also suggests that the juvenile will forget his crimes. In the article "Startling Finds on Teenage Brains," Paul Thompson reports that teenagers lose massive tissue on their brains, but it does not remove their ability to be responsible. As it restructures at a delicate movement with massive speed, "...teens need all the help they can get to steer their development into the right path" (Thompson 90).…

    • 1745 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Juveniles should not be tried as adults for it is wrong to hold adolescents, under the legal age, to adult standards. If children do not even receive the same rights as adults in the first place, it makes no sense to try them in adult court. These juveniles should have the opportunity to be rehabilitated in a positive manner, for they tend to come from troubled households and violent neighborhoods. In over half of the cases these troubled kids don’t know any different way than a life of crime when surrounded by both social and environmental factors that influence their delinquent actions. One must commemorate that juveniles are mentally underdeveloped, and still have time to innovate if their issues are dealt with precisely and accurately.…

    • 1310 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Juveniles and Life Sentences Do juveniles deserve mandatory life in prison for their crimes or should they have the opportunity to receive a second chance? In 2012, the Supreme Court ruled that mandatory life sentences for any crime are now illegal to give to juveniles meaning that juveniles are no longer allowed to serve mandatory life sentences in prison. This ruling is agreeable because juveniles are not fully developed, and it is unfair for juveniles to serve mandatory life sentences. Juveniles do not deserve life sentences because the teenage brain is not fully developed.…

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The prefrontal cortex is the region that adults rely on and is involved in high level cognitive functions, such as, decision making (Blakemore, 2011). In teens, decision-making and other cognitive skills is heavily relied on another region, known as the limbic system (Bessant, 2010). As a result to relying on their limbic system, teens are susceptible to being highly emotional and impulsive. This explains why they engage in high risk behavior, such as unprotected sex (Blakemore, 2011), for example, Juno engaged in unprotected sex and as a result became pregnant. Initially, she went to the clinic to terminate the pregnancy; this decision is another example of how teens usually have the urge to make life changing decisions without considering the possible outcomes.…

    • 2030 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many adults always think they know what is wrong and right for teenagers these days, but since a adults brain and a teenagers brain are so diversely different how can they. The brain that a teenager has is very different from an adults, for an adult's brain has matured greatly from recent years since an adult's brain is so diversely different why is it that adults have the right to tell teenagers what to and what not to do. Teenagers go threw many stages of thinking and adults do not know what to do because they think differently from a teen. Thinking for a teen is very different from an adults, for adults have many sections of the brain connected a bit more and have matured very greatly from their present years.…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays