Cross-Dressing Analysis

Improved Essays
In her article “Performing Genres: Sarah Edmonds’ Nurse and Spy and the Case of the Cross-Dressed Text”, Jane E. Schultz discusses the interconnection between the form and the content of Sarah Edmonds’s book Soldier, Nurse and Spy (1864). She begins with the general information about the text and proceeds to the phenomenon/issue of cross-dressing as the main distinction/characteristic of the given story.
According to Schultz, Edmonds’s book is one of the first stories of cross-dressed women during the American Civil War (73): it was published in 1864, during the War, and was sold in the quantity over 175,000 copies. The idea of cross-dressed women in American literature seems to be yet older; Edmonds book has such fictional antecedents as The
…show more content…
In the light of the fact that Edmonds’s story is a story of successful cross-dressing, Schultz explains/remarks/mentions that, during the Civil War, the medical examination for enlisting soldiers did not require undressing oneself, which, theoretically, made cross-dressing possible for women (74). In addition, Edmonds had already an experience of cross-dressing before the War started (74). Further, Schultz claims that the fact of cross-dressing concerns not only the main character, but also the story itself, which means that the story does not belong to some distinct genre, but combines the traits of the nursing narrative and historical narrative, transgressing the norms of both genres and forming/making some kind of a generic hybrid …show more content…
In this respect, Schultz introduces the theory of performativity of gender by Judith Butler’s: according to it, gender identity is instable and is learnt by each individual through observation of other members of the society (79–80). Accordingly, the success of all 11 of Edmonds’s disguises can be seen as the proof of the theory: the main character is able to perform the role of a man, because this role has particular prescriptions that are to be followed in order to be a man. According to Schulz, the war was an opportunity to experiment with or even reform the social order (80), because “during wars, … social identity is more fluid” (88). Certainly, it was appealing to women from all classes (80–81): cross-dressing seemed a way of assuming more powerful male roles and to escape from the prescriptions of femininity (81, 88). Schultz claims that Edmonds’s book provided the reading audience with a chance to experience the crossing of gender boarders without a penalty (80). Schultz mentions that the fact that the book belongs to the nursing narrative confers/lends it the air of respectability; moreover, it extends it also to the main character by moral ascribing character to all her actions

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    This gives a new perspective to look at the Civil War from by allowing readers to see that slavery was not condoned by all southerners. Along with specifying a certain person and place, “Southern Lady, Yankee Spy” also combines the problems and struggles of the American Civil War and the struggles of the Women’s Suffrage Movement. Elizabeth Van Lew was an abolitionist. Along with this, she was a women’s rights activist, challenging the reader’s concept of the Civil War, which would typically be thought of as very separate from the Women’s Suffrage Movement, by showing the relationships between the two events in American History. Overall, “Southern Lady, Yankee Spy” is an informative and well-articulated book and for the most part, it is not confusing.…

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Hi Mrs.Homberger I am having diffculty oraganizing my essay. I was gonna organize by charcter first by Nurse Ratched, then by Candy and sandy and then Billy's mother and cheif Bromden's mother. 1. I was gonna talk about Nurse Ratched becoming masculine in order to dominate men and control them.…

    • 294 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The American Revolutionary War is very much revered as a “man’s war”. The most recognizable figures from this era were mainly male, however there were several heroines involved in the story of how the United States came to be. Women were often overlooked as viable soldiers, their roles were mostly focused on the upkeep of the base. These jobs included being a laundry maid, waitress, and seamstress for the base residents that could afford it. These roles were neither glamorous nor glorious, and much like the female gender at the time, was looked down upon as unimportant.…

    • 1522 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In literature, the role and function of women varies depending on the author. Particularly in the past, there were playwrights who portrayed women as frail, passive figures to be only used as pawns for mistreatment from men. We can see this portrayal in William Shakespeare’s, Hamlet, as well as Arthur Miller’s, Death of a Salesman. The female characters in these two plays are to be considered as two-dimensional characters that only serve to help develop their male counterparts character. However, a closer study reveals that the true roles these female characters took on had purpose; for some, they were the most prominent characters of the play.…

    • 106 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Hannah Webster Foster elaborates on gender expectations in her novel, “The Coquette”. The main characters Eliza Wharton and Major Sanford are examples of how society is very strict on gender norms. For example, from birth society is quick to picture an infant male with the color blue and a female infant with the color pink. This shows how men and women are socialized from birth. The novel also explains how men and women have double standards.…

    • 1106 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Contrasts and Evaluations of Namaste and Butler’s Approaches to Violence against Transwomen In “Undoing Theory, The ‘Transgender Question’ and the Epistemic Violence of Anglo-American Feminist Theory”, Viviane Namaste (2009) examines the impacts of feminist knowledge production on transgender lives, specifically looking at the ways in which Judith Butler’s theories frame violence against transwomen. Indeed, in doing so, Namaste astutely points out that Butler fails to recognize the complexity of this issue as she is blinded by gender primacy (2009, p. 18). However, although this conclusion is enlightening, Namaste’s own analysis of violence against transwomen is quite superficial as it largely relies predominantly on the concept of labor. Although…

    • 1543 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This intrusion only serves to further enhance the already immense gender stereotypes of the 1950s. Through the perspective of Jeff, the audience is led to perceive a rather promiscuous woman, namely ‘Miss Torso’ and a rather melancholic character, ‘Miss Lonelyhearts’. Jeff simply assigns the female characters labels which could be viewed as further oppressing the female population. In contrast, the connotations of the male characters - ‘The Composer’ and ‘Thorwald’ are rather neutral and inconspicuous in the sense that they bare no negative alternative meaning. In reference to the male characters, the lack of pronouns within their labels segregates them from their gender.…

    • 1121 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Identity Change as a Result of Cancer Illness is a challenge that can take over many aspects of one’s life resulting in a change in identity. As seen in Margaret Edson’s play Wit, the main character Vivian Bearing is forced to face the traumatic experience that comes along with cancer. Vivian’s circumstances make it very easy to understand the many ways identity may be altered when dealing with a difficult situation.…

    • 1576 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Sweet Girl Graduate by Sarah Curzon focuses on this specific representation of gender where the heroine of the play is attempting to comply to societal norms by cross-dressing in order to receive a higher education. The heroine is obliging to the gender hierarchy that exists, and as a result, this portrays the heroine as someone who is attempting to break away from male dominance, while at the same time accepting it as women were expected to. The representation of gender roles in The Sweet Girl Graduate creates a contradictory perception of what women are meant to achieve in the play, and this is due to the portrayal of the heroine as a free individual; however, at the same time she is subjected to follow the status quo forced…

    • 1089 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is a known fact that both men and women had different tasks in society. In both plays “A Doll’s House” and “Trifles”, it is obvious how women are not treated as equals by the men. The play “A Doll’s House”, which takes place in a small town in Norway, tells the “happy” life of Nora and her husband, Trovald. Then the other play “Trifles”, which takes place in Nebraska, USA, tells how the men, and the women accompanying them react differently to the life the murder suspect lived. Even though these two plays are in different continents, it is easily noticeable how men look down on women.…

    • 1194 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “A Few Words About Breasts” by Nora Ephron The essay that was my personal favourite was “A Few Words About Breasts” which was published in the magazine Esquire by Nora Ephron in 1975. This essay was about an androgynous woman named Nora who writes a series of anecdotes about her struggles of being flat chested throughout her childhood, adolescence, and adulthood. During her childhood and adolescence, women with bigger busts, and more “girly” qualities were considered to be “real women”. This impacted her so much that she did not feel like a female anymore and pretended to be someone who she is not for many years. She faked her periods and cramps, and tried “do it yourself” home remedies which suggested that you can make your breasts grow by various ways such as splashing cold…

    • 659 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The roles of women reflected in the late nineteenth century up until the 1960’s were known to be portrayals of the perfect housewife or of one who lacked status. Jamaica Kincaid’s “Girl” and Kate Chopin’s “The Story of an Hour” both represent the gender role that was expected of woman in their time period and their restrictions to having their own identity. Mrs. Mallard and Girl are similar because they both lack their own true identity and have expectations from others as to how they should act and who they should be. A common theme shown in both stories is repression.…

    • 1265 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Two important works that are good examples of traditional gender roles are Susan Glaspell ’s play Trifles and Lynn Nottage’s play Poof. On the surface, these plays don’t seem to have very much in common; a closer look, however, reveals that both plays show similar themes and issues. The issues highlighted in both plays are suppression of women and ramifications of society.…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The early 1900’s were dramatically different from the current time period. World War I was held on a large scale at the time, but there was a more domestic issue at hand--the role of a woman. In her play Trifles, Susan Glaspell writes in relation to the current issue around her own everyday life. The role of a woman is told through a captivating story and a profound setting that is used to draw in her audience from the start. Glaspell focuses on the setting to reveal her story by applying character work, theme, and symbolism.…

    • 766 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gender identity creates a distinction in order to create a sort of understanding between the “inherently untidy experiences” of sex (2549). In other words, a recognizable and common western boy is a boy because he commonly doesn’t wear skirts. Butler identifies that “Drag illuminates the distinctions between all states that are falsely naturalized as a unity through the regulatory function of heterosexual coherence” (2550). The gender behavior that an individual presents publicly and internally provides a baseline and a source of understanding for harmonic social interaction. The process of developing a gender identity coherent with anatomical sex functions as an identifier for an individual.…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays