The Sweet Girl Graduate Analysis

Improved Essays
Works Cited
Bird, Kym. “Leaping into the Breeches: Liberal Feminism and Cross Dressing in Sarah Anne Curzon's "The Sweet Girl Graduate."” Australasian Drama Studies, 1996. ProQuest. Web.

Bird’s article focuses on female cross dressing in Canadian theatre through Sarah Anne Curzon’s protagonist, Kate from the Sweet Girl Graduate. Bird suggests that female cross dressing is a mechanism used to critique male sexuality and expose the socially constructed relationships between sex and gender. Bird infers that cross dressing as a female to male is viewed as a mechanism for the greater good of women (173). Apart from the gender constructs, through close readings, Bird analyzes the primary symbols of masculinity and femininity through aspects of apparel
…show more content…
She suggests that drag queens behave in a way that illuminates different forms of ‘hyper femininity’ (656). Hyper femininity is explained as an “exaggerated adherence to stereotypic feminine gender role” (656). The choices that the drag queens make based on appearance, such as wearing a wig or putting on lipstick, are examples of hyper femininity performed by drag queens. Greaf states that gender is an act that everyone performs and those who identify with similar genders will have similar experiences. In addition, Greaf explains how drag queens are treated as female while in their personas and will have similar experiences as women living in a patriarchal society. Consequently, when a drag queen removes her persona, the male is re-entered into society with the expected treatment that a male would have within …show more content…
They note that females who cross dress usually have the intention of attaining male behaviours. Whereas, males who dress as women are seen as individuals that are seeking pleasure for erotic purposes (4). In order for all the readers to have the same understanding, the authors defined and explained the origin of the term ‘drag.’ Based on the author’s research, there is a strong relationship between the gendered performer and their gender identity (7). The authors explain how being a drag offers a limit to hegemonic masculinity because this view depicts men as superior to women. However, a male dressing as a woman contradicts hegemonic masculinity because they are representing themselves as their subordinates, females (7). Schacht and Underwood’s study on drags has some correlation with Kym Bird’s study of female cross dressing. Both articles conclude that females who cross dress as men do so in order to take on the behaviours and perks of being a man. These sources in combination provide a stronger support for my argument, indicating that women use cross dressing as a tool to acquire male behaviour and power. Furthermore, Schact and Underwood’s article will be used to distinguish the different motivations for a male or a female to cross dress and how it differs to be a

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The book displays that certain plays reveal ambivalence as they attempt to represent women as free individuals, but at the same time subject them to follow the male dominated status quo. Sangha 3 Derksen, Celeste. “Out of the Closet: Dramatic Works by Sarah Anne Curzon, Part Two: Re-dressing Gender Inequality: The Sweet Girl Graduate.” Theatre Research in Canada 15.2 (1994): Web. This article examines Sarah Curzon 's use of “closet drama” and gender inequality in The Sweet Girl Graduate. The main argument that the article presents is that of the importance of cross-dressing and how it played an important political role in progressing a women 's education.…

    • 1089 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The perception of “male” and “female” roles is based on the cultural depiction of the “husband as [a] breadwinner” (Anderson 658). The practice of raising males to believe that they are in charge brings up the question: what makes men consider that they have this power over women? According to sociologist Laverne Berkel and her associates, who explored how gender roles and beliefs establish violence against women, “positive relationships have been found between traditional sex role attitudes and negative attitudes towards women” (Berkel et al. 120). Berkel’s assertion accurately pinpoints the key reason as to why men act and think in a hostile manner towards their significant other.…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Benevolent Sexism

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Heterosexuality comes into play when understand how benevolent sexism and hostile sexism are combined to describe why women are viewed in such ambivalent ways. Men rely on women to achieve desired romantic relationships. In this case, the superior group is depending on the lesser for an intimate experience in life (Fiske and Glick 1996). This makes the women more superior in this situation. Some men may not find this suiting, causing hostile attitudes towards women.…

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sexualism In Advertising

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages

    These ads affect men and women’s minds, especially women’s, as it exposes them to advertising ideas that control their behavior and thoughts. The idea of women stereotypes has influenced dissatisfaction and anxiety about their bodies, clothes, and material goods. Through research and understanding, it can be seen that the sexualization and objectification of women is a harmful portrayal. If ads are unable to redefine female images, then women will continue to live in society where self-image and worth are dictated by unattainable deals, prolonged by male dominance. Ads could create a more positive environment for women through self-confidence, happiness, love, and an approved social status that wouldn’t defame woman in societal or gender…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Masculinity and Power Relation From urging women to behave like men by suiting up, to promising “promotions” to those who purchase advertised clothes, the “Man-up” commercials express an identity politics that favors and centers on male traits, stating women cannot be like men, and a power relation that subjects both genders. Butler and Foucault converse with each other through the presentation of this image, arguing whether a consensual subjection to a new form of individuality should be championed, and what are the possible technique women can adopt to combat their identities being subordinated. The phrase “man-up” implies there exists a prototype of being man. It is necessary to have a standard male figure in order…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The way they present themselves has a positive impact on how men react to them. Ironically, it is the women who is submissive to men in order to get into their circle, but is also the men in the end who becomes submissive to what women ultimately want in these stories. Both novels, however, examine the role of women and their authority over men in society; eventually, Shahrazad and Alysoun differ from each other, Shahrazad uses her ability of storytelling to save herself and other women from Shahriyar’s deranged murders, whereas Alysoun uses her helplessness in order to achieve supreme authority over her fifth husband. In The Thousand…

    • 1463 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Atwood successfully uses pathos and ethos argumentative points to bring attention to the hardships women face. The title is deceiving because the paper itself is not only about the body but of the actual person and the treatment women receive due to their superior male counterparts. She uses a dark pathos that bring about a sympathetic view to women. In one instance she refers to a woman as a body, not a person, when she states that “the basic Female Body comes with the following accessories” (Atwood), in which she then starts reciting common feminine items that are a associated with the sex. In all of the examples she gives it is more or less a dark tone due to the amount of moments she addresses the horrible issue of sexism.…

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A study by M. R. Dennis and A. D. Kunkel found that “gender stereotypes are common, culturewide beliefs about how men and women differ in personal qualities and characteristics” (156). Dennis and Kunkel presented testable evidence that gender stereotypes are something that is across many cultures and accentuates the differences between men and women. This is something that is not going to stop any time soon but there is knowledge about how it can work to a person’s advantage or disadvantage. A study by Stewart Page and Samantha Meretsky, found that “both men and women frequently endorse many stereotyped ideas about both genders” (29); however, studies have shown that “women view others, regardless of sex or position, as more qualified than do men” (Dennis, M. R. et. al.…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Bad Feminist Analysis

    • 1394 Words
    • 6 Pages

    If society were to get rid of raunch culture and stop making the objectification of women an acceptable practice, we would be one major step closer to gender equality. Society must also relieve itself of the labels it puts onto both genders. This pressure compels men to think that they need to objectify women to be accepted and compels women to think they need to accept it and participate in it to…

    • 1394 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This suggests that men are inherently more aroused by nudity than women, which is consistent with the Kinsey study. Yes, some of this difference likely stems from deeply ingrained cultural norms, but very real biological differences do exist between the two sexes, beyond just physical appearance. Hormone levels have a very real effect on the way the human mind works. That’s partially why Bordo’s argument that “perhaps too, heterosexual men could learn to be less uncomfortable offering themselves as sexual objects if they realized the pleasure women get from it” (197), is far from ideal. Is the objectifying men really the optimal way to address the culturally created disparities in arousal?…

    • 1286 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays