Namaste And Butler's Approaches To Violence Against Transwomen By Judith Butlern Summary

Great Essays
Contrasts and Evaluations of Namaste and Butler’s Approaches to Violence against Transwomen
In “Undoing Theory, The ‘Transgender Question’ and the Epistemic Violence of Anglo-American Feminist Theory”, Viviane Namaste (2009) examines the impacts of feminist knowledge production on transgender lives, specifically looking at the ways in which Judith Butler’s theories frame violence against transwomen. Indeed, in doing so, Namaste astutely points out that Butler fails to recognize the complexity of this issue as she is blinded by gender primacy (2009, p. 18). However, although this conclusion is enlightening, Namaste’s own analysis of violence against transwomen is quite superficial as it largely relies predominantly on the concept of labor. Although
…show more content…
Namaste attempts to complexify the simplistic notion of gender transgression as being the only factor explaining violence against transwomen by adding the factor of labor. Indeed, basing her claims on Mirha-Soleil Ross’s work, she explains that transwomen (particularly transsexual women of color) are frequently victims of such violence because of their prevalence in the sex work industry, whose workers face dehumanization and stigmatization (Namaste, 2009, p. 17). Although there must be an appreciation of Namaste’s problematization of violence against transwomen, her reflections are clouded by her shallow look at labor as she doesn’t delve into the power dynamics of gender which are enacted through sex …show more content…
As credible bearers of those attributes, however, genders can be rendered thoroughly and radically incredible” (1990, p.193). In other words, Butler seeks to radically resignify gender based on the illusion of an inner truth of gender (2009, p.186); she wants to abolish power relations that marginalize trans people, among others (by looking at the production of gender – and consequently, its abolition). We have to be clear, however, and specify that this deconstructing, theoretical approach to gender does not mean that feminist theory must not account for the lived experiences of people it studies; rather, a more holistic approach to gender must be promoted in order to bridge the gap between their theoretical explanations and the lived experiences of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The documentary, Not Criminally Responsible, follows the story of Sean Clifton, a man suffering from psychosis, depression, OCD and schizophrenia, who stabbed Julie Bouvier, outside of a Walmart. Clifton claims that the devil told him to stab the ‘prettiest girl he saw’. Julie Bouvier was a young woman about to get married, who was walking into a Walmart one evening in 1999. Abruptly, and without explanation, Clifton charges towards her and begins to stab her, screaming gendered insults at her, and exclaiming that she should “die, b***h”. The gendered insults, and underlying hostility that Clifton harbours towards women, due to a prior relationship that had gone bad, can be examined through the lens of feminist theory, which critiques gender…

    • 302 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Rahilly ‘Gender Truth Regime’ Rahilly (2015) adapts Foucalt’s concept of a ‘truth regime’ to explain the ideological prevalence of the gender binary in modern western society. She argues that at an individual, interactional, structural and ideological level, the notion of sex and gender being intertwined has a pervasive effect. Weaving this with West and Zimmerman’s (1987) concept of ‘doing gender,’ she likens parents’ resistance to the gender binary to Bernstein and De la Cruz’s (2009) description of Hapa activists’ challenging of the US monoracial truth regime. Both the monoracial and gender truth regime promote a discourse of erasure of that which defies binaries – mixed race and trans individuals, in this case.…

    • 2128 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The category of “women” used in a feminist context is rejected by Butler because it creates ground for over generalization, and thus, would misrepresent individuals of that category that leads to the public’s misinterpretation of them in turn. The language and wording used in which to supposedly unify a group of people with similar characteristics turn out to generate resistance and factionalization. The term “women” could hold certain meanings and be understood as something different at face value. As demonstrated in the early 1980s, the usage of “we” to group all women together created a backlash because women of colour did not identify with the term and did not find it suitable to be used to represent them. Since they believed that the term could only relate to white females, they were in…

    • 705 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    To drive home this thesis Skidmore uses the stories of four women who differ from Christine whether it be from class, race, heteronormativity, or all three in juxtaposition to the Jorgensen story of the “good transexual.” The story of Charlotte McLeod highlights the importance of class as well as respectable feminine behavior, both of which were exuded by Jorgensen, in the social perception of transgenders. SImilar to Jorgenson McLeod was white and a former G.I., but he had found it to be difficult so he left which had created this negative narrative living up to Christine’s standards. Her behavior was for the most part deemed unladylike due to the fact that she had gotten into some altercations with reporters. (Skidmore p.279) Charlotte was displaying manly behavior according to the press which did not fit into the mold of the middle class American female during the post war era.…

    • 1649 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The term “trans” has been a poorly explained throughout history due to “studies” claiming that mental diseases were the explanation of trans behaviors. Sandy Stone attempts to change the way trans are perceived by writing a manifesto. She also uses a few examples of real people along with addressing Janice Raymond. Ultimately, Stones manifesto forever changes the view of trans in society, but at what cost?…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After examining Butler’s through the lens of Stryker, it is obvious that Butler’s theories fail to account for the lived experience of gendered individuals. By seeing the gendered individual as purely performed, Butler disregards the gendered body, which Stryker argues is actually very important to appreciating a true analysis of gendered experience. Butler’s distinction between “performed” and “performative” is not fully developed. This can be partially linked to how complicated gender is, yet, she does not make a direct claim that gender is either performed or performative. Stryker might say that Butler managed to accomplish further complicating the subject in her effort to clarify the ways in which gender is performed and perceived by others.…

    • 252 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From this point that institutions rely too heavily on codified identities, leading them to re-identify populations in ways that counter individual’s meanings (124), all informed by a “politics of accommodation” that informs a “theoretical split…(that is) problematic in that they are unable to account for…(trans) subjectivities” (CITE). Valentine picks up this tension is the crafting of his own ethnography, an ‘impulse to open up transgender for both theoretical and political purposes, and the recognition that in some cases, the work of many of my activist informants aims to do just the opposite”…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Feminism constantly works to eliminate oppression, inequality and discrimination. A highly important tool used by feminists to do this that assesses differences among individuals in society which the author of “Feminisms Matters”, Victoria Bromley critiques is called intersectionality. Intersectionality enables one’s critical thinking about a person’s interconnected multiple identities and also goes into a deep investigation about how these identities are interwoven into society’s power structures as to discover the roots of inequality. This is accomplished by embarking into an in-depth analysis of the concepts of power, such as zero-sum, empowerment and hierarchies of privilege. As Bromley has thoroughly supported and emphasized, intersectionality…

    • 1291 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Beside Oneself: On the Limits of Sexual Autonomy, Judith Butler talks about the correct path to attain human rights in connection to autonomy and community. Butlers struggle finding the right balance between the two in order to achieve success in the political arena connects greatly with the ideas of Appiah in Race, Culture, Identity: Misunderstood Connections, and my own personal experiences with the law. Throughout Butler’s essay, she struggles with the concept of balancing autonomy and community when it comes to human rights. Butler discusses the struggling that is fighting for our rights early in her essay, and she brings attention to the paradox it creates: “We have an interesting political predicament, since most of the time when…

    • 2037 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Natasha Martin’s arrest shows that though we may live in a time that transgender identities are entering the cultural mainstream, transgender people who are not white and upper class still experience unique forms of oppression. The article begins by citing the various ways transgender people have received cultural attention, making it seem we live in an “enlightened” time. This progress did not, however, protect Natasha Martin from vulnerability to arrest because her oppression is interlocking at the intersection of her race, class, and gender as she is both hypersexualized and seen a deviant from hegemonic ideals. Black women experience hypersexualization that traces back to slavery, and there is stigma around transgender women that links them to sex work.…

    • 597 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She goes into how gender discourse is a “symbolic system” which means that no woman or man perfectly fits the roles they are given, nevertheless people’s…

    • 677 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout history, society has looked at the role of woman with a domestic and submissive perspective. Women were the property of men, and were there to pleasure him, bear his children, and relieve him of the domestic duties. Throughout time the role of women in society has evolved; however, women still struggle to have full control of their own bodies. As Adrienne Rich said (Of Women Born):"Women are controlled by lashing us to our bodies. " The theme of women being lashed to their bodies has been evident in America from the 1800’s until the 1970’s, as women have fought to gain the right to their own bodies and is still evident today as women continue to battle against patriarchal control of their bodies by the government and media.…

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Heidenreich article looks at the relationship between race and sexism. Heidenreich argues that there is harsher discrimination against queers of colour, and particularly those who cross gender lines. This is due to a broader discourse about queers of culture, which normalizes violence, dehumanizes queers of colour, and threatens masculinity norms. In the case study, the murder of transgender Latina youth Gwen Amber Rose is compared to the murder of Matthew Shepard. Heidenreich observes that there was very little attention paid to Gwen’s murder, while the murder of Matthew Shepard received a public outcry.…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    ‘“Night to His Day’: The Social Construction of Gender,” Judith Lorber’s article written in the mid 90s, describes western societies as having two genders: men and women. Lorber explains that, while they not wholly separate genders, transvestities and transexuals are “crossover genders” (2007: 43) floating in between society’s two genders. Society’s framework for gender affects everything a person does from the moment that person is born, without them even knowing it. The clothes a person wears, the friends a person makes, the job that person ultimately does or does not get: all affected by gender.…

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the book, Just One of the Guys?, Kristen Schilt examines transgender men’s experiences in the workplace. Schilt recognizes that men and women are treated differently in work environments, but the reasons for this are highly debated. By bringing transmen’s experiences into the light, Schilt hopes to provide solid evidence that gender is a social construct and that notions of gender as fixed and based on biology are inaccurate. Schilt also wants to show just how much gender inequality is present in institutions like the workplace. Transmen have a unique perspective due to their experiences as women and later as men.…

    • 1712 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays

Related Topics