Third Shift Case Study

Improved Essays
The Third Shift

The third shift at the Corpus Christi plant is not making its production goals. When the Coordinator or Winslow try to help the third shift, workers claim that they are going back on their promises.

The cause of this issue is that Winslow did not set a hard boundary line for the decisions that the Self Directed teams could take on as they matured. He did not expect them to set production goals for themselves or to be involved in developing and setting strategies for the entire plant but did not express this to the teams. The third shift team thought that their power was being compromised when the coordinator or Winslow offered help. There are several things that need to be done to remedy these issues.

First, Winslow needs
…show more content…
The intended role of the coordinator, as defined from the beginning of the experiment, was to change over time as the teams gained more and more knowledge and became more comfortable with the roles of SDT’s. The coordinator would move from a directive leadership style in the beginning to the delegate leadership style in the end. It is unreasonable to expect that the teams on all three shifts would progress at the same rate. As such, it would appear that the third shift team has not progressed to the point that the coordinator can use the delegating leadership style yet. They have shown significant progress by supplying process improvement ideas and maintaining a high standard of safety. In light of the Team’s progress and what they have accomplished to this point, I would put the progression of coordinator’s needed leadership style in the Supporting Style. In this style the leader talks with the team and listens to their ideas and suggestions to solve problems. In this instance, Winslow needs to have a meeting with the team and discuss with them why they feel they are not making the production goals and what they can do to fix it. He needs to share the decision making with the team so they do not feel that their power is being removed. The team needs to be informed what progress that they have made and what they still need to do in order for the coordinator to assume a delegating …show more content…
The improvements that we have recommended are critical in keeping the ball rolling in the implementation of SDT’s. Recognition of and feedback to the workers will fix a lot of the motivation and confusion problems that are going on among the workers. Letting the workers know how they are doing is the only way they can recognize when what they are doing is good or bad. Feedback should act as a guiding light to these workers while the recognition should let them know when they have reached a goal. The workers need to know that their jobs are not in jeopardy and that they actually have a great opportunity of promotion laid in front of them. Give them incentive as a team and they will function as a team. By giving the workers goals to strive toward, they can understand what is expected of them. The physical structure of the team is an issue that can be readily fixed. Restructuring the team into smaller groups will increase the team’s cohesiveness and self-accountability. Smaller groups are considerably more efficient and productive than larger groups. This will also decrease the turnover rate, as the workers within a smaller team will feel more important and less likely to let down the other members of the team by

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    An essential component to overcome a lack of commitment is to review the decision and how that affects each team member’s department. Further, it should be clearly stated how items should be communicated to each team member’s direct reports. By reviewing the various aspects of the decision it will assist in making sure each team member understands what is expected. Another important strategy is to incorporate deadlines and to develop emergency plans. Through establishing deadlines, it keeps the team on track. Further, developing emergency plans will give reluctant team members a safety net to aid in their buy-in. A leader must not be afraid to make the wrong decision. The other team members are looking to the leader to demonstrate confidence and the assurance that, if the decision is incorrect, everything will be…

    • 1450 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Identifying the difficulties that managers may be having in establishing self-directed, high-performing teams, first you have to look at the basics that include team building, having a clear purpose, problem solving, decision making, negotiation, setting goals, conflict, effective leaders, and proactive planning. All of these together help create a self-directed high preforming team, so you need to look at each of these to find out what problems you are experiencing in your teams and then assess what steps you need to take.…

    • 991 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    One important factor of cohesion is group size. Many studies have shown that small to moderate group sizes, 3 to 5 members, show the greatest level of cohesiveness (Crocker, 2016; Grieve et al., 2000; Yarmey, 2013). Furthermore, large groups are more prone to social loafing, which is a reduction in individual effort when people believe others will pull their weight (Crocker, 2016). Social loafing, and therefore large groups can have a negative effect on cohesiveness. A strategy used to combat this is to break up a large group into smaller groups (Yarmey, 2013). Not only does this promote cohesion on its own, but this technique also helps with communication, another factor that is indicative of cohesion. In Remember the Titans, Coach Boone uses this technique by pairing up the White and Black players and forcing them to room together. By placing them in close proximity, he is increasing the opportunity for communication between the players, and therefore creating cohesiveness among them (Crocker, 2016). Another factor of cohesiveness is homogeneity. The more homogenous a team is, the more cohesive they will be. However, this is not describing factors such as being homogenous in ethnicity, unlike the Titans, but more with being homogenous in aspects like personality, attitudes and aspirations, much like the Titans (van Vianen & De Dreu, 2001). As the only desegregated football team in the…

    • 1601 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Accountability, unity, and intentionality are fundamental elements of a successful team. All three of these elements are interdependent on each other, yet are significant on their own. For these elements to work, each member of a team must depend on each other’s contribution, but not rely on one member to do all the work. As well, an intentional goal must be set for all members to unify the same mentality. In my own experience with the Buckeye Twirl baton team, we fail to perform as a team and work as individuals. However in the midst of challenge, we are able to overcome with balance and unity through our individual contributions.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Their survival would not have been possible if not for teamwork and collaboration of the men which emerged after the shift supervisor Urzua, relinquishes his duty as the team leader.…

    • 1356 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Unfortunately, there have been several incidents on his squad that resulted in crew clock resets. Eliminating these deficiencies requires more oversight from Patterson and his supervisory staff. In the future encourage your shift supervisors to spend more time in the field vigilantly looking for any and all instances where procedures are not being followed as designed. This will hopefully eliminate procedural non-compliance issues, thus preventing crew clock resets. Work on your delivery methods to provide the correct communications when engaging your squad members, peers, and site personnel.…

    • 87 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To enhance the success of the group and the effectiveness of group performance in the inter-professional team, here are some group factors should be considered.…

    • 1060 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The driving forces must be strong enough to overcome the resisting forces for change to occur (Lindauer, 2015). As identified, a lack of communication and clear vision present one of the largest resisting forces. The leadership could more effectively communicate the state of the organization, planned changes, and the vision of the organization. Further, the leadership should encourage feedback and input from line personnel to improve engagement and use the expertise of the line employees in the decision-making process. The MSPAC must initiate operational practices that provide the greatest balance of service and cost containment. This could include an operational restructuring of bases and personnel assignments. Also, consideration for overtime is important, but a better understanding of the best allocation of employees could provide a greater benefit in the reduction of human resources…

    • 1110 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Preventive Teamwork

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The book provides specific examples of various teams found within an organization. Those examples are a helpful resource for any leader undertaking a team who lacks alignment in goals and values. Furthermore, examples are provided for groups who need to regain their teamwork skills. Each scenario is explained in detail with suggestions for reorganizing the unit to become effective again. The numerous companies mentioned in the book serve as proof in the author’s methods in creating effective teams. Therefore, there is validation in the methodology behind the concepts. Team Building is also an effective reference for those who do not want the leadership role but would like to be a proficient team member; since it is essential that leaders and followers have an overall understanding or view of the organization as a…

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Second Shift

    • 377 Words
    • 2 Pages

    This week’s chapter described the second shift, which involves the housework women complete after their first shift of paid employment. I first learned about the second shift in my intro to sociology class, it explained that women spend more time doing household chores than men. It is no surprise that often women focused on the private sphere as they were expected to clean and care for children. Whereas, men worked for wages in the public sphere to support their family financially. By doing this, men fulfilled their family obligations. This belief has been widely held for years, men feel a sense of completion if they can financially support his family, once this role has been fulfilled, the contribution to household chores was not expected.…

    • 377 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dick And Donna

    • 699 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Furthermore, with expectations spelled out and setting the standards for teamwork, it is likely that the contention between the managers will be significantly diminished, and Gene won't need to play arbitrator so regularly. As per Reader, Flin, and Cuthbertson (2011), viable group initiative is vital for guaranteeing group execution (p. 1689). As a result, there should be less fighting and more work that gets…

    • 699 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The group’s leader was selected haphazardly in the few minutes at the start of the lab. There was very limited time to select leader so the time constraint restricted our ability to find a suitable leader. The errors just trickle down from there. The roles were also selected with little thought. The group openly conversed with disregard to the roles on our name tags, a move that would hinder our ability to efficiently record and compile data. One group member wrote down all the data as the others recited their facts for each suspect. A logical organization structure is crucial to efficiency within the group as a whole. According to J.B. Carson, P.E. Tesluk, and J.A. Marrone, “Teams that establish shared leadership by effectively delegating it are more effective than teams with a traditional single-leader structure” (Robbins and Judge, 165). Despite distributing the name tags at the start of the lab, our group essentially treated each other on the same level of the group hierarchy. Decision making was problematic because no one was in a position to make an executive decision since we ignored roles. Decision making speed was poor, partly because of our inorganization but also because we didn’t have central leadership. When it came time to turn in the sheet with the final verdict, we were slow in comparison to other groups because there wasn’t an opinion with more power than others that would…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    One the of the immediate leadership issues outlined in the case is the lack of hierarchy. BP should have continued having multiple leaders sign off on a decision verses allowing a few BP project managers to choose the…

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    An effective team building requires appropriate organisational structure and significant individual contribution as prerequisites, and a consistent team process that pulls all team members together.…

    • 1791 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The organization succeeded in setting up a guiding coalition of six employees to compose the change team. The employees were responsible for developing and implementing additional ideas to the enforced change in the organization. The guiding coalition ensured a minimum mass member support to the change; the number should grow progressively to avoid being overtaken by the opposition that could in turn stop the change.…

    • 1161 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays