Authenticity Of A Child's Testimony Essay

Good Essays
Authenticity of a Child’s Testimony A child’s testimony is not very reliable, and is bound to be flawed. Due to their lack of age and experience in social intercourse, there are a lot of aspects of everyday scenarios that children just can’t grasp. For example, a child may not pick up on the subtle change in someone’s tone when they make a sarcastic remark; the child may take what that person said literally, and misinterpret the meaning behind what was said. Typically, children also have pretty active imaginations, which could lead to an anomaly in what they think they’ve experienced and what they’ve actually experienced. There are many things one should take into consideration when listening to a child. For one, they are like dogs in that a lot of the time they just want …show more content…
This desire for positive affection may cause the child’s story to stray from the facts or the actual events. The child will say what he thinks the adults want to hear, and in return be praised for his compliance. Another thing that should be taken into consideration is the fact that everyone, regardless of age, is capable of lying. If we can’t trust adults to tell the truth 100% of the time, how can we expect a child to do so? There’s also the fact that everyone has an opinion, and therefore a bias. A child could let his thoughts and opinions cloud his judgement; his testimony would no longer be objective, thus making it somewhat unreliable. Everything is open to interpretation, and everyone interprets things differently; how I see something is completely different than how my siblings see the same thing. A child’s interpretation of a course of events is likely to be different than the interpretation from an adult. It’s certain that there will be differences in the way other people recount the same events. I’m not saying that children can’t be trusted, or that they never tell the truth. In fact, a lot of children do tell the truth. However, their version of

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Meaning that they are able to differentiate between right and wrong. Even though many a time, they unable to control their urge to do something that is against what they were initially instructed not to do. They are able to self-evaluate their conduct and feel ashamed, and self-criticise whenever they do something wrong (Bussey, 1992).When they are in the early years such as 3, most children find it challenging to be consistent when telling a lie. They are unable to create a false belief in the mind of another person, and that can prove the misunderstanding of belief and false belief of when a child use deception (Talwar & Lee, 2008). Therefore, that is why most children turn to understand deception better depending on their age (Lee, 2013; Talwar & Lee, 2008).…

    • 2137 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Ingoldsby And Shaw Summary

    • 1193 Words
    • 5 Pages

    With the stress that is on the child, it can cause them to go through different stages of life they might not have to go through. In addition to this stress children don't show it like any other adult they have their own ways to show it. Bettelheim explains that children may show their stress by conflicting with their siblings and disobeying others.Shaw and Ingoldsby explained three problems; externalizing, internalizing and cognitive deficit, which each had their own characteristics and ways to be shown. Externalizing was basically described as the delinquency and disobedience that is shown. Internalizing is expressed as jealousy from not receiving as much attention from one parent as a child would like to receive.…

    • 1193 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Also incomplete information in the mind of the child promotes irrelevant thinking and fantasizing, which is wrong in the long run for the child. Let me quote one example here, a couple who has decided to separate, conceals this information from the child who is the worst impacted party. But the child senses, and asks questions for which he/she is not told the facts; or will be told the lies. Ultimately the child is going to know the facts, so why not make him aware at the right time, at the proper place. Let him face the facts and realize the situation.…

    • 957 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Learning and retaining new information can be challenging for anybody, as well as misplacing your wallet, forgetting important dates, and stressing out over big events. All of these can be difficult when there is a disorder impairing your thought process and preventing your ability to control concentration. In school, many children struggle with focusing, staying on task, bad behavior, hyperactivity, and more. While many of these children grow out of it, some cannot help but continue to act in an almost careless manner and are unable to change. Quite often, parents of children with ADHD do not notice that something is wrong and assume that they are merely disobeying them.…

    • 2346 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Winnie The Pooh Moral

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages

    People express themselves in many ways and children should know that it’s okay if they want to do something out of the ordinary. I feel that a lot of times parents don’t understand when their children are different, and their children realize this, so they change to be accepted. Children need to know that being yourself, and allowing others to do the same is what’s important. There are so many things in the world we don’t understand. There will be times you’ll see someone do something and it will confuse you.…

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    One of the ways communication is effected is by the inadvertent way ASD individuals may sound self-centered. As stated previous ASD individuals have a difficult time understanding all the words in a conversation and therefore react to only the ones they understand. When communicating with other people this causes ASD individuals to seem like they have no interest in whatever the topic of the conversation may be. This mixed with sometimes inability to maintain eye contact can lead to the miss-interpretation of self-centeredness. According to Susan stokes, Individuals with ASD have issues understanding the turn-taking aspect of communication and will frequently change topics in an unnatural way to something they want to talk about(1), further instilling the perceived ego-centric attitude.…

    • 1449 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    What is true for me mightn’t be true for someone else, because we have different perceptions. What makes different perceptions are different experiences that influence our way of thinking and our pattern of behaviour. if something happens here are always two sides to the same story. None of them however know the whole truth, in other words none of them is True. each story has only a small part of truth in it based on the perception of the involved party.…

    • 1384 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Forming relationships is tricky with neglected children because children are sometimes so neglected, they want to attach to anyone and anything (Kazdin, Moser, Colbus, Bell.,1985). This can be unsafe if the child attaches to someone who may potentially harm them. However, it is important for the child to form healthy attached relationships to continue down the right…

    • 1549 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Without allowing all ideas to be heard, people can easily fall into a false sense of security that what they believe is true because of the opinions of the majority. He knows that the popular opinion is not always correct, which is why we must allow freedom of speech and opinion. Mill sees the importance for all opinions to be heard so that the opportunity can arise for people to exchange error for truth. He believes that a person can only firmly believe something is true if it is able to withstand contraction and disapproval. This can only happen if there is liberty to criticize others opinions, if there is not liberty to do so, then we can lose the opportunity to challenge our…

    • 1816 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    There are times where we need to do what 's best for ourselves, such as the disaster that Sarah and her children are facing, and forget about everyone else for a while. I would assume that Sarah would certainly not follow this theory all the time because she would feel like that could make her a very selfish person. However, I found it most interesting because most of us are raised to be humble and honest. This theory almost seems to be the opposite of that. The textbook brings up the fact that most people would probably begin to resent you if you acted upon this theory all the time.…

    • 1270 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays