Arturo Garcia V. Mary Chavez Case Study

Decent Essays
To: Supervising Attorney
From: Heather Wells, Student
Date: January 31, 2016
Case: Arturo Garcia v Mary Chavez
Re: Child support modification
Statement of Assignment:
I have been asked to prepare a memorandum for you regarding the following questions
a. “Was it permissible for Ms. Chavez to unilaterally reduce support when the oldest child reached the age of majority?”
b. “What is the likelihood of the court granting a modification of child support due to Ms. Chavez’s change of occupation?
Issue:
Under Statutory Laws:
a. “NMSA § 28-6-1 (Repl. Pamp. 1991) (state of New Mexico) provides that the age of majority is reached when an individual turns 18 years old”,
b. “NMSA § 40-4-7 (Repl. Pamp. 1994)…Section F… ‘The court may modify and change any order in respect to . . . care, custody, maintenance . . . of the children whenever circumstances
…show more content…
In regards to the first question, no, when a child reaches “the age of majority”, this does not mean that one party can make a change to the order of child support of their own accord. Ms. Chavez did not request a modification to the order through the courts, but simply made the change herself. The case reference for this is Britton v. Britton, 100 N.M. 424, 671 P.2d 1135 (1983) even though the child support is terminated at the age of 18 it does not allow for the order to be automatically modified. It has to go through the courts.
b. In regards to the second question, no, just because she decided to change her life once again does not qualify her to make the choice to alter the child support payments of her own accord. She once again did not request a modification through the court but rather modified it herself. The case reference for this is Wolcott v. Wolcott, 105 N.M. 608, 735 P.2d 326 (Ct.App. 1987) which states that just because a person makes a life change that alters their ability to afford the ordered child support, does not mean that they can modify the child support order without the courts

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    SCOTT V. CARPANZANO United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit, 556 Fed. Appx 288 (2014) FACTS: Rick Scott deposited $2 million in an escrow account into Salvatore Carpanzano’s company. Because of his violation of the escrow agreement, his funds were withdrawn. Scott was not able to recover his money so filed a suit Salvatore Carpanzano, which included his daughter Carmela Carpanzano. Scott did not make any allegations on Carmela’s part.…

    • 339 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    QUESTION PRESENTED 

 Whether Kaleigh Cyprus committed transfer intent with respect to Jack pursuant to A.R.S. section 13-203(B)(1) and State v. Ramirez . The phone was thrown towards another person involve, identified as Helena. In result it ended up hitting Jack BRIEF ANSWER 

 Yes, Kaleigh did commit assault because her intention was to throw the phone to Helena and with respect to Jack, she was not intentionally throwing the phone at him. Since Jack ended up sitting in that location and turning his head it resulted in the phone hitting him.…

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Elridge V.: Case Study

    • 160 Words
    • 1 Pages

    The Elbridge’s divorced in 2010 and Mrs. Gwen Eldridge was awarded custody of their two minor children. Mr. Eldridge was ordered to make child support payments of $700 per month. He lost his job as an electrician in January of 2011 and was unemployed from that date through October of 2011. Upon which Mr. Eldridge received a job in his field as an electrician. Unfortunately, Mr. Eldridge did not make child support payments for the 10 months that he was unemployed.…

    • 160 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    R V Gonzales Case Study

    • 1517 Words
    • 7 Pages

    R v. Gonzales refers to a criminal case of a triple parricide by twenty year old Australian BOS: 28744455 Sef Gonzales which occurred on the 10th of July 2001. Sef’s motives for killing his father Teddy, Mother Mary Loiva and sister Clodine derived from his parent’s unattainable high expectations of him and his desire to financially benefit from their death. Having premeditated his crime, Sef entered Clodine’s room at 4pm armed with two kitchen knifes and a baseball bat and killed her. The cause of her death was the combined effect of the compression of her neck, the blunt force injuries and abdominal stab wounds. Sef’s mother arrived home an hour later and was ambushed in the living room by Sef, stabbing her multiple times, severing her windpipe.…

    • 1517 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Most recently, the Husband has filed an Urgent Motion for Pick-Up Order of Children and Motion for Contempt Against Wife for Her Interference with Husband’s Time-Sharing and Her Failure to Comply with the Agreed Order Establishing Temporary Parenting Plan and Time-Sharing on October 12, 2017 as the Wife has kept the children in Texas and away from the Husband for one…

    • 4573 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, held that the dispute over the primary agreement did not prohibit “an application for periodical payments” as it would not be fair on the basis of her contribution being the primary carer of the child; thus an award satisfying the need were settled upon. Therefore, the argument stands, with a change of circumstance a couple especially if there are children cannot be bound to stand by the agreement as it is unlikely the parties would have thought of the future. If one party decides to give up work to be the primary child carer, this would have a big impact on their earing capacity. As a result, even with a prenuptial agreement in place, the principle of fairness would be ignored; ultimately relying on the courts to interpret a suitable financial…

    • 1510 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article Preglimony, Shari Motro argues that the justice system or court system should develop a new framework to address the common relationship between individuals who conceive children out of wedlock. Motro feels like the current justice system is robbing women, she does not understand why a man who impregnates a woman has no obligation to help the woman he has impregnated with the costs related to the pregnancy until the baby is born. Our current laws only protect the baby and not the mother; She wants our legislators to make man financially responsible for the woman they impregnate. Motro acclaims what about the mother? For 9 months the mother is left to suffer alone, she does not understand why the law does not hold the father…

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ecomap and Genogram Relationship The following illustration demonstrates my surrounding neighborhood, which consist of a single parent household. The family is comprised of a recently divorced mother, S.W., and her two children, which are both school age boys, A.W. and B.W. Health promotion can be achieved through the establishment of daily routines and rituals because these are predictable patterns necessary for the health of the family as well as the health and wellbeing of children (Kaakinen, Cohelo, Steele, Tabacco, & Harmon Hanson, 2015). S.W. just finalized her divorce with the children’s father last year and has joint custody of the two boys. She remains in her current property while her ex-husband moved out of their home into…

    • 748 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Temporary Custody Next we will look at the temporary care agreement and how this system fails our children and their single parents who are addicts. First we will look at the time limit this act puts on a child’s custody: “(6) No temporary care agreement shall be made or extended so as to result in a child being in a society’s care and custody, for a period exceeding, (a) 12 months, if the child is less than 6 years of age on the day the agreement is entered into or extended; or (b) 24 months, if the child is 6 years of age or older on the day the agreement is entered into or extended. 1999, c. 2, s. 8 (2).”…

    • 1231 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Savitri Bhama

    • 470 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Plaintiff Savitri Bhama and defendant Rajendra Bhama were married until they got a divorce in 1977, they both are psychiatrists. While married they had two kids together. After the divorce custody of both kids was given to Savitri. Which led to a custody battle between the defendant and the plaintiff. In 1981, custody of both children was given to the defendant.…

    • 470 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Before the Child Support Enforcement Amendment came about in 1984, there were many fathers who refused to pay child support, especially divorced fathers, and judges had limitations against forcing fathers to make court ordered child support payments. In order to gain control of this problem the U.S. Congress created the Child Support Enforcement Amendment; this amendment gave structure, equal fairness for both parents, and enacted responsibility. The CSE program was established to help struggling single parents who are in need of assistance, and try to aid them to become self- sufficient. Moreover, the CSE program gave rights to states to provide income provisions for fining employers who refuse to withhold such payments.…

    • 153 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    For example, child support is a method commonly used when one of the two parents has full custody of a child and the other parent pays a specific amount to the full time parent to help support the needs of the…

    • 2567 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Father who fights for custody is rare, therefore many judges feel the father should be awarded custody for loving his children, or they assume that something is wrong with the mother. The mother and her children are being systemically impoverished, psychologically and legally harassed, and physically battered by the very father who is fighting for custody (Chesler, Phyllis1990). Society believe that some children are better off with their fathers. When non-custodial fathers are highly involved with their children’s learning, the children are more likely to get A's at all grade levels (NCES 2007-040). How many women do you know that pay child support?…

    • 1767 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction The case study involves Hernandez versus Texas this was a Mexican – American civil right case which was recorded as the first one. The case was listened by States Supreme Court this was after the Second World War. Historically it was around 1950. The case was involved murder the named Pete Hernandez who was a cotton picker was accused of killing Joe Espinosa. They were no Mexican who has served on the jury for more than twenty-five years.…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the State of Tennessee and just like any other state in the U.S, child support if a very controversial subject amongst many due to mainly one reason, the fairness of the courts between mother and father. Child support, a court ordered payment system, is comprised of a payment method made by the non-custodial parent to the second parent for the better benefit of the child or children. In the state of Tennessee, more often than not, custody automatically goes straight to the mother it seems. Personally, fathers get the short end of the stick when it comes to raising their children after the papers have been filed from personal experience with my own father and our family. Overall, looking into the child support system fathers should not be held accountable for child support and that it should be equally divided amongst the two involved parents and not be withheld with jail time for the result of missed finances.…

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays