Arguments Against Random Drug Testing

Improved Essays
We are debating the constitutionality of random, suspicionless drug testing of high school students who participate in extracurricular activities including sports, clubs and the band. The debate centres around the fourth amendment of the constitution, which is interpreted as the protector of unreasonable search and seizure, and warrantless search without probable cause. In our case study a high school football athlete was randomly screened for drug and alcohol use and failed the screening. He was removed from the football team and is at risk for losing his college scholarship. He has decided to sue under the basis that the school’s policy is in fact unconstitutional. In 1995, in the U.S. Supreme Court case, Vernonia v. Acton, the court upheld the school district policy that required students to consent to random drug testing to participate in school sports. The court argued against the fact that random drug testing was against …show more content…
In the Supreme Court case Vernonia v. Acton, they set forth that student drug testing should only be allowed in situations where the individual student is suspected, or where a particular group of students is demonstrated to have a level of drug use of epidemic proportions. Following the wording of the 4th Amendment of the Constitution, I believe that drug testing is definitely illegal. The crux of the argument lies within how you interpret the Constitution. If you believe the constitution can be interpreted very loosely then it is easy to say that drug testing is constitutional. If you are like me, and you believe in a more strict interpretation of the constitution, then it is obvious that drug testing violates the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    peer pressure, these teenagers tend to try new things and that's when illegal drug use enters. At first, of course teens will just try to use it as a form of stress…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Drug Testing All over the world teens are in danger. The danger has been around for hundreds of years. It takes different forms and shapes. The danger is drugs. There aren’t very many ideas or actions that are effective against drugs. One of these ideas is very controversial, but it prevents the drugs for sure. Student drug testing is the answer. Teens are being pressured into drugs every day. It is unavoidable in high school. Drug testing is an important repellant against drug use in schools. Many…

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    School District v. Acton (1994)- Random Drug Testing of High School Athletes. B. Facts of the case 1.The official investigation led to the discovery that high school athletes in the vernonia high school district participated in illicit drug use. School official were concerned that drug use increases the risk of sports related injury.Constantly, Vernonia school district of oregon adopted the student athletes drug policy which authorizes random urinalysis drug testing of its student athletes.The vernonia…

    • 680 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Great Essays