Argumentative Essay: The Broken Electoral College System

Improved Essays
How would you feel if your vote in deciding the next president of our country didn’t matter? Well, this is true for many people due to our broken Electoral College system of voting. I strongly feel that we should get rid of it for many reasons. My first reason is that it doesn’t give equal representation to certain states. My second reason is that it doesn’t match up with the popular votes that were taken by the people. This two reasons alone are more than enough to show this system needs to be fixed. My first reason is that representation is NOT equal; our founding fathers wanted everyone to be considered equal. Furthermore, its unequal in a way that most people would not expect, the smaller states have a larger say in who gets to be our president. One example of this would be the election data from 2010 comparing the states of Montana VS Illinois. Montana is a small state with a population of approx. 989,000 people and 3 electoral votes. That is approx. 329,000 people per electoral vote. In contrast to Illinois, a state with a population of approx. 12 million people and 20 electoral votes. That is an astonishing 600 thousand people per vote; almost double the vote worth of Montana. If you wanted your vote to count even more wouldn’t you go to Montana? Because some of us can’t take the trip to get what we rightfully were given …show more content…
The representation in the EC is broken. The popular votes don’t also don’t align with the Electoral College votes. In addition to all this, the system was based on the premise that we were not knowledgeable to make an informed decision on who our president should be. That fallacy is vastly outdated because we have channels devoted to seeing our state legislature at work. We are more than informed enough to make decisions regarding the future president of the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    All the effort that they went to in order to make sure that the president would not be elected based off of just popular votes would have gone to waste. They would probably fear that uneducated voters would be a large portion of the voter turnout. This may end up resulting in a president who may not have the best qualifications to serve as a leader for the…

    • 1995 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Every citizen’s vote should count in America, not just the votes of the partisan insiders in the Electoral College. The Electoral College was necessary when communications were poor, literacy was low, and voters lacked information about out-of-state figures, which is clearly no longer the case.” This quote by Representative Gene Green reveals the faults in our current presidential voting system and the need for it to change. It has been an example and a basis to newly formed democracies all over the world, but the election to choose our nation’s leader isn’t as fair as it seems. While every citizen’s voice is heard in the public polls, ultimately it’s the Electors’ votes that select the new president. Therefore, I believe that our election…

    • 1339 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The concept of a representative democracy is flawed and will continue to be flawed because someone’s opinion will be left out. This does not mean however, that representative democracy cannot work. Many countries, including the United States, have managed a representative government quite well. It is only now that people are talking about changing the system of representation because a state of gridlock is occurring. Both major political parties in the United States are refusing to work together to solve problems.…

    • 1459 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Being a Democrat, I was assigned to create a speech against this bill. One of the main points I made during my speech was the quality of the voters would drop (Shineman). This is not saying that certain people should not vote based on class, race, gender, or any other defining characteristic, though. This just means that the people who would vote just to get the money would be on average less informed than voters in the past. People who are uninformed about the potential presidents of our great nation will believe whatever the media says about them, and as most everyone in the United States knows, the media is full of half-truths and ,rarely, outright lies.…

    • 1311 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although I do agree with some opinions against the system when they state that it is not an equal manner in which to represent every individual vote in this country. The winner-take-all aspect that most states use prevents diversity and the recognition of the minority of that state. This is a major issue since most states are fastened to one party. On the other hand, I do agree with how the Electoral College prevents the voting of presidents by people who do not really know much about the candidates they are voting for. Sometimes people vote with their emotions, or even sometimes buy into propaganda.…

    • 974 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Why is that? It is because politicians don't believe that they hold a high enough electoral vote count. This being not only against the right to vote for the people of those smaller states, yet it merely shows how unjust and irrational the electoral college is. These smaller states plea to have a system that will allow them to have a vote that counts. The best way to achieve such a system would be by a nation wide popular vote.…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Patrick Henry said, in a speech to the Virginia ratifying convention, that he believed that America was too large and diverse to be ruled by one single government, and that any attempt at this kind of government would lead to tyranny. A similar speech in Pennsylvania stated that an extensive territory like the United States could be ruled only through a united confederation of republics. This summed up the feelings of many Americans at the time- they knew and trusted smaller state governments, and believed that a national government would be too distant. This was an understandable reaction. Americans had no experience with the governing of a country as large as the United States.…

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sources from Procon.org said, “If the election depended solely on the popular vote, then candidates could limit campaigning to heavily-populated areas or specific regions (Procon.org).” The candidates would not have to do as much campaigning because they would only be focused on the battleground states. Even though if the U.S only had the popular vote, all states would become battleground states because there would be no pledged delegates to put the final state vote in. The election process needs to be changed, there are several fixes that could be implemented into Congress to fix the electoral system in the United States. The Electoral College takes the power away from the citizens that they should have in a modern democracy, like voting directly for presidential candidates most importantly. According to Jerry Fresia, "None of our rights have been handed down; they have all been won through resistance.…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Electoral College is a system that contradicts that the people are the voices of the nation and should no longer be in effect for future elections. The United States is a nation that has a smooth, shiny exterior but in truth is deeply flawed in the many ways. The Electoral College is an example of what revokes what the Citizens of the United States of actually want.…

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We cannot just elect the president due to popular vote. This is because there is too much politics involved. States with a smaller population have more political power than in a direct election system. Since most of the low population states are Republican, electing a president by popular vote would drastically decrease the chances of the president being Republican. If we wanted to get rid of the Electoral College it would require a constitutional amendment.…

    • 1070 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays