A Critique Of Containment Analysis

Good Essays
Toward the end of the second world war, on April 12, 1945, the new, inexperienced Harry Truman progressed toward becoming president and instantly stood up to issues of baffling magnitude and complicated problem. The war had changed the balance of power in Europe, remove colonial empires and political disturbance within nations. One of the concerns was the broken down of the U.S wartime alliance with the Soviet Union. After the fall of Nazi’s regime, the Soviets were forcing their influence of communism and military control over the region. While the white house insisted that the European nation should follow the American path by open their minds the ideas about democracy and free trade business. In contrast, the Soviets were determined to …show more content…
He argues that The Truman Doctrine is completely misunderstood on many major points. Walter Lippmann debate that the policy is misjudging the Soviet believe and suggest that the American policy is a monstrosity. Lippman’s believed that these decisions will lead the war with the Soviet Union, as well as exaggerated the problem, military issues, and unnerve the American individuals by escalating the Cold War. Furthermore, Lippmann explained that what Soviet did was try to influence their own power toward the nation that was used to be part of their own nation like Belarus or Lithuania. He limited the threat and influence role of the …show more content…
Kennan, an American diplomat support the policy of containment. Kennan suggested that the American government should stop the influence of the Soviet in every way. Interestingly, both Lippmann and Kennan agreed that the Soviet power should be suppressed by the American power while at the same time rejected the ideas of goes a war with the Soviet. To many people the Cold War period was a huge winning success to the American side and theirs later generations, Since the arms race between the U.S and Soviet has brought to the high tension which led to the creation of the new technology era, space exploration and established the United States into a superpower nation and allies closer with the western nations and Japan. However, many critics include myself believe that this event lead to a series of the new modern issues such as the Korean and Vietnam War, China turn to communist and the nuclear weapons issues.

Kennan’s ideology was deliberately risky to the United States entering the war conflict with the Soviet. One of the problem was it gave the Soviet Union an advantage to pick the confrontation for the territories like Korea. In my opinion, Kennan’s ideology is less persuasive because in my opinion, the U.S government at the time was over exaggerated the upcoming power of the Soviet. In addition, Lippmann also points out that the containment policy did nothing but to scare their own American

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Stalin, who aimed to guarantee the security of the Soviet Union lead Russia to become the leading communist country. With their growing "sphere of influences", many fear their America would fall on the similar pattern. With this, president Truman was often blasted for being "too soft on communism." To the Americans, communism prevents the Wilsonian ideals of decolonized, demilitarized, democratized, and global peace. Thus the Cold War molded the society and economy to a tense standoff between different…

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Truman Doctrine

    • 1671 Words
    • 7 Pages

    [10] Should any single nation fall to communism, he feared, it would have a “domino” effect on its neighbors. Truman decided to leave the U.S. Army deployed in Central Europe, which blocked any invasion route for the Red Army to invade Western Europe. Stalin, in turn, saw American actions after the creation of the "containment" policy as aggressive and a threat to the Soviet Union. At the time the American government did not realize what the implication of their action would be. The infuriated Soviet Union responded in the future with the Berlin Blockade, COMECON, setting up of East Germany, the Soviet atom bomb, and the Warsaw…

    • 1671 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I believe his argument about colonialism is ironic and contradicting as he claims these two opposing statements. There can be many “what if” statements concerning the Cold War, but my belief is that America did ruin any trust that was held between Russia and the U.S. when they avoided telling the Soviets about the creating of an atomic bomb. I feel as though America did not have faith in Russia’s honesty, and wanted to avoid any attention towards the United States and the atomic bomb. Because the Soviet Union was in such ruins, why would they want to risk breaking forces when they needed it most? As expected, Russia went to large measures to protect themselves, and the United States saw this as a threat.…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Cold War was the fault on the Soviet Union an American policies. The Cold War was simply an opportunity for each country to try and prove its superiority and served no true purpose except as an outlet for each country to express its superiority. The Cold War the sole fault of Soviet and American policy, which lead to the arms race, the lack of solving territorial disputes, and the fear of loosing…

    • 1801 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Instead, the Soviet Union and communism was now an enemy and threat to U.S. interests. Due to these developments, hysteria or also known as the Red Scare was presented in both films. Specifically in Failsafe, it was the American duty to protect democratic society from the evil Communists. Prof. Groeteschele stated “And the Lord said, gentlemen, ‘He who is without sin, let him cast the first stone.’” And later states the question “Do you believe that Communism is not our mortal enemy?” Anyone who was against using everything possible to stop Communism was…

    • 1273 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When President Truman gave his iron curtain speech, he argued that the United States should support nations trying to resist the Soviet Union. Truman and his advisors developed a plan to provide financial aid to Europe to prevent communism and was seen by Stalin as suspicious. Truman’s intolerance and loyalty to his country caused him to make opposing foreign policy without regard to other nations. On the other hand, Stalin’s foreign policies created a lot of tension in the Cold War. His goal was to expand the influence of the Soviet Union and create a stumbling block of communist states to protect the Soviet Union from the United States.…

    • 304 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Defeating Communism

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Unfortunately, the United States indirectly caused the rise in Islamic terrorism by siding with the mujahedeen against the Soviets in Afghanistan and by continuously fighting the secular Saddam Hussein in the 1990’s. Once Arab nationalism lost its appeal, the new way to be “free from the West” became Islamic fundamentalism. While the real national interest of American security remained unchanged throughout the Cold War and into the 1990’s, American policy makers learned the dangers of focusing on only one enemy. Focusing all efforts against Communism allowed for the rise of Islamic fundamentalism, the new enemy of the United…

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The main cause of this war was that the Soviet Union wanted to impose its system of communist rule the world and as the United States did not like this system. Americans were getting atomic weapons which alter the Soviets. Both countries feared the attack of one or the other. The American President felt a grudge against Russian President Josef Stalin. The Soviets feared that America used to Western Europe as a base to attack the Soviet Union (Atkinson).…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Following the Korean War, the United States was convinced that more had to be done to combat communism. The goal had shifted slightly from simply containing communism, to pushing it back. Eisenhower proposed liberating countries under attack from communist ones, much like the Truman doctrine, but the plan failed. Unrest in Eastern Europe led to rebellions, but the United States refused to help the protesters, and the USSR quelled the unrest. Despite that, the United States increased its stockpile of nuclear weapons to be sure that the Soviets would be deterred from either bombing the US or invading Berlin, due to the theory of massive retaliation.…

    • 2134 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The U.S. also did not like the fact that the Soviet Union was trying to spread communism across the globe, because the U.S. followed a democracy. “Most significant, both sides feared that the other would win the 'war of ideas’” (Suri). Both superpowers also saw each other as a hostile threat; therefore, the U.S. tried to counter this threat…

    • 433 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays