A Critique Of Containment Analysis

Improved Essays
Toward the end of the second world war, on April 12, 1945, the new, inexperienced Harry Truman progressed toward becoming president and instantly stood up to issues of baffling magnitude and complicated problem. The war had changed the balance of power in Europe, remove colonial empires and political disturbance within nations. One of the concerns was the broken down of the U.S wartime alliance with the Soviet Union. After the fall of Nazi’s regime, the Soviets were forcing their influence of communism and military control over the region. While the white house insisted that the European nation should follow the American path by open their minds the ideas about democracy and free trade business. In contrast, the Soviets were determined to …show more content…
He argues that The Truman Doctrine is completely misunderstood on many major points. Walter Lippmann debate that the policy is misjudging the Soviet believe and suggest that the American policy is a monstrosity. Lippman’s believed that these decisions will lead the war with the Soviet Union, as well as exaggerated the problem, military issues, and unnerve the American individuals by escalating the Cold War. Furthermore, Lippmann explained that what Soviet did was try to influence their own power toward the nation that was used to be part of their own nation like Belarus or Lithuania. He limited the threat and influence role of the …show more content…
Kennan, an American diplomat support the policy of containment. Kennan suggested that the American government should stop the influence of the Soviet in every way. Interestingly, both Lippmann and Kennan agreed that the Soviet power should be suppressed by the American power while at the same time rejected the ideas of goes a war with the Soviet. To many people the Cold War period was a huge winning success to the American side and theirs later generations, Since the arms race between the U.S and Soviet has brought to the high tension which led to the creation of the new technology era, space exploration and established the United States into a superpower nation and allies closer with the western nations and Japan. However, many critics include myself believe that this event lead to a series of the new modern issues such as the Korean and Vietnam War, China turn to communist and the nuclear weapons issues.

Kennan’s ideology was deliberately risky to the United States entering the war conflict with the Soviet. One of the problem was it gave the Soviet Union an advantage to pick the confrontation for the territories like Korea. In my opinion, Kennan’s ideology is less persuasive because in my opinion, the U.S government at the time was over exaggerated the upcoming power of the Soviet. In addition, Lippmann also points out that the containment policy did nothing but to scare their own American

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Kennan used the Soviet Union of why communism must be contained. He stated that the Soviet Union is negative and destructive and they want to spread their global influence and policies. He claims that they will not stop the spread of communism until they are the dominate power in the world. He wants delegates to keep that information in mind when negotiating with them. He compares the Soviet Union to America, in America culture will change and political opinions will too.…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Over the years from 1945 to 1989, different presidents use doctrines to take a stand on issues such as the Truman Doctrine was to help countries from the threat of communism spreading. Other president’s doctrines were similar in that they were to stop the spread of communism by different ways and intensity. There were situations that they felt required U.S. diplomatic efforts during Truman time in office. During the time Truman was in the office, the doctrine was called Truman Doctrine and took actions that showed his standing on the issue of trying to prevent the spread of communism. The actions and events which took place from the Truman Doctrine had effects on the U.S. and other countries.…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “ If the Soviet policy was expansion, then the American policy was containment.” The US and Soviet had one big difference and that was over communism. The Soviet communists did not like capitalism. Russian leaders believed that capitalism was dying and that communism would spread throughout the world. On the other hand, the Truman Doctrine helped the containment that the US was wanting.…

    • 601 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This shows that the United States quickly ended the threat of Soviet bombs and prevented the expansion of the Soviet Nation. Although there were many times during the Cold War that the United States attempted to contain communism like the Truman Doctrine , which declared that America would support the free people, three examples are very clear.. They controlled the expansion of communism by the Berlin Airlift, the Korean War, and the Cuban Missile Crisis. As soon as the Soviets decided to expand, the Americans followed up with the decision to contain.…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    U.S. Leaders in the Cold War As World War II ended in 1945, the United States and the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics began a decades long struggle for global supremacy known as the Cold War, which lasted until 1991. During this period of time the following Presidents governed the United States: Truman, Eisenhower, Kennedy, Johnson, Nixon, Ford, Carter, Reagan, and Bush. For the purpose of this essay I’m going to focus on three of the more influential Presidents: Harry Truman, Richard Nixon, and Ronald Reagan. All three of these Presidents played crucial, but very different roles during the Cold War.…

    • 1286 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Soviets wanted to enlarge. George Kennan was a US foreign service agent in Moscow, he suggested containment. Containment is the idea that the Soviet Union and Soviet Communism should not be allowed to spread. These three events clearly demonstrate the US's policy of Containment, the Berlin Airlift/ Blockade, Korean War, and The Cuban Missile Crisis. One example of Containment was the Berlin Airlift.…

    • 278 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What was the Cold War and why did it happen? How did it threaten the entire world? The famous author name’s Hans Kung said: “After two world wars, the collapse of fascism, nazism, communism and colonialism and the end of the cold war, humanity has entered a new phase of its history”. In human history, the Cold War definitely changed the condition of the world.…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    However, just because Stalin and Truman had vastly different political ideologies doesn’t mean the Cold War was inevitable. A large part of why the Cold war escalated to the height it did was because of a general lack of cooperation and understanding and an unwillingness to discuss territorial dispute from both the Soviets and Americans. Ironically, despite having deep feelings of hatred towards each other’s country Stalin and Truman met in person only one time (Patterson 108). Truman believed he could deal with Stalin, but the actions he took proved otherwise (109). The fact that Stalin and Truman only met once shows that the two countries were equally guilty of not wanting to deal with the problem at hand.…

    • 1801 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Student name - Simran Singh Student ID- 100280501 “SOURCES OF SOVIET CONDUCT” The single document “George Kennan's famous Long Telegram of 1946” best explained American anti-communism policy known as containment and aspirations of Soviets. (T)According to the Soviets capitalism is a threat for the socialism and the policy of containment which was started by the US was type of strategy to stop the spread of the communism. These issues can best illustrated by the reading-(a) aims of Soviet regime, (b) methods they used to pursue them,(c)policy of “containment” used by Americans to defeat soviets.…

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Soviet occupation in Poland), and bolstered attacks, asserting on the USSR's behalf, their bent on world domination. The United States misconstrued Soviet intentions and assigned ‘world domination' as Stalin's main goal. With such a seemingly aggressive Soviet threat at hand, the U.S. utilized documents and speeches like Kennan's Long Telegram, Churchill's Iron Curtain Speech and the Truman doctrine to acknowledge the maturing Soviet menace. These three documents and declarations deepened the stratification of the already tenuous Soviet and U.S relationship and unwittingly expedited and worsened Cold War tensions. The Soviets would then respond to the United States via pronouncements and reactions (i.e. the Cominform as a rebuttal to the Marshall Plan) as an escalating tit-for-tat would lead the U.S. and the USSR towards more enmity.…

    • 2609 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Therefore the US being a capitalist society wasn't under instant threat. However the Soviets approached their attempted domination with more rational in the logic and rhetoric of power as they were not discourage by a singular victory of their opponents. Overall Kennan's concern lay around the US's response to the USSR, and how to overcome the spread of socialism. Although Russia assumed that the West had a complete lack of control over it's own economic destiny, it also relied on…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    American policy after World War II aimed to strengthen capitalism and prevent the Soviet Union from spreading its totalitarian regime any further beyond the regions in which the Red Army were already situated. The policies introduced by America accelerated the division of Europe, such as the Truman Doctrine and the Marshall Plan. By 1949, the creation of the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) fortified Europe’s division. In March 1946, George Kennan sent an 8000 worded telegram to the U.S with his own views of the Soviet Union and the U.S policy towards them. This telegram highlighted that there would be no ‘peaceful coexistence’ between the U.S and the Soviet Union.…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kennan regards the Soviet Union as still rooted in Marxist ideology, but to strengthen the power and status. Consequently, international relations between the Soviet Union and other states have become hostile and fraught with secretiveness about internal policies and other weaknesses, to keep states such as the US wary of their power. Thus Kennan deduces that polarity between American and Soviet ideologies means that co-operation between the two superpowers would be unlikely for some time. The infallibility of the Kremlin, and the nature of the oppressive rule led to insecurity and a need to strengthen power through the exploitation of the population, manipulation of truths, installation of fear and propaganda.…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Book Review Author: Robert J. McMahon Title: The Cold War: A Very Short Introduction Publisher: Oxford University Press Place and Date of Publication: New York, 2003 Topic and Scope: In The Cold War: A Very Short Introduction, Robert J. McMahon discusses a general account of the Cold War, spanning the period from 1945 to the finale of the Soviet-American confrontation in 1990. McMahon discusses key events, trends, and themes that that highlighted key players, such as Stalin, de Gaulle, and Reagan. He also devotes much attention to the Cold War 's domestic as well as international effects.…

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The conflict between capitalism and communism caused one of the biggest conflicts of the twentieth century. The United States feared the Soviet Union would infiltrate their country, this caused lots of political anxiety. This fear was caused by the news media and politicians who characterized the Soviet Union as being bent on world domination. The United States was traumatized by the events before the Cold War so they didn’t want to take any chances. During the 1930s the U.S went through the Great Depression.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays