Wit Compare And Contrast Susie And Jason

Improved Essays
The movie Wit deals with Vivian Bearing, a professor of 17th century poetry with stage IV ovarian cancer, and her journey through experimental chemotherapy which is accompanied by several flashbacks to significant moments in her life. Two of the main characters, Susie and Jason, play a role in shaping their patient, Vivian Bearing’s, outlook on her life, because both of them have a significant connection to her— they are two of her caretakers (Susie is one of her nurses and Jason is one of her doctors and a former student of Bearing). While both of them have a connection to Bearing, they see her in different lights— Susie sees Bearing as a suffering patient, whereas Jason sees her as chance for research. Though this differing view of Bearing …show more content…
Despite both Susie and Jason being members of the medical field, they approach their practices quite differently. The medicine that Susie is shown practicing appears as a more narrative medicine approach— one which focuses on the patient, and their whole story, rather than just ordering tests and ignoring the patient as a person. She listens Bearing, and attempts to get to know her as much as possible, placing emphasis on her comfort, rather than just the medical reasons that Bearing is at the hospital. This directly contrasts to Jason who is primarily interested in the medical and research potential of Susie's case. This focus towards the potential research benefits of Bearing’s cancer leads Jason to adopt a starkly different attitude than Susie. She becomes an advocate for Bearing, as she is the first to notice that Bearing has had no family or other visitors. This leads Susie to …show more content…
Before Bearing was diagnosed with cancer and began chemotherapy, she was straightforward and solely focused on her profession. This is exemplified in a flashback where one of her students asks for an extension on a paper because their grandmother died. Instead of being sympathetic, Bearing responds with a harsh no, showing her strict attitude towards schoolwork, and her belief that others should adhere to this attitude. Jason mentions her course in seventeenth century as one of the hardest classes at the college, something that speaks to Bearing’s character— she likes to challenge both others and herself. This is evident at the beginning of the movie, when Bearing is shown speaking to Dr. Kelekian, where they discuss her treatment. Kelekian describes this experimental treatment as “an aggressive treatment for an aggressive tumor”, and despite knowing many of the side effects, Bearing agrees to go ahead with the rounds of chemotherapy. However, as the rounds of chemotherapy go by, Bearing steadily grows weaker. The weaker Bearing is, the more her attitude begins to change. Rather than just being the scholarly-focused professor, she begins to see the importance of compassion and going to extra mile. She is able to see this through Susie’s actions towards her, as Susie goes above and beyond what is expected of a nurse. One moment that demonstrates

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Courage is essential in the nursing profession; but not as essential as caring. Caring is known to be the central aspect of nursing by many professionals (Petrou et al., 2017). “Care is the essence of nursing and the central, dominant, and unifying feature of nursing” according to Leininger in the article by Dahlke and Stahlke (2017). However, care can be shown in many different forms. Larson and Ferketich describe caring not only as a physical treatment, but also encompassing empathy and feeling of safety with your nurse (Petrou et al., 2017).…

    • 1737 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Chcpa Case 5.07

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages

    1. What CHPCA guiding principles did you see enacted? • GP1. Family focused – when Lee takes over providing Marvin, her father, with care after Bessie was not successful at finding a bone marrow donor. • GP4.…

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    . There was no palliative care where treating symptoms is as important as pain management and providing psychological support. Vivian continues with the full-dose of treatment even though they fail to explain the full dose chemotherapy to her. The author is portraying how important it is for doctors and patient should agree about the course of the treatment and hence achieve a balance between honesty and autonomy. In the movie, you see Vivian realizing that the doctors treating her see her less as someone to save and more as a guinea pig for their research.…

    • 331 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the essay “The Empathy Exams” the author, Leslie Jamison, plays the role of a Medical Actor to help in the learning process for medical students. As a medical actor, her main job is to pretend that she is a sick patient. She must be a Standardized Patient, meaning she must pretend to have the mentality and all symptoms of the patient she is play-acting to be. The students are supposed to go along with the acting and ask the “sick patient” anything from health related questions to person life questions. Throughout the essay the narrator undertakings the characters Stephanie Phillips, a twenty- three women who has been experiencing seizures for the past two years because of grief of her brother’s death, and Leslie Jamison, a twenty-five year…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I hope that by better understanding her illness, I will be able There are many lessons to be taken away from reading The Center Cannot Hold. The lesson that I found most important was the importance of your experiences with your health care…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The late Diem Brown was a magnificent woman who had an energy and grace to her that would only be seen in fairytales. When she was just twenty-four years old, this self proclaimed dancing queen got cast to be on a reality competition show where she fought against other competitors in a series of challenges to claim a grand prize of two-hundred and fifty-thousand dollars. As her first reality TV debut hit, she hid a secret from not only her cast mates, but also from the world. This beautiful energetic soul had closeted the fact that she had been diagnosed ovarian cancer. Through here life she not only had to fight cancer one time but in all she battled against it for a heart wrenching three times.…

    • 1658 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jacqueline, or Dr. Black, was one of the multiple people who Pearson met who strongly believed in the importance of standing by their patients through difficult times. By the time Jacqueline’s patient, Gloria was found to have cervical cancer, she had already had her phone number. Pearson writes about how some doctors, like Jacqueline, choose to make doctoring the main focus of their life. While the workdays of many doctors ended as soon as they left the office, Jacqueline spent her time convincing St. Vincent’s House to fund Gloria’s CT scan, driving Gloria to Houston to apply for charity care, and continuously comforting her through their struggle to find a treatment. This way of practicing medicine is seen as wrong by some doctors and even Pearson thinks that some doctors get too involved with their patients.…

    • 843 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Templeton, who is suffering from an incurable lung disease in the intensive care unit. Tilda experiences difficulties with delivering optimal care to her patient due to Mrs. Templeton’s son being responsible for his mother’s care plan. He insists that everything will be done in order to save his mother’s life but, when Tilda is confronted by a stubborn and demanding family member, she is unsure about how to provide care for her patient. Tilda understands that Mrs. Templeton is passing away due to her age and lung condition and believes that she should not have to suffer during her death. After observing Mrs. Templeton agonize in pain, she advocates for her patient and communicates with Mrs. Templeton’s son that the ventilator, intravenous, feeding tubes, and the catheter are irritating Mrs. Templeton.…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jin vs. Junior A part of growing up is changing and accepting yourself for who you are. Although transferring to a new school may be inevitable how you handle this experience is what counts in the end. Everyone goes through a series of events that either change your life in a favorable way or unacceptable way when being apart of two cultures. In this case Junior and Jin must both battle with many different problems because they are trying to find an identity while being apart of two different cultures.…

    • 1102 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Upon arriving at the hospital, Amir’s worst fears are yet becoming far too real as it seems that Baba may have cancer. The doctor comfortingly reassures Baba of the treatments that can be taken to prolong the cancerous effect. When the doctor mentions to Baba that chemotherapy is an option in prolonging the cancer, He exclaims ignorantly, “’… Thank you for that but no chemo medication for me”’ (Hosseini 156).…

    • 1872 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Two years of Susanna’s life were wasted all because of the doctor who diagnosed her in 20 minutes. “In Massachusetts,…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the beginning of the memoir Susanna Kaysen details the meeting with the doctor who sent to McLean Hospital, a decision that would affect the next two years of her life. Further in the book Kaysen wonders how long the initial meeting was by retracing her steps, but admits that the hospital’s records of a three hour meeting might be correct. Then Kaysen adds a new piece of evidence in another hospital record that fits her timeline. The use of evidence persuades the reader to believe everything she says is true. Yet, through the inconsistencies of Susanna’s memory and contradicting pieces of evidence Kaysen proves that she is an unreliable narrator, illustrating how human judgment is uncertain and not always trustworthy.…

    • 924 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Danny and Reuven are proof that opposites do attract. They met by an unfortunate event where Reuven got hit in the eye by Danny’s ball in a game of baseball. Reuven’s eye was pretty badly injured and he was taken to the hospital. While Reuven was in the hospital recovering from his injury, Danny visited him and tried to mend what had been broken by saying he was sorry. At first, Reuven wanted nothing to do with Danny,but Reuven’s father convinced him to accept Danny’s plea for forgiveness.…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Identity Change as a Result of Cancer Illness is a challenge that can take over many aspects of one’s life resulting in a change in identity. As seen in Margaret Edson’s play Wit, the main character Vivian Bearing is forced to face the traumatic experience that comes along with cancer. Vivian’s circumstances make it very easy to understand the many ways identity may be altered when dealing with a difficult situation.…

    • 1576 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Our Time Is Up Analysis

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The patient did not have a clue of reality and the therapist did not care, he was going through the motions. He could have been emotionally indifferent or stringing them alone to keep up his patient intake. This was evident when the patient asked him how long with the therapy take because two years had already passed; the reply was all in due time with an ominous tone. When the therapist receives the news of his impending death, this marked a turn of events that change the whole dynamic of the…

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays