He chose bat as an example because they are close enough to human beings. Bats has this echolocation which they perceive their surrounding. Our own experience can provide the basic material for our imagination as stated in What is it like to be a bat?. It tells us what it would be like for us to behave like a bat behaves but the question is, “What is it like for a bat to be a bat?” We may act like a bat but we won’t be able to describe what they are experiencing in their surrounding because our experiences are not like the bat’s experiences. Vice-versa for the bats or martians, they could ask “What is it like to be humans?”, they may also behave as humans but they can never be because their experiences are not same to us. Based on a video I have watched, “What is it like” doesn’t mean how our experiences be similar to “it” but how the subject be
He chose bat as an example because they are close enough to human beings. Bats has this echolocation which they perceive their surrounding. Our own experience can provide the basic material for our imagination as stated in What is it like to be a bat?. It tells us what it would be like for us to behave like a bat behaves but the question is, “What is it like for a bat to be a bat?” We may act like a bat but we won’t be able to describe what they are experiencing in their surrounding because our experiences are not like the bat’s experiences. Vice-versa for the bats or martians, they could ask “What is it like to be humans?”, they may also behave as humans but they can never be because their experiences are not same to us. Based on a video I have watched, “What is it like” doesn’t mean how our experiences be similar to “it” but how the subject be