Baseball Bat Controversy Essay

Improved Essays
A Chicago officer who shot and killed a 19 year old suspect is suing (via counterclaim) the decedent's estate for trauma. The officer claims that the suspect assaulted him with a baseball bat during the confrontation. It is claimed by the officer that he suffered deeply from the traumatic experience of having the baseball bat nearly miss his head when swung by the suspect. In fact, the officer alleges that the suspect tried to hit him twice, nearly missing on each occasion.

Although what happened during the confrontation has been subject to different interpretations, one things is clear: the officer used deadly force to stop the suspect. Specifically, the officer shot the suspect four times as he (the suspect) lunged towards the officer
…show more content…
Authorities know for certain that the suspect, Legrier, was the person who made the initial 911 call. It appears he and his father called police seeking some sort of assistance. The victim's father claims he called 911 because his emotionally challenged son was hitting a door with the bat. Then it appears that the officer arrived to the location and immediately requested that Legrier drop the bat. Subsequently, it is said that the suspect swung the bat a few times in the officer's direction, but while the two had several feet of distance in between …show more content…
However, there are other aspects of controversy in this case. First, the family has been criticized for quickly filing a lawsuit after the death occurred. The family's attorney claims that this was done to ensure that all possible pieces of evidence would get preserved. However, the officer involved, and the law enforcement agency have made statements suggesting that the family is just looking for a quick windfall. The officer's attorney, Mr. Brodsky, even stated that the family shouldn't be using the lawsuit as a "lottery ticket.

From the opposite side, the family and its attorney claim that the police department is trying to downplay the shooting and blame the victim for what occurred that day. The family's legal team is also reaffirming their underlying desire to preserve evidence by showing that it has already received several pieces of evidence as it originally

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The identification of several significant facts in the case of Tennessee v. Garner calls into question the use of deadly force in the “unattempted” apprehension of an unarmed suspect. The first such fact is the admission and later verification by Hymon that Garner was unarmed. A second fact is that the suspect was fleeing in the opposite direction (away) from Officer Hymon and in a position as not to cause the officer to be in fear for his life. Additionally, Officer Hymon with the aid of his flashlight was able to observe that the suspect was a minor and of slender statue (observing his hands and face) posing no threat to him or others.…

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    ELMIRA (WENY) - One Elmira woman is in the hospital after getting in a brawl involving a baseball bat Thursday evening. The Elmira Police Department says the 40-year-old victim is suffering from a fractured skull and bleeding on the brain after being hit in the head with a metal baseball bat. Police arrested 19-year-old Alexis Driscoll, of Elmira, and charged her with first-degree assault for allegedly hitting the victim in the back of the head with the metal bat.…

    • 149 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    People Vs. Goetz's Trail

    • 311 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Case Number 2: In the early afternoon of December 22, 1984, four juvenile African-American men boarded the New York City subway, in which Bernhard Goetz shot and seriously wounded all four teenagers, after they allegedly tried to mug him. Nine days after the incident, Goetz eventually surrendered to law enforcement. In the process of People vs. Goetz’s trail, he was charged with attempted murder, assault, reckless endangerment, and several firearms offenses, however, a jury found him not guilty of all charges except for one count of carrying an unlicensed firearm, for which he served eight months of a one-year sentence. The incident sparked a nationwide debate on race and crime in major cities and the legal limits of self-defense, incidence…

    • 311 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Baseball Bat Essay

    • 694 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Ashley Ramirez Forensic Science Mr. Kirby November 1st 2014 Baseball Bat On April 19th, 2014 Ricky Betancur life was taken from him by Eric Noyola who willfully and unlawfully killed Betancur, hitting him in the skull with a baseball bat. Noyola was also charged with being drunk in public as well as first degree murder. This case began late Saturday night when the two were watching friends at Boomer Sports Complex in Oklahoma City located off I-240 and Sunnylane Rd.…

    • 694 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    An Analysis of State v. Steele (2013) for Police Misconduct and Kingsley v. Hendrickson et al. (2015) for Police Brutality Background: In this case evaluation, the overarching problem of police misconduct and police brutality will be examined in State v. Steele and Kingsley v. Hendrickson et al. In the past ten years, there has been an alarming rate of police misconduct and police brutality, which continues to be a problem in terms of prosecuting corrupt law enforcement officials in the field. A vast increase in the use of deadly force and police misconduct was conducted by Bowling Green State University, which evaluated 6, 724 cases in which a police officer was arrested for some form of police brutality, gun usage, or misconduct from 2005-2011…

    • 1354 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Brenton Butler Case Study

    • 1231 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Their sole piece of evidence was the identification given by the victim’s husband and a coerced confession that police wrote out themselves and beat Brenton into signing. With the research provided it is evident that eyewitness testimonies can be affected by many factors and it is not sufficient enough evidence to stand on its own. The police asked the victim to identify Brenton 2 hours after his wife had been shot which is hardly enough time for his shock of the situation to die down. Also, when they presented him Mr. Butler, they did not do so in the form of a lineup they presented him by himself in the area that the crime happened. The setting he was presented in, the time he was allowed to view Mr. Butler, the distance he viewed him and the traumatic state he was in, all led to his wrongful identification of Brenton Butler.…

    • 1231 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    August 9th of 2014, an African American male who was eighteen years of age named Michael Brown was killed in Ferguson, Missouri. It was shown that minutes before his death Mr. Brown was earlier at the local liquor store stealing cigarillos. Mr. Wilson, of 28 years, was the police officer that picked up on the situation as he saw someone to appear as to what the suspect looked like. Once stopping Michael, and him cooperating onto the sidewalk, there was later an altercation between Mr. Brown and Officer Darren Wilson, who is of white heritage. Moments later, Michael Brown was shot and killed by Wilson, after having the officer chase him.…

    • 1011 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When a police officer pulls their gun out it is because they are under a possible deadly threat or the public is under a threat. In the case of this story, a public citizen threw a beer bottle at the back of a stopped police car causing the glass to shatter. Furthermore, the officers, “fearing they were under fire, the officers bailed out of the cruiser and fired their own guns at a nearby man they believed was responsible, killing him” (2015). The officers who are now being investigated on whether there force was reasonable due to the fact the suspect did not possess a gun or a weapon. So ultimately, there is a question of was it necessary to fire in this situation?…

    • 357 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In early July, the death of a civilian under the hands of the police in the U.S. occurred. Philando Castile, who was only 32 years old, was fatally shot by police officers from the passenger seat of his girlfriend’s car. According to an ABC News article by Julia Jacobo and Enjoli, the police officer planned to stop the vehicle Castile was in because he unethically assumed that Castile and the driver were robbers based on racial profiling (par. 4). After the officer killed Castile, the driver live-streamed the aftermath scene on her Facebook account and states that the officer assumed Castile was pulling out a gun instead of his wallet and shot him four times in the process. Philando Castile was fatally shot based on uncertain and false pretences.…

    • 1811 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Police Body Worn Video: The Good and the Bad In 2014, the shooting and killing of Michael Brown left many with uncertain answers due to having uncertain claims from witnesses. The claims made by witnesses did not corroborate with the crime scene. Many of the witnesses claimed that Michael Brown was a victim of Officer Wilson as he posed no threat and yet was shot and killed. Certain witnesses claimed that Michael Brown had his “hands up” when he was shot.…

    • 1966 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Gloria, Great post, you did a great job of defining what dead force actually is and what constitutes deadly force. Deadly force should only be used as a last resort unless you are defining yourself are the safety of another person. There are instances where officer must make a split decision on what to do and sometimes deadly force is needed. If an officer can show that he or she believe the suspect possessed a significant threat then deadly force is acceptable.…

    • 82 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Use Of Force

    • 1332 Words
    • 6 Pages

    There are multiple tables and figures that were provided in Chapter 10 which is use of force. Table 10.1 on page 324, showed the number of police officers that have been killed accidentally while on the duty. Data from 2001 to 2010 has showed that over 400 police officers were killed in automobile accident which is the highest reason for officer’s death. The second highest was struck by vehicle with little over 100 death. Figure 10.2 discussed fairly new law that was law that was made in Florida that when an authorize vehicle with their light one approaching you, you must move immediately and open the road for an authorized vehicle.…

    • 1332 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Mr. Ede was walking along Albert St about 1.30pm when he was allegedly assaulted before falling and hitting his head on concrete; the unprovoked attack resulted in the death of Mr. Ede. After 12 months, the accused will finally stand trial charged on the crime of “Unlawful Striking causing Death.” The defendant, Mr. Mayot will be the first person in the state to be charged with this crime. Another prevalent case in regards to this issue was the horrific attack of an 18-year-old aspiring Water polo player, Cole Miller. He was walking home from a night out in Fortitude Valley, when he was struck in the head.…

    • 1016 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Baseball Observation Essay

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages

    As I walked into the stadium, the smell of hotdogs and popcorn filled the air. It was a familiar setting. A setting I had grown to know very well because my dad loved baseball. The red white and blue colors were everywhere as fans came from every direction into the stadium. My dad and I walked to the outfield where the opposing team was warming up for the game.…

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Police officers are often placed in dangerous situations that result in them killing a criminal or suspect. Law enforcements utilization of various forms of force has gained the attention of policymakers, citizens, media outlets and researchers. Incidents such as police interactions with Abner Louima, Michael Brown and Freddie Gray resulted in the citizen’s death. In recent years there has been a rise in the amount of citizens who are killed by law enforcement in the United States. A large portion of the individuals who were killed by law enforcement were found to have been unarmed.…

    • 190 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays