Weber's Theory Of Calvinism

Improved Essays
We are often told to think about our actions in rational terms. Because of this, when thinking about a situation, all emotions, opinions, and things that make us human are set aside for the sake of rationality and efficiency. The development of bureaucracies in order to deal with the large masses is a result of rational thought that is prominent in the Protestant ethic. According to Weber, this leads to a world in which the individual’s freedom is at threat, often trapping them in an iron cage.
Weber establishes that the spirit of capitalism is imbedded in the Protestant ethic. He explains that those who are financially successful have roots in Protestantism. This can be explained by “…the spirit of hard work, of progress, or whatever else
…show more content…
Weber argues that “…Calvinist diaspora [is] the seed-bed of capitalistic economy” (10). He continues by suggesting that Calvinism places an emphasis on “…constant self-control and thus to deliberate regulation of one’s own life…” (79). Even Calvinist ministers counsel their followers to engage in systematic rational conduct, in their calling, as a way to cope with their anxiety over their salvation. As a result, there is an emphasis on “…a systematic rational ordering of the moral life as a whole” (79). Calvinism has a sense of antipathy towards the worship of worldly things, however, it places an emphasis on religious duty in order to make use of God’s given resources available to all people. Through systematization and orderliness in all aspects of life, profit is earned and in that, a sense of salvation. Thus, through this rationality and systematization, bureaucracies were developed in order to deal with the large …show more content…
The Protestant ethic fosters a rational orientation to the world that demands using rationality to make all decisions. Bureaucracies, as goal-oriented institutions, are set to produce a systematic way to control and regulate other organizations. Branches in bureaucracies are ranked in hierarchical order in which information flows up the chain of command. Bureaucracies’ efficiency lies in its impersonal rules that are based on rationality. They explicitly state responsibilities, standardize procedures and make sure that everyone in the branches are highly qualified. In bureaucracies, people are not regarded as individuals, instead, they are numbers in order to be able to reach the whole population. Bureaucracies function because they “[segregate] official activity as something distinct from the sphere of private life” (197). Through this, there is an “…increase in the speed by which…economic and political facts, are transmitted exerts a steady and sharp pressure in the direction of speeding up the tempo of administrative reaction towards various situations” (215). These characteristics allow goals to be reached, but because people are regarded as numbers instead of actual individuals, policies developed through bureaucracies may have unintended consequences that result in

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In the Spirit of Capitalism, one must generate profit. In Western Society, working hard is an acceptable ascetic technique. and because labor came to be an end, ordained as such by God. This does not change, even for those people who are wealthy, because everyone has a calling in which they should labor, and taking the opportunities for profit that God provides is part of that calling. To wish to be poor is similar to wishing to be sick, and both are morally unacceptable. Not greed but encourages good work “A calling” – working at it…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Greed is God: The Genesis of the Christian Share Index. Independent, 27 April 2010, http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/faith/greed-is-god-the-genesis-of-the-christian-share-index-1956176.html…

    • 1666 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I perpetually rest assure that Capitalism is selfish and corrupt. Contemplating that greed hurts the poor and helps the rich, that greed is all about the desire for money and power. After reading the introduction and chapters one and two of Jay W. Richar ds book “Money, Greed and God: Why Capitalism is the Solution “, Richard certainly grasps my consideration and leads me towards to considering that a capitalistic economy is not a deficient concept after all and that a “good Christian can be, indeed should be, a good capitalist”.The author seems to structure the book…

    • 748 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Carlyle Vs. Marx

    • 1409 Words
    • 6 Pages

    149, 1843). They challenge us to consider what is the added value that humans bring to the workplace and perhaps the world in general (Carlyle, p. 149-150, 1843). Not paying attention to this leads to a working class that feels, and is in fact, inferior (Marx, p. 22, 1844). It will eventually hurt all involved (Marx, p. 22-24, 1844). They both use religious overtones referencing “Hell” (Marx p. 24, 1844) as well as, the consequences of falling prey to these inhumane ideas (Carlyle, p. 36, 1844). The fear of “The terror of ‘Not Succeeding’ of not making money, fame, or some other figure in the world…Is not that a somewhat singular Hell?” that continues to exist in our world today. People continue to think that more money will make them happier. I wonder why after more than one hundred years we still struggle to understand that it does not. This causes us to pause and consider the everyday quotes we still use today such as “for the love of money is the root of all kinds of evil” (1 Timothy 6:10) and the popular saying “money can’t buy happiness”. We use these saying very regularly, but still do not embrace their meaning or live by them in our day to day lives. We also have learned nothing from Carlyle’s mention of the working of the “Charitable Establishment” in which…

    • 1409 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    emphasis on reason, social utility, pragmatic reform, and aversion to arbitrary rule.” (337) when so…

    • 875 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The ‘futuristic’ European state is portrayed as one with large looming towers, pervasive terrorist activity, and sarcastically large factories. Individuals move about the environment hurried and chaotically, giving the audience a sense that these structures work to dominate and organize individuals, rather than the other way around. This reflects Weber’s notion of the “Iron Cage of Reason”, which posits that in a highly bureaucratic society, rational behaviour is dictated by what the bureaucracy views as rational (Dandeker 1991). Brazil features comical manifestations of this idea in a particular scene when a ministry guards apprehend Sam after he attempts to use a restricted elevator. Following a brief pursuit, Sam accidently flashes his badge, signalling the guards to stand down, thus revealing a contradiction that illustrates how the bureaucracy works to serve itself. One gains an understanding of the dichotomous nature of the ministries classification of individuals as one notices it delicately balances between two undisputable extremes: citizen or…

    • 1149 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    In her presentation of theological economy, namely, the economy of grace, Kathryn Tanner investigates the practical implications of her incarnational dogmatic enterprise. I concur with Tanner’s claim of the urgent need of an economy of grace as I take into account the ever-growing gap of wealth between the rich and the poor as well as the Global North and the Global South. Furthermore, as George Harvey rightly diagnoses, it seems to be the unbridled desire for private possession in the capitalist market that resulted in the housing bubble, which eventually “destroyed the capacity for many to acquire and sustain their access to housing use values.” (George Harvey, 21). To top it all, the housing market crash triggered a global crisis. Nevertheless, ironically, while the economic life of commoners and small businesses suffer, many corporate companies and major financing companies are enjoying the joy ride of increasing profits (The Price of Inequality, 469-70). Above all, Tanner’s economy of grace is strongly invited in the current global capitalist market in that her suggestion addresses the problem of people’s alienation in the market that operates under the rubric of profit maximization.…

    • 1628 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this document, Carl Degler focuses on how unlike the conviction of most historians, the Puritans were not an overly ascetic group of people who denied all worldly pleasures, but instead they enjoyed a reasonable amount while still following moral values and social ethics. The Puritans agreed with most Calvinist theology. One belief they agreed with was that God had not only created things out of sheer necessity, but also so that people could enjoy them. It was only until pleasurable activities disrupted productivity and the pursuit to follow the will of God that they would ban such pleasures. The prohibition of cards and dice while allowing public lotteries best displays this. Cards and dice were seen to lead to wasting time, while the lottery…

    • 335 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Luther’s understanding of spiritual and temporal authorities in 1523 is still prominent in the modern day government. Luther believed the bureaucratic leadership is a way to maintain order in a chaotic and sinful world even though Luther realized the state could also be dictatorial. Limits to the state are necessary for fear that the secular political power will persecute the faith. Luther stated the idea that Christian’s should not have temporal authority or law since they can rule themselves with the guidance of the Holy Spirit. However those who are not Christian’s must have temporal authorities so they do not implement their wicked deeds.…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When given so much power, any economic system would skew the morals and values people hold themselves to. In The Great Gatsby, Fitzgerald chose to explore the repercussions of allowing capitalism to become the moral authority of the main characters in the novel. Capitalism, “legally...is a system of objective laws (rule of law as opposed to rule of man)” (“Capitalism” 1). Capitalism, as an ethic guide, is not based on true values, but what is best for each individual, a far cry from the guidance of actual religions (1). “The closest any country has come to pure capitalism is 19th century America…” when capitalism was roaring and the all-important economy was king (1). It is not hard to believe that under capitalist rule the characters in The Great Gatsby viewed the eyes of T. J. Eckleburg, an advertisement, as…

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The church-state relationship has varied in various cultures over time. It is my belief that church and state are “distinct but mutually influential.” Church and state have distinct areas of responsibility, and those responsibilities should be exercised with mutual respect and negotiated influence and authority. (McQuilken & Copan, 2013). Additionally, I believe that the church has an obligation to deal with world poverty. This paper will outline my reasoning for believing that church and state are distinct but mutually influential, and illustrate the application of this philosophy to the issue of world poverty.…

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Here obedience is owed to the impersonal order (or office); of which the incumbent’s authority exists within a formalised legal structure and are subject themselves to the rule of law. The purest type of system claiming legal-rational authority employs a bureaucratic administrative staff to exercise domination, which is itself constructed using legal and rational methodology, and, thanks to its supreme efficiency, can be applied in all kinds of situations and contexts, i.e., political or economic (Weber 1978: 217-220). This is based on a belief that rationality leads to the most efficient form of administration, and therefore provides the most effective and stable form of government. However, this is not without its limitations. Although, according to Weber, this method of rule favors the leveling of status and mitigates the likelihood that unjust rulers will reach positions of authority, it is not completely insulated from perversion. Leaders or ministers of an agency who generally do not have advanced technical training in the area of their administrative portfolio possess considerable power over the agencies actions, and in some cases its objectives. A severe deviation could be based purely on value or instrumental rationality, even on behalf of their associated political party. A poor decision might be in contrast with popular public opinion, and, in turn, destabilise the legitimacy of the executive authority. A contemporary example of legal-rational authority is evident in all liberal democratic states, whose leaders claim their legitimacy based on formalised legal processes. Its wide dissemination is a testament to its ability to provide lasting political…

    • 1100 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Protestant Reformation destroyed the Catholic Church in medieval society. It promoted the formation of the European nation. Protestant advocated the church should take care of themselves, did not need to accept the protection and control of the government. In addition, the church should be pure. People have the freedom to join the church that the government could not intervene in religious affairs. It is the core idea of liberal democracy. According to the survey, the Western Protestant countries' (such as the United Kingdom, Switzerland, the United States and Germany) democratization faster than the Catholic countries (Mr.Chen Xiao Hong & Mr. Qiu Cheng, 2011). These Protestant countries practiced the liberal democracy. Protestants focused on the responsibilities and individual’s rights. In addition, the Protestant Reformation led to the modern view of politics and law. Protestantism led many people to rebel the authority of the church. The Protestant Reformation cuased the political conflict in Germany and France. It caused the Thirty Years' War of the 17th century (Cole, J, & Symes C, 2014). For example, many German princes converted to Protestantism. It resisted the Hold Roman Empire. After the war, every Germany can determine on its own whether it would be Catholic or Protestant, greatly reducing the authority of the emperor. People’s ideas began to become more…

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    One aspect I like about Weber is his approach to understand modern Capitalism as a product of religion. On page…

    • 1764 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Rationalization refers to the overall historical process where reality is, ‘increasingly mastered by calculation, scientific knowledge, and rational action’ (Morrison, 2006, p. 285). In contrast, rationality is a term Weber used to refer to ‘the capacity of social action to be subject to calculation, of the means and ends of action by taking up a methodical orientation to reality’ (Morrison, 2006, p. 285). Weber believed the rationalization process was apparent in individual action, in orientations, and also in institutions (Morrison, 2006). It can be seen that Weber’s concept of rationalization refers to two broad trends in historical development (Morrison, 2006). First, social and historical processes have become more reliant on calculation in order to obtain rational control over the natural and social world (Morrison, 2006). An example of this is the development of science, engineering and modern technology (Giddens, 2001). Second, is of human social action to free itself from being dependent on magical thinking in order to rely on what is immediately given without superstition (Morrison, 2006). Weber believed that the concept of Western rationalism would spread disenchantment and instrumental rationality around the world; this was a sociological and historical observation (McLennan et al, 2010). Giddens (2001) depicted that Weber was afraid that modern society would turn into a system and diminish the human spirit through the attempt to regulate the spheres of social life. Weber discovered that the development of rationalization was becoming increasingly common and is potentially harmful to everyday…

    • 2122 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays

Related Topics