Analysis Of Waiting For Superman

Better Essays
Helan Essa
SYD 3700
March 21, 2016
Race and Education: Waiting for Superman In "Waiting For Superman", Davis Guggenheim, demonstrates throughout his documentary on the importance of good teachers and schools, and how they have a tremendous impact on students and their education. This documentaries agenda was to show that there is a model for education out there that has been proven to work where others have failed. The documentary goes in depth on the role of charter schools and different educational reforms, and how these factors are producing results that may change the future of education. Throughout the film, it is obvious that the way to fix what is going on in the American public education system is to reform to a setting smaller and
…show more content…
Another obstacle to good education discussed in the movie was the role of teachers. An example of a great teacher that Guggenheim uses is the elementary teacher who turns math into lyrics for the students to remember. Guggenheim discusses the protected, tenured teacher waiting to collect her pension is the reason why America’s children don’t have a high-quality education. Getting rid of tenure is one possible solution to the problem of underperforming teachers. For example, the viewer sees footage from the early 1990’s of a teacher reading a newspaper while his students sit listless at their desks. Guggenheim shows that teachers in teacher’s union get tenure with a Simpsons’ clip: Lisa Simpson’s teacher counts down to when she gets tenure, and after she received tenure, says that she won’t teach and asks Ralph to teach the class instead. Part of the problem, Rhee says, is that the union doesn’t recognize good teachers. Every teacher is paid the same based on years of service. Canada says that there can be no reform without going through the teachers union. Lastly, Guggenheim says that while 1 in 57 doctors and 1 in 97 lawyers lose their license, only 1 in 2500 teachers lose their …show more content…
Black and Hispanic children’s parents typically have lower incomes and lower levels of educational completion than white children’s parents. Because higher-income and more-educated families typically can provide more educational opportunities for their children, family socioeconomic resources are strongly related to educational outcomes. Socioeconomic segregation is a stubborn, multidimensional and deeply important cause of educational inequality. U.S. schools are now 41 percent nonwhite and the great majority of the nonwhite students attend schools which now show substantial segregation (Orfield, 2005). Guggenheim shows the affect segregation can have on students based on how the neighborhoods who pay higher taxes get a better education. The way I see segregation matters through the plot of the movie because it shows if something happens in a poor neighborhood than it doesn’t have a big impact on a rich neighborhood. The rich people are not affected by what the poor people are hit with. I see it as the rich might feel for the poor but it’s not such a strong impact to them personally for the rich to do anything about it. The upper class people already have good schools and live in low crime areas which works will for them because students who are of lower socioeconomic neighborhoods that bring trouble are not allowed to attend their

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Inequalities In Schools

    • 1056 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Students who live in West Hartford and whose parents’ income level is higher have better test scores as opposed to students living in East Hartford and Hartford. According to Kozol, unequal educational outcomes are caused due to the fact that schools that are located in less affluent neighborhoods have less financial resources, thus they are unable to provide the same opportunities for students as schools in more wealthy neighborhoods (Kozol 168). However, Grubb claims that not only does the school’s budget determine inequalities but also how financial resources are used, and he argues that schools in more affluent neighborhoods allocate money more properly (Grubb 25). Finally, Noguera argues that social capital leads to unequal educational outcomes because parents in more affluent neighborhoods have the power to put pressure on the school, hence they can have their demands fulfilled (Noguera 33). All in all, there are some theories emphasizing the importance of money as a cause for inequalities, however, one must point out that it does not solely account for unequal educational outcomes.…

    • 1056 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    They can only rely on the material in school and the help from teachers. Thus, their reading achievement will not be as good as the rich student bodies as additional resources do affect achievement. With that, the poor student bodies may not be able to go to a college and achieve higher degrees. There will always be an education gap between the rich and the poor, and the poor will be unable to break free from poverty. The rich student bodies have more money so they are able to go to a nicer public or private schools and have the means to eat more nutritionally to help in their concentration in class.…

    • 1138 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I think this was the point in my life where I no longer cared for math. I remember the teacher coming to class and just start writing problems on the board with no explanation and told us to solve them. My ninth grade math teacher was a cold man. I distinctly remember the time I completely gave up on math. The teacher came to class and told us we were going to have a quiz.…

    • 1099 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the documentary film, Waiting for Superman by Davis Guggenheim, it depicts the story of several kids and their families on a journey to find better education than what is being taught in the tattered public school system. Through this film it allowed us to see into the minds of the student, the parent, the teacher, and the officials leading the education system today; giving us an important viewpoint on the way schooling is to be further handled in America. This analysis will point out the two strongest parts of the documentary, followed by the disappointing weakness helping support its main idea that “education is the way out.” First, we look at the meaningful message that is given to the viewer, and what it outlines for them. Waiting for Superman’s call to action tackles one of the most important topics in the United States, “What do we need to do in order to improve our education system?” Not only does this film give numerous examples of what is wrong. For example, low income areas are influencing bad education while the thing needed to succeed is a good education, it is increasingly hard for parents to get children in to good schools, and how different each child is in their learning method.…

    • 1111 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The American education system are not created equally and provides unequal opportunities. Poor or working class students are less likely to graduate from college than wealthy or middle class students. So, David Laude and other researchers have been looking into why poor students struggle in college, and why they have a low rate of graduating and how to influence student mentality in college (Tough, 2014). Most wealthy and middle class students get chance to have more opportunity by having better resources, such as having the ability to afford private schools equipped with excellent facilities, AP courses, information technology, and classrooms with smaller student to teacher ratios. High-income students also able to afford hire tutor and test preparation courses, which give them an advantage on applying to colleges.…

    • 950 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    You might think that college graduates do not provide any benefits for the society. However, this is only if their college education is put to waste, otherwise, college graduates will benefit everyone. The first reason why a higher education benefits the society is that college graduates decrease the rate of unemployment (Leonhardt 1). This is due to the fact that they are well-prepared when searching for jobs. In addition, the lower the rate of unemployment that we possess; the more functioning our society will be (Gale 41).…

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    2004) That means, people with different races are not attaining the education achievement. More important, there is a big academic achievement gap between white and black people. The result show that race and social socioeconomic status (SES) each have a distinct effect on oral vocabulary knowledge (Lin, Harries 2005). The overall effect on white and black differences is increased by the fact that white tend to be concentrated toward higher social socioeconomic status values, while black children cluster toward lower social socioeconomic status values. One the other hand, children who learn English as a second language could experience inequality.…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    There are various factors leading the academic achievement gap among youth living in poverty. These factors include funding for schools, the school environment, efficiency of teachers, parental involvement, and educational resources that are available at home (Morgan, 2012). One of the major disadvantages is that poorer communities tend to have less funding for schools. In fact, some advantaged school districts spend over twice as much per student than poorer school districts (Frost, 2007). Many schools within disadvantaged neighborhoods have also been found to have overcrowded classrooms, run-down buildings, and unkempt textbooks (Frost, 2007).…

    • 1470 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Wealth Gap Analysis

    • 1499 Words
    • 6 Pages

    This would be favorable for the American society because currently the country is divided. Typically, white and black Americans live opposite sides of each city. Another quality of the previous proposal is that black American families would live in safer neighborhoods, surrounding them with better influences, and allowing their kids to attend higher ranked public schools. Children attending a better school allows them to receive a greater education. The weakness of the previous proposal is the substantial amount of time it would take for black Americans to generate wealth.…

    • 1499 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Social Mobility

    • 936 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The lower amount of lower-income parents is due to the fact that in typically lower-income neighborhoods, enrichment programs are harder to find and are typically too expensive to be feasible for most families. This is deeply connected to the fact that parents who did not obtain a higher education than high school, typically have lower yearly earnings than those who obtained a college degree (Pew). This interestingly directly relates to how they view their neighborhoods. Parents from lower or working class are more likely to rate their neighborhoods as “unsafe” or “a bad place to raise kids” than their middle-class counterparts (Pew). The upper classes see their neighborhoods as a “safer” area to raise their children as their presence can raise the value of the neighborhood, in turn raising the quality of the school (Perrin 3).…

    • 936 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays