Bill C-36 Prostitution Case Study

Improved Essays
Prostitution has always been around and always will, it is a part of human nature. Recently Canada has put a new law in place, Bill C-36 to try and end prostitution in Canada. This law is meant to discourage prostitution by promoting an exit, and holding johns, pimps, and traffickers criminally responsible. This law was put into power on December 6th, 2014. The main changes in the law is that now buying sex is illegal, advertising services of others is illegal, and anything to do with sale of sex cannot be anywhere near someone under 18. It is not a

The definition of prostitution In Canada is that prostitution is based on case law, not statutory law. This states that three elements must be established for prostitution to be taking place.
…show more content…
The Court had given the government one year to bring in a new legislation. The Justice Minister Peter Mackay is behind the new law. He describes the new law as a “Made in Canada approach and the best way to eliminate prostitution altogether.” Bill C-36 recognizes prostitution as “inherently exploitative and harmful”. The new bill marks a turning point in Canada’s approach to prostitution. The federal government has devoted $20 million to implement bill C-36.

Canada’s old law states that selling sex was legal, but living in a bawdy or a brothel house is not. Soliciting sex in public was also illegal, as was living off the profits of another individuals prostitution. Canada’s new law states that selling sex is still legal but buying it is now a criminal offence. It is also now illegal for anyone except the prostitute to communicate for purpose of prostitution. The law also prohibits the advertising of sexual services of
…show more content…
The women are able to hire bodyguards, rent apartments, or hire a receptionist. Except anyone of the people they hire cannot be paid as they will be making money off another person 's prostitution. Since prostitution cannot happen where anybody under 18 could reasonably be it results in them being pushed into worse neighbourhoods and locations, making their job more unsafe than it already is. Only allowing the individual woman to advertise her services protects them from pimps and johns, on the other hand this limits them because they cannot advertise their services on the internet or in a magazine because the owners of those services would be advertising them and be fined. The main problem with this law is that the buying of the sex is illegal. Because the clients can be charged and go to jail, they will not put their business in the prostitute with safety measures in place and the one who screens her clients and has all their information. The customers will go to the prostitutes who don’t ask for any information and are in more discrete locations. If the women want to be able to continue to make a living off the selling of their sex they will have to go into unsafe work conditions and put themselves at

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In Alomar and Bell’s case there is a definite infringement on section 8 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and therefore, the photographs of Ms. Alomar holding a handgun should be inadmissible to the trial. Including this evidence would be injustice when coming to a final verdict due to the fact that it violates section 8 of the Charter which states that “everyone has the right to be secure against unreasonable search and seizure” The search of the photos was not authorized by the law because there was no consent expressed or implied by Ms. Alomar. Reason for judgment is found in paragraph 19 and quotes “Det. Colabello immediately went into the cell phone log and noted the last two or three cells in her note book. She also looked…

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Gun Control Effectiveness

    • 1667 Words
    • 7 Pages

    But the failure of gun control would not be the only instance when the federal government failed to prohibit or regulate certain items. In The 1920’s the federal government passed the Volstead Act, which prohibited the sale and the consumption of alcohol. The Volstead Act was enforced strictly in most states, and it was hard to come by Alcohol by common means. This helped create a monopoly on the illegal selling of alcohol for gangs and the mafia. More and more people started to buy alcohol illegally.…

    • 1667 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is no right given to those who have sexual intercourse with others for a price (which is usually performed privately). However: prostitution is LESS degrading than the two, yet it is NOT considered legally acceptable. The law insists insist that prostitution is a moral wrong, disregarding that it charters the legalization of pornography and strip clubs. Sex work like the other two professions, allow men/women to survive in the real world. They can afford clothes on their backs, food on their table and a shelter over their heads.…

    • 1561 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    While many may think it is good to have prostitution illegal, no matter the situation you are ultimately punishing the seller and if that person if a victim of sex trafficking than they will have that on their record and it will not be able to get expunged with the exceptions of a few places. In America 90% of the people arrested for prostitution is the seller while on 10% of buyers get arrested. If a person in the sex industry wanted to get out but they have prostitution of their record it will be hard for them to get a job because people will look at that negatively. Also as mentioned earlier, how will sex workers be able to get the adequate support they need while the practice is still illegal here in America? Workers don’t have access to the proper health care and they need to be able to get tested regularly.…

    • 2007 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If they do continue to sell sex then if a client gets to be violent they have the choice to call the police and face no fine for doing so. The majority of violence behind anything is it being illegal. Like with drugs, the victims of crimes dealing with prostitution won’t go to the police, afraid of being fined themselves. For example, if a sex worker has a client that physically abuses her and beats her, she cannot go to the police for fear that the person fined or arrested would be her. She would the guilty party.…

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This provision is seen as a ‘double-edged sword’, while the provision might be aimed at addressing exploitive relationship between prostitutes and pimps, it also criminalizes persons who provides their services to prostitutes in return for money. A prime examples of this hiring of bodyguards or drivers who help ensure their safety is illegal under section 212(1)(j). The court deemed the section to be too broad because it effected non-exploitive relationships which had no connection to the law whatsoever and hence had been struck down for the time…

    • 1049 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sex workers live in fear of law enforcement; they are concerned that they will not be able to work if they don’t hide in unsafe places do to being found by police and forced to stop working or be prosecuted. Decriminalizing sex work would allow a policy to be put in place, compelling workers to register as an employee of sex work. This has the potential to bring victims who are being coerced into sex work to the surface and allow the victims to be helped rather than law enforcement trying to help workers as…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mr. Epps stated that because prostitutes have been known to practice unprotected sex they will continue to do it in legal brothels. Therefore, more STD’s will be shared between client and prostitute. Mr. Epps is guilt of a slippery slope fallacy in his assumption. Mr. Epps has no clue what will happen if prostitutes find work in legal brothels. So, he does know how the situation involving STD’s could/would be handled.…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Lawrence V. Wade

    • 1313 Words
    • 6 Pages

    He also points out that we still have laws prohibiting bigamy, prostitution, obscenity, and child pornography, which restrict a persons right to make their own choices in their sex lives. He finds the courts claim to be totally hypocritical. In my opinion, sodomy is a fundamental right, and it is "deeply rooted in our Nation's history and traditions." It may have a history of being illegal, but it is not the government's right to restrict sodomy based purely on morals. Bestiality and adult incest, as I mentioned before, have other reasons to illegalize them.…

    • 1313 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Banning Guns

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages

    As a result, I believe banning guns should not be processed because it will only worsen the problem. Banning guns will worsen the problem in different aspects. For example, gang members will always find way to get a gun illegally. They do not care about the law or breaking the law. According to Susan Musser “Breaking the law is their way of living and consequences mean nothing to them.” In addition, people who aren’t part of any gang members will also find a way of getting a gun illegally.…

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays