Teacher Judgment

Improved Essays
The article “Teacher Judgment in Identifying Gifted/Talented Students” is about a teacher’s role in selecting students and referring them to a talented and gifted program. The article investigates what could hinder a teacher’s judgement and what could help them better decide which students were talented and gifted. Research has found that a student’s socioeconomic status can impair a teacher’s judgement and make them less likely to refer a student to a talented and gifted program. Students who were classified as being in lower socioeconomic groups were less likely to be referred to a talented and gifted program than those classified in higher socioeconomic groups. In addition, race and culture also affect a teacher’s judgement of whether students …show more content…
The article is written by teacher who teaches a self contained gifted classrooms and is about her students who exhibited many different forms of unhealthy perfectionism. The teacher describes five different types of unhealthy perfections forms of students: the academic achiever, the risk evader, the aggravated accuracy assessor, the controlling image manager, and the procrastinating perfectionist. A student who fits the profile of an academic achiever feels the need to answer every question on test, regardless of their exposure to the material. Academic are achievers are the students who put pressure on themselves to get the highest grade, while also aiming higher through extra credit assignments. This form of perfectionism hurts students’ self esteem, as they are not always able to get the highest grade possible and make common human errors. A teacher can help academic achievers by acknowledging students’ efforts and the process of learning, rather than solely complimenting student’s grades. Academic achievers should also be encouraged to reflect on their efforts and find areas of weakness in order to improve themselves. The next form of perfectionism is the risk evader, these students can’t always demonstrate their abilities due to physical or mental blocks and instead opt to not perform at all. These …show more content…
As a child, I was often seen as having above average intellectual skills and this article resonated with me because I share many of these traits, in a mild form. I can remember multiple times as a child when I would avoid sharing test scores or standardized testing information with my peers in order to maintain a status of success and excellence in their minds. In elementary school I would make many drafts of projects in order to ensure that my ideas would come to life exactly as I had envisioned them. In fact, even through high school, I would often rewrite essays the night the assignment was due in order to achieve perfection in my mind. Although my experience with perfectionism was not detrimental or particularly unhealthy, it is easy to see how it could be in students who are seen as the “smart kids” and who have pressure to succeed to the highest level of their ability. I believe as a teacher it is very important to teach students the value of failure and to allow for mistakes to be made in order to help students grow. Once students realize that they can learn from their mistakes, they will be less likely to be worried about making them. Ultimately, I believe that failure is the key to growth and success in all students and that is something that needs to be expressed very clearly when teaching gifted

Related Documents

  • Brilliant Essays

    A major barrier to the effectiveness of formative assessment is the fact that the mark generated doesn't usually count towards a student's final grade and therefore students can be less motivated to put a great deal of effort into such assessment. Brown and Knight (1999) suggest that if used in an effective manner, formative assessment can help students to be more autonomous in their learning and to reflect on their performances and take responsibility for their academic growth. As a tutor, I tend to rely on formative assessment with my students; the reason for this is to…

    • 2537 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Brilliant Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example, one teacher could view a student as lazy or annoying, while another teacher could see the same student as intelligent and hardworking. Being a Classroom Chameleon can prevent the teacher from getting to know the “whole” student, claims Pope. Students become Classroom Chameleons in order to help them succeed, but this habit could be doing more harm than…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Students not passing test or missing multiple class days can fail the class, Alfie Kohn explains “Grades tend to reduce student preference for challenging task”he also states that they tend to reduce the quality of students thinking and they are not valid, reliable, or objective (Kohn1). Teachers should always understand the students when their having a bad day.Evaluating teachers would show whether the students understand the lesson that the teacher has given. Johnathon Jeffrey states that “Students evaluating their instructor can provide insight to on what they are doing well in and how they can improve also can be a tool for growth, not as cause of stress” …Teachers can learn how to improve their instruction quality, without fearing retribution from administrations.…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    They don’t want to be teased at for not understanding a subject or they are too shy to asked about with a huge class. It causes students to not pay attention and start getting low grades which is something the school educational system needs to improve on. It is also stressful for learning facilitators to manage so many kids in one day when in reality it should be a right amount of students instead of so much which effects the child…

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Self Esteem Importance

    • 1367 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Students who consider that they have failed at school do not listen to any other person point of view although it is positive or helpful for them. This fact is due to the self rejects to change in order to preserve a consistent and organized world. The school is a place where self-esteem may be threatened by failure, rejection or limitations (Purkey, 1970). To avoid this, García (1982) suggests that teachers not only have to praise good results but also the methods, ideas or attitude. So, as she says, the teacher must be a "booster" instead of dedicating to just correct mistakes.…

    • 1367 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Resulting in the fact that students shouldn't rate their teachers. These teachers work hard to educate their students. It isn't the teacher’s fault that the student is unprepared for class, and lacks the motivation to study. "The bad news is that students often conflate good instruction with pleasant ambience and low expectations. As a result they also reward instructors who grade easily, require less work, are glib and chatty, wear nice clothes, and are physically attractive… Plus students will penalize demanding professors or professors who have given them a bad grade, regardless of the quality of instruction that a professor…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The group’s grade assesses the group’s output, but does not showcase feedback for each team member on his or her own skills. Not only does this unfairly score students, but it also does not help the individual improve his or her own weaknesses because he or she has not received accurate criticism; the individual student also will not be able to shine or experience his or her own mistakes. When a teacher notices a student struggling in a specific area of study, she may cater to that student to provide materials or extra help to assure they will succeed; however, with group work, the student’s struggle is shadowed by the overall group’s work ethic. Not all students are well suited to work in an environment in which they must rely on others to complete his or her work. In 2007, 67% of the public voted that public schools should be responsible for dealing with behavioral, social, and emotional needs of students (Alters).…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    An Effective Teacher

    • 1160 Words
    • 5 Pages

    There is a particularly significant gap between advantaged and disadvantaged students, which explains a similar gap between American and Asian students (Intellectual Capital). The lack of shared knowledge that slows progress creates both a national excellence gap and a fairness gap in America. This leads to misbehavior among the best and worst students, reducing their willingness to learn. As a teacher, it is key to reduce this misbehavior in order to kindle their interest in learning (Intellectual Capital). If children aren’t willing to learn, then they aren’t going to learn.…

    • 1160 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Those students’ daily lives are extremely complicated; they are unrecognized, isolated and often have a variety of unhealthy characteristics which contribute to anxiety. These students’ education system should change in order to better assist them. By identifying the gifted using characteristics such as level of motivation and not academic scores and offering gifted services which give them a challenging, accepting atmosphere, the neglect of gifted students will end. All these gifted students require, like all human beings, is recognition and compassion. Ending those stereotypical myths and granting these students what they deserve in their education is not too much to ask in the twenty-first century, especially when the majority…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some people make false claims by saying that standardized tests can only hurt students, rather than help them. If standardized tests are used correctly, they don’t only provide accurate, fast result; but they also help us to find out where the United States struggles and needs to improve on. It is true that in some cases, these tests can cause anxiety; it is good to prepare students to deal with unwanted stress and tension. Some teachers spend class time doing useless worksheets that do not benefit their students in any way, so teaching to this test would be a much more productive use of time. Since these tests contain crucial information for a student 's future success, it is very important that they learn all of the material on it.…

    • 1441 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays