Struggle For Smarts By Alx Spiegel Summary

Improved Essays
In the article “Struggle For Smarts? How Eastern and Western Cultures Tackle Learning”, The author Alix Spiegel, opens the readers mind, showing how different each culture really is. Although we are all human and live on the same planet, it is surprising to learn how different we all really are. There are plenty of differences in the way everyone was raised and taught, and the way each individual puts forth effort. Back in the year 1979, a man named Jim Stigler, who at the time was a student at the University of Michigan, traveled to Japan to study another cultures teaching and learning strategies. A study he witnessed was in a classroom of young students. The test was to see if each student would give their best effort. Each student …show more content…
Li studied the difference in learning beliefs between Asian and American children. Jin Li has recordings of two different mothers and sons. One mother and son who were American had a conversation, the mother told her son that intelligence comes from the books he reads. He does not enjoy reading, and it seems as though he has a bad attitude toward books. From this, he is taught that even if he does not enjoy something he just needs to finish what he starts. The other conversation was between a Taiwanese mother and son. The son plays the piano, the more he practices, the more he improves. The mother tells her son that with great attitude and practice comes great achievement. The little boy practices hard and tries his best. Although he may mess up, he does not give up. This shows he likes what he does and he likes the outcome of it. The difference between mothers is that one tells her son he needs to learn what he is given, while the other tells her son he should love what he does in order to achieve the best possible outcome. I believe if a person loves what they do, they will work harder and give forth more effort and attitude. If someone is given something they may not understand , nor like, they will get frustrated and give up on it. It’s easier for a person that likes something to give positive attitudes toward it in order to figure out how to solve or practice for it. Another study was done with fifth grade students, the students were given an impossinks problem. The American students gave up on the problem within the first 30 seconds, while the Japanese worked on the problem for an hour, having to be stopped by their teacher. This shows a difference in how a child in each culture is taught. The American students gave up because they were not taught how to do the problem, in this culture they are told that their is always gonna be someone there to

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Chinese Philosopher, Hsun Tzu is the author of “Encouraging Learning.” He became a significant figure towards the advancement of Chinese philosophy. Continued education was the focus in this article; however, Tzu being a firm promoter of education chose to highlight human nature in the natural world. He covers topics ranging from how to conduct yourself as an educated person to how to apply that knowledge learned. To educate ourselves according to Confucius’s way according to our reading “Encouraging Learning”, it states…”one must do so by duty, order and ritual”.…

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The father thought the teacher thought his son was a slow learner because of his culture. For instance, his father explains Indian traditions, the “turtle shell’ served as the first…

    • 1701 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Document 1 1. The authors felt that the basic problems facing the Western Roman Empire is that a lot of the population is excluded from political responsibilities. They were not able to organize themselves so they could be protected. Also they could not serve in the army. Also their economy was going to a downfall, most of the people were agricultural laborers bound under the feudal system to work on his lord’s estate.…

    • 1775 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In some extent, I disagree with Amy Chua’s view about “Chinese mother” and “Western mother” in the article why Chinese mothers are superior. Although, she thought that Chinese mothers are superior, in my opinion, her some description about Chinese mother and reasons that support her ideas are unconvincing, exaggerated even extreme. We cannot define Chinese mother as what she said in the essay. Her view of Chinese mother looks like the truth, but actually far from the fact.…

    • 909 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The general argument made by Alix Spiegel in his work Struggle For Smarts? How Eastern And Western Cultures Tackle Learning. Explains that there are different ways that different cultures and country's approach teaching and the education of their children as the United States continues to fall behind in academic excellence many countries continue to grow their academic prowess. More specifically the author points out that in Asian countries the students dont just give up when faced with a problem that they have not worked on the students in the United States just give up after a short period of time where students of the same age and intelagence level will sit and work on a problem for hours. Alix states that althouigh students in the…

    • 489 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Some people believed that a cultural bond is the essential root to their happiness. The time spent with family carried lessons for them to fundamentally grow. Sometimes family experiences presented educational lessons that different perspectives. However, the way people valued their family`s role in education could determine the quality of how they wished to learn. Richard Rodriguez`s priority of education separated him from the cultural ties he had with his family, which negatively impacted his perspective of education throughout his academic life.…

    • 1460 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Moreover, I was guilty of stereotyping Americans. I should not have believed the stereotype about Americans that most of them are overweight. Before I came to America, someone told me that Americans are obese, and if I wanted to keep a good figure, I’d better cook Chinese food and eat as little American food as I could. After I came here, I noticed that a large amount of girls I saw on the downtown streets and campus own a thin and healthy figure. I realized that this stereotype mislead me, since just a few people are overweight.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Learning is a part of life that can bring a lot of fortune or keep you in the dust. Education has a big part in our society, it's basically what people use to judge your success. Books are the primary source of learning, books contain knowledge and power. However, in Albert Huxley’s, Brave New World education is very different from our own. In his novel there are three different forms of learning “sleep teaching, book learning, and craft teaching.”…

    • 1212 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Holism, in the concept of self, can be seen as the most widespread understanding when it comes to Indigenous education and philosophy. It is understood, within the perspective of Indigenous groups in Canada, that an individual has four elements: intellectual, emotional, physical and spiritual. This concept can often be seen as an expression through a visual concept known as the Medicine Wheel. The Medicine Wheel is a modern holistic concept with the intention of representing the Anishnaabe Indigenous worldview based on a foundation of holism and creation. Within the wheel is “cardinal directions, the four races of man, medicines, values, teachings, the interrelationship between different aspects of creation, and cycle of life, as well as everything else…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This link between culture and classroom instruction is derived from evidence that cultural practices shape thinking processes, which serve as tools for learning…

    • 602 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Elizabeth Wong’s story, The Struggle to Be an All-American Girl, she reveals denial and shame towards her parent’s culture to illuminate the importance of having multiple cultures in a person’s life. Though reading this story one can discover her denial towards her Chinese culture was because she just wanted to integrate and be like the rest. The majority of children will be forced into ideas that are presented and taught by the parents. The parent is only passionate to keep the traditions that are passed down through generations. This is where high expectations are enforced by the family members which could lead to pressure.…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Sick Leave Case Study

    • 1268 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Culture profoundly influences how people think, communicate, and behave. Culture at times can be hurdle to understand the other’s views and which in turns make the transaction (verbal/nonverbal) difficult (Congden, Matveev, Desplaces, 2009). Differences in culture between business executives, for example, in this case, the work culture, tradition of Japan teachers and foreigner can create barriers in the understanding, action and implementation process. In the case study Kelly has thoughts as per her upbringing in a Canadian environment where 5 days a week working is good, as important to personal life is must. A culture where there are equality among the genders, whereas in Japan, people are so committed with their work that they work on Saturday and often stays late even after working…

    • 1268 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The ten given tips mentioned in the video all seemed to be very effective ones to implement in the classroom if done correctly. Classroom management is crucial, and can definitely make a difference in-between a well ran room and a chaotic classroom. The first tip mentioned was beginning the year tough. I definitely believe teachers have to set the stage of what is expected and stand their ground to instill the procedures and expectations into the students, but this should also not be taken to extreme measures where students are uncomfortable or scared to be in the class. Also, it’s easier for the teacher to set certain procedures such as bathroom signals, attention grabbers, or classroom rules at the beginning of the year so the students know…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    (Markos, 2017). Each student in the class, as well as Ms. Gruwell, was subject to be defined as disabled simply because of a misunderstanding of cultures. In the readings, Black Ants and Buddhists, Ms. Cowhey describes the challenge of teaching students who come from cultural norms or a culture that is different than hers. Ms. Cowhey approaches the challenge by educating herself and incorporating diverse perspectives into her lesson plans that would pertain to many students, “I found it was better to be proactive, honest, and humble enough to admit I wasn’t confident about how to handle it than to bank on a strategy of avoidance.” (Cowhey, 2006.…

    • 1413 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Another issue of Japanese education, especially when compared to western countries, would lie in the effects of Japan’s homogenous characteristic of its citizens. While this unique national trait helps bring the country and its inhabitants together as a whole, in schools this tends to take away from individuality, especially when it comes to students that were born differently from the standard Japanese. In an article in The Japan Times, the most popular English-language newspaper in Japan, O’donoghue (2015) says that although differential treatment is not incited in Japan, “by emphasizing sameness they [the teachers] could be instilling conformity and intolerance of difference.” Each student’s uniqueness seems to be taken away due to this…

    • 1719 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays