Upward Comparison Theory

Improved Essays
A study has shown that Internet appearance exposure and magazine reading exposure were correlated with higher internalization of thin ideals, appearance comparison, weight dissatisfaction, and drive for thinness in adolescent girls of mean age of 14.9 years. (Tiggemann & Miller, 2010). As mentioned in lecture, an average American watches 5.13 hours TV per day. (K.Dalrymple, personal communication, October 26,2015). This data shows that television is a dominant media that plays a great deal in our lives. In addition, according to Sparks(2013), young females tend to compare their own bodies with those that are frequently depicted in the media to the extent that they may start to develop various eating disorders like bulimia or anorexia nervosa. …show more content…
Social comparison theory refers to the constant self-judgments against others in order to see how we measure up due to the need for self-evaluation.(Andsager,J.L., 2011). There are two types of comparison. Firstly, downward comparison refers to the process where individuals compare to others who are less than themselves to feel better about themselves. This will result in a boost of self-esteem and aiding individuals to keep their status quo. Secondly, upward comparison refers to the process where individuals compare themselves to someone better. This will in result in either self-dissatisfaction or motivation for self-improvement. According to Andsager (2011), exposure to thin ideal in media may lead to social comparison, where media consumers compare themselves to people in the media (E.g. diet product ads) using mostly upward comparison, which would lead to an increase in body dissatisfaction and a decrease in …show more content…
In my opinion, the use of the experimental method and survey are the best research methods for this study. Through the use of a pre-test and post-test experiment with a treatment and a control group, one would be able to show the effect of exposure to diet product ads models on college male students. However, one should take into account that the result of this experiment is probably not generalizable to all college male students since each individual may have different levels of neuroticism and may be affected or not affect by media images in different ways. In addition, with the help of issuing surveys during pre-test and post-test would allow me to know the participant’s feelings about their body satisfaction through their self-reports both before and after their exposure to the diet product ad. However, one should account for socially desirable responses from the participants when using the survey method. As participants may be able to guess the purpose of this study and hence give socially desirable responses when completing the surveys for both pre-test and post-test in order to make themselves look better.

In this research study, college male students from all regions of America would be randomly selected. This proposed study is particularly interested in finding out the effects of exposure to advertisement models of diet product ads to college males. College males are chosen as the research

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Fa Fad Diet Analysis

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The overriding problem that influences the newer generation through persuasive advertisement is the fad diet that supposedly promise dramatic results for the user. Young adolescents in our modern society today is directed into the path of having a slim, toned body like those models in magazines or television. To have that ideal body, people are often willing to try anything that promises them to help them lose weight easily. It's this desire to look or feel better or the worries about getting disease that are weight-related amongst teenagers that are health threatening rather than being wellbeing. Those businesses that promotes the fad diet plans, they take advantages of the fact that people are inclined to lost weight fast.…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout history companies have customarily used advertisements to sell products to potential consumers. Generally speaking, the objective of an advertisement is to gain the attention of a specific group of people to which the company knows their products are more likely to sell. However, current times suggest, rather than enticing young men and women into purchasing their products, many advertisements can lead to negative behaviors such as eating disorders, self esteem issues, and representing themselves in a provocative manner. To clarify, in an effort to fit in with society's standard's of appearance, many young women and men turn to eating disorders. Ad's from companies such as, Victoria's Secret, do little to deter this type of behavior.…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many ads do promote an impulsive and shallow lifestyle, but many others have adopted and continue to adopt a more positive, intelligent tone. In the arguments previously posed, there is an example of a restaurant chain that uses its position to promote healthy, moderate eating. Advertisers have discovered that if they run positive ads promoting solutions to problems like child obesity, bullying, and poverty, consumers will support their products as a…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    How has advertising effected the average American teenager? Advertisers use a variety of techniques to influence people's attitudes, beliefs, and behaviors. In this day and age the typical American teenager is a Gold mine for anyone selling a product. According to the article, “Price of Happiness” advertising is persuading people in the wrong way.…

    • 424 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Culture and the effect it has on obesity 1320 The purpose of this paper is to talk about why the Americans culture is so obesite. Obesity is one of the ongoing problems in America that has affected the American culture in many ways some more then others and has affected the way other countries view America when it comes to weight. Considering there are close to 50,000 fast food chains across the United States, with McDonald's being the largest restaurant chain, this information does not come as a surprise to the average American. Considering we see some form of a fast food restaurant when driving to work or anywhere else for that matter.…

    • 1515 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a result, this goes to show consumers pay attention to the symbolic values (Law, Wong & Yip, 2012). Moreover, in a recent study (Budgeon 2003; Davis, 2002; Kimmel and Messner, 2004; Vigorito and Curry, 1998) found advertisements have made males more self-conscious about their bodies and appearance and influencing their self-identification through their bodies such as by their fashion, level of fitness, and how they evaluate themselves (Tan, Shaw, Cheng, & Kim, 2013). Advertisements are more detailed for women than for men. Furthermore, women notice the diminutive details in the ads, while men focus on the actual product itself. Magazine advertisements have an understanding men do not want to be perceived by other man as caring too much about their fashion or how they dress.…

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    While we are familiar with how advertising can affect how women feel about their appearance, we don’t tend to think as much about its impact on men. Advertising has a negative influence on men and boys by presenting unrealistic and unattainable images that are impossible to achieve for the normal man. Three articles address the same issue in different ways. The article “Body Image Pressure,” from The Atlantic, written by Jamie Santa Cruz, discusses how the ideal image of man has changed, and the effect these changes have on an average individual. James S Fell, in his article, “How the Media Makes Men Hate Their Bodies Too,” mentions how the media influences a person to become muscular.…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Media Influence On Women

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages

    As the women in media have thin and hot body, many teenagers are going on diets or exercising too much because of artificial images of women in media. Young people believe that they can have a thin or hot body like models when they do not eat. However, many young girls do not know that avoid eating can lead to anorexia and eating disorders. When the rates of teenagers’ dissatisfaction of their body increase, it also brings out eating disorders among men, women, and girls (Americans). According to the statistics, ninety-five percentage of between the ages of twelve and twenty-five have eating disorders (Crow).…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In today’s society, more and more teens, young adults, and children are being influenced by celebrities. Celebrities can influence one’s wardrobe, hobbies, and even what they eat. In the article "Kids Finally Speak on Celebrity-Based Ads for Food and Beverages," the authors discuss children's and teens' reactions to celebrity-endorsed food and beverage commercials. They have concluded that the youth of America is largely influenced by celebrities. Some are concerned that the celebrities should not be such an influence on children.…

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Food commercials have a major impact on child obesity as they influence children to consume and buy junk food products that are not good for them. Many studies conducted by the IOM show that food commercials have a direct affect on a child's preference of food. “Marketing strongly influences children's food preferences, requests, and consumption” Studies have also shown that food advertisements and commercials can affect the consumption of food in children. “American children spend $30 billion of their own money annually on foods companies design to tap the market.” These two factors show that there are undeniable correlations between food advertisements/commercials and child obesity in America.…

    • 256 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Previous research has found that television may negatively affect the body image of young women. Tiggerman and Pickering (1996) found that these effects did not just come from the amount of television viewed, but they could also come from the appearance-focused shows. Studies have shown that body dissatisfaction can be seen in girls as young as the age six years (Dohnt & Tiggemann, 2006; Tiggemann & Wilson-Barrett, 1998). This is what led researchers to come to the conclusion that the amount of time spent watching television is not to blame for this effect, instead, it is the type of television that is being watched. Since research shows that image insecurities can arise in young girls as young as the age of six, the blame is not to be placed…

    • 1396 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Coupon Survey

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Survey assessment: The survey part of the experiment produced mostly quantitative data. After analyzing the results of the survey, a few interesting findings to support the hypothesis were found, as well as a few that did not necessarily support it. When asked directly, consumers’ answers overwhelmingly supported the original hypothesis. Displayed advertising for healthy food seemed to have a substantial effect on consumers, due to the large sector of survey respondents who claimed to notice such ads. However, it appeared that the most significant result was the distinction between the effectiveness of some types of advertising in comparison to others.…

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Overweight people who are jealous of those more physically active than them will have a low self-esteem because they will want to achieve what normal weight people have achieved. “Perhaps the tendency to compare oneself to others possessing the thin ideal is the main source for the negative effects produced by the exposure to thin ideal media” (Gayle R. Bessenoff). Overweight people who are motivated by those that are more physically active than them will have a high self esteem because they will be encouraged to do better and live a better live like the normal weight people. “However, upward comparisons may also serve to enhance the selves by eliciting behaviors to improve oneself” (Higgins). Both reactions create comparisons with the “superior” as the media calls it and creates a sense of different social levels in the world.…

    • 2061 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    (Kurubaran, Al-Dubai, & Quershi, 2012). The promotion of wrong role models is one of the psychological factors incautiously affecting young people to feel the wish to look just like the examples in print and media. Advertisement influences this particular group of age especially as they are in a period of life where they feel insecure and in the process of forming their image of them selves and the world around them. The examples they are exposed to make them believe in order to fit in society, to be successful or popular they need to show the same features. The ability of advertiser to use modern technology such as Photoshop does additionally distort the picture of a healthy body shape and makes it even harder to match the…

    • 912 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Images of thin, beautiful women and muscular, wealthy men form stereotypes for many that have led to a decline of self acceptance. Many of the images portrayed by the media shape individuals to think that thin is beauty and most will attempt by all means to achieve it. Teenagers (mostly women) on social media experience body shame, body dissatisfaction, weight dissatisfaction, lower body esteem and higher levels of depression. The internet and other similar sources like magazines can have a negative effect on the mindset of a human being. For example, many people at a certain point in their life has looked into a magazine and wondered why they were not created or structured like the celebrity shown.…

    • 1322 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays