Should Student Athletes Be Paid

Improved Essays
The NCAA currently debates that student athletes should be compensated for everything they do. There are not a lot of high school athletes that can’t even make it to the NCAA, but for those who don’t realize how much they get involved in. Although the debate is currently balanced on both sides, it is not ethical to pay student athletes. For a division I athlete, they are clearly already getting a full ride leaving with a college degree and no debt. Why should they be paid more? One clear reason that it is not ethically right is the title IX situation, another would be the benefit compared to the cost. Along of with Title IX, discrimination through out the team. For example, how would you pay each player? Would you pay by starting verse not starting? What about those who don’t get equally playing time. Title IX states that no person in the US should be excluded from participation, be denied benefits, or subjected to discrimination under any program that receives Federal financial assistance, …show more content…
While the athletes are paying other students are out working making a job, but these students are out working to pay the debt that the athletes do not have. Student-athletes are amateurs who choose to participate in intercollegiate athletics as part of their educational experience, thus maintaining a distinction between student-athletes who participate in the collegiate model and professional athletes who might be students as well. Participation in collegiate sports is not a student-athlete 's job. It would not be morally right to pay these student athletes. It would not work out in the way that everything would work out equal. Title IX takes away most of the hope in paying college athletes. Along with the cost of it, it would add up but from there you have to pay other people more for doing their job. In the end, schools would lose money instead of benefits they are currently getting from the athletic

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    College Athletes Paid

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages

    It is a populous opinion to think that it would help the athletes through college if the received money. This in the long run would be sending them into the real world unprepared. “But the evidence presented in this book does demonstrate a consistent tendency for athletes to do less well academically that their classmates” (Shulman 51). If this continues to happen there will be a world full of people who used to play sports with no degree and no way to make a living. It is said that the graduation rates in sports are the lowest (McCormac 24).…

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Paying College Athletes

    • 1342 Words
    • 6 Pages

    According to some, getting a full ride to a college isn’t enough. Many think that college athletes should be getting paid because their sport, is their job. Others think that getting a full ride to go to school is enough and college athletes get enough benefits as it is. College athletes may take an educational decline to support their team but these athletes have many tools for success that everyday students are having to pay for. College athletes shouldn’t be paid to play sports because many are already getting scholarships to help out the financial aspect of college, recruiting athletes would be even more based on having a powerhouse, wealthy school than it already is, and these athletes are given an opportunity to become professional athletes,…

    • 1342 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Paying college athletes and giving them a higher status degrades professional sports players, because most athletes join professional teams to be payed for playing a sport. Student-athletes should not be compensated because their wages would not be fair, and the sport should not replace their educational…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    College Athletes expect too much such as getting paid, but don’t actually focus on school. The athletes want money but if they were to get paid they wouldn’t show up to class and they would not know how to manage the money properly and not deal with the money in a childish type of way. The players want money but who is going to pay for everything else that they need to have? If they paid all of the athletes they would be paying a lot of money to all of those athletes. College athletes should not get paid because why should they in the first place?…

    • 1236 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Out of the huge amount of student athletes only a handful are drafted. Why begin to pay college athletes if a large percentage will probably not even make it to the big leagues. College student athletes will begin to be amused by the pay they receive and it would be such a drastic change that the student athletes would not know how to manage their money correctly. Not all students have been taught to manage money wisely. However, there will be students that are capable of making smart choices with the money they receive if college athletes were to be paid.…

    • 1996 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If the NCAA started paying these athletes, the students would be too closely compared to true professionals, while actually they are students at a university. Most college sports team are not profitable enough to pay their athletes, let alone operate the cost of their institution. Some colleges do not have enough benefits to make every single athlete happy, and if they start paying athletes as well, the powerhouse colleges will become so much more powerful and destroy the lower colleges because they can not receive the best available players. Professional players mainly choose which team they will play on based on whichever franchise will sign them the biggest contract. “Students are not professional athletes who are paid salaries and incentives for a career in sports.…

    • 2398 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On College Athletes

    • 1418 Words
    • 6 Pages

    This plan will likely require passing grades and a college degree. If athletes are given money to play, then they will worry more about their salaries than their education. Athletes will worry about making money rather than their classes. College athletes are first and foremost students and they need to concentrate more on their classes than sports. A college education is essential for the future, making it more important than sports, thus college athletes should not be…

    • 1418 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is much debate over whether collegiate student-athletes should be compensated for their work at their respective universities. Some individuals believe that student-athletes should be paid because, like most college students, they do not have a lot of money. Many also believe that student-athletes should not be paid because they are getting to attend an institute of higher learning at a lesser price. Collegiate student-athletes should not be paid not only because they are already attending college at no cost while being able to earn money for themselves, but student- athletes also receive some benefits that are unavailable to the average college student. Individuals who argue that student athletes should be paid do not take into consideration that the athletes are already being compensated for their talents.…

    • 1185 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Athletes and students attend college as an extra preparation before entering the “real world” . There is still a veil of innocence or “a sanctity amateur sports [give players that] would be violated if players were paid”(“Paying”). If college athletes were to be paid, they will be too worried about earning their payment, rather than playing for enjoyment while gaining an education. College athletes already receive scholarships that hold “little incentive to promote the “student” half of the student-athlete model”; what will keep a college-athlete locked into their studies if college players are already receiving paychecks(“Introduction”)? If college athletes get paid, it defeats the university’s purpose and makes the university unable to fulfill its duty and goal for their college-athletes to be educated at a higher level.…

    • 1372 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Evidently, the courts feel that the NCAA is looking out for the athletes and the rules already in place justify why they cannot be paid. What the NCAA constantly brings up is the money they receive does not go into their pockets but back into the schools and programs the NCAA has to offer. Ways the NCAA uses the money is by “increasing the amount of money in scholarships offered” and by “upgrading and refurbishing equipment and facilities” (Steele 522-523). I feel this is a good thing the NCAA is doing but for many college athletes the money they get in grants and scholarships is not enough and they have to get a job. Having to get a job takes away from time they could be out practicing with the team and working on class projects/assignments.…

    • 1489 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays