Representative Representation Research Paper

Superior Essays
Representation and its Purpose
Nicholas Mickulin nicholas.mickulin@gmail.com October 3rd, 2014.

The concept of a representative government was meant to be as representational as possible. The idea of a representative government is to filter the opinion of the masses by electing a small elite to run the country. This idea of government is actually contradictory because a representative government never represents everyone in the populace. In a representative government, representatives can only represent the majority that elected them. The representatives do not care about the minority in their district or state because the minority did not elect them. In reality, the majority is the only one being represented in that district or state, while
…show more content…
It does not expand the number of representatives in total, but rather redistributes them to make them seem more representative of the population. The problem with this idea is that it only eliminates a lot of congressional districts and does not actually give more representation. It does not give more representatives to the same area, which is crucial if you want to maximize representation. Another problem with this idea is that it solves almost nothing. For example, a state with three congressional districts that has two republicans and one democrat in office combines all the districts into one super district. The republicans get 54% of the vote while the democrats get 46%. Under the fair voting system, the republicans would still have two seats and the democrats would still have one. Imagine states that have only one representative. They will not benefit from this plan because they already have a state wide election. Salam even admits to this in his article by saying, “fair representation voting won’t do much good in states that send only one member to Congress”. Low population states that only have one representative are the states that are least represented as a whole. An entire state has to choose one representative to represent them in the federal legislature. Something has to be …show more content…
The concept of a representative democracy is flawed and will continue to be flawed because someone’s opinion will be left out. This does not mean however, that representative democracy cannot work. Many countries, including the United States, have managed a representative government quite well. It is only now that people are talking about changing the system of representation because a state of gridlock is occurring. Both major political parties in the United States are refusing to work together to solve problems. This causes many individuals to rethink about how their system of government works. These individuals tend to complain more about how their government doesn’t represent their political party or their political ideas, rather than how their government does not represent enough of individuals of different

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Sources from Procon.org said, “If the election depended solely on the popular vote, then candidates could limit campaigning to heavily-populated areas or specific regions (Procon.org).” The candidates would not have to do as much campaigning because they would only be focused on the battleground states. Even though if the U.S only had the popular vote, all states would become battleground states because there would be no pledged delegates to put the final state vote in. The election process needs to be changed, there are several fixes that could be implemented into Congress to fix the electoral system in the United States. The Electoral College takes the power away from the citizens that they should have in a modern democracy, like voting directly for presidential candidates most importantly. According to Jerry Fresia, "None of our rights have been handed down; they have all been won through resistance.…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The representation in the EC is broken. The popular votes don’t also don’t align with the Electoral College votes. In addition to all this, the system was based on the premise that we were not knowledgeable to make an informed decision on who our president should be. That fallacy is vastly outdated because we have channels devoted to seeing our state legislature at work. We are more than informed enough to make decisions regarding the future president of the…

    • 507 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Electoral College Faulty

    • 1346 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This causes him to believe that the institution is failing as a democracy. There are two major limitations to Edwards’ argument. His bias is very noticeable throughout the book. This causes his support to become weakened since his is not providing a more balanced approach. Secondly, the United States was not built to emulate Greece and…

    • 1346 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Voting Argument Analysis

    • 2029 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Where my one vote swings the whole state” (Reasons). If the one vote doesn’t make a difference in the overall election, then there’s no point in voting anyways. Another reason is that there will be no change. Since the older, rich, and white citizens are the majority of the polls, what they vote for would be what occurs. The views of voters and nonvoters are on separate poles.…

    • 2029 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They only interact with the citizens of the states they are trying to win over. Because they already know the votes of the other states. Then the argument of it helps with recounts and litigation. Lots of citizens can not vote, so that decrease the number of people voting and you only have to do a recount if the election is close. But if a candidate winning the majority of the votes there would be no reason to…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Every citizen’s vote should count in America, not just the votes of the partisan insiders in the Electoral College. The Electoral College was necessary when communications were poor, literacy was low, and voters lacked information about out-of-state figures, which is clearly no longer the case.” This quote by Representative Gene Green reveals the faults in our current presidential voting system and the need for it to change. It has been an example and a basis to newly formed democracies all over the world, but the election to choose our nation’s leader isn’t as fair as it seems. While every citizen’s voice is heard in the public polls, ultimately it’s the Electors’ votes that select the new president. Therefore, I believe that our election…

    • 1339 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Candidates don’t visit every town of the battleground states and the citizens don’t have the opportunity to meet and ask all the questions they want to them. But this might also result from according to State University, a lack of votes. As they worded it “Presidential candidates might ignore states with small populations if not for the electoral college. Under the current system, candidates campaign in whichever states the election results are expected to be closest. Under a national popular vote, critics say, candidates would focus their attention on capturing areas with the most people and the most votes” (stateuniversity.com).…

    • 1617 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some U.S. citizens believe that it is unfair, while other argue that it is the only way to choose a president. The electoral college is outdated and should be discarded because smaller states don't have a large impact on the system and the disaster factor. It is up to the people to recognize wether the system should be discarded or saved. Smaller states like Rhode Island and Maine never even lay eyes on any campaigning. Why is that?…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Xlandia Government Essay

    • 2008 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The citizens were therefore unable to have a say in their laws or have their choice of executive. Therefore, a presidential system must be established to ensure that the country has the citizens’ best interests in mind. The president should be able to veto laws as well as suggest them to the congress. However the laws should only be able to be passed if they are both signed by the president and agreed upon by the congress. In only a presidential…

    • 2008 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Effects Of Filibuster

    • 1468 Words
    • 6 Pages

    This makes the voters angry with the political system and can lead them to stop caring about the political process. The filibuster also brings less accountability to the voters. This takes place because representatives are not doing what their voters want them to do, as stated in the previous few sentences. All of this leads to no responsiveness from the government which interferes with all of the five democratic values. With this in mind, political science can help understand the filibuster with respect to the democratic values.…

    • 1468 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays