Cathy Davidson Project Classroom Makeover Analysis

Superior Essays
Relevance and attention work hand-in-hand, but they work differently from person to person. The one-size-fits-all model of standards calls for a student who is expected to learn only in the way that he has been taught and only what he has been taught; however the one-size-fits-all model does not represent every single student. It fails to recognize the different types of students⏤some who may have learning disabilities or who may just not be genetically constructed to attain lessons in the traditional way that has been used over the centuries⏤and instead catalogues each and every one into a single category when it comes to education. Cathy Davidson, in her article “Project Classroom Makeover,” cries out for a change in the educational system …show more content…
Every student can fit into the one-size-fits-all model of standards, but not every student can fit into The One-Size-Fits-All Model of Standards. Every student is their own model of standards because every student has his own highs and lows and minimums and maximums. Limits to a student’s education in any topic that catches his attention is the cause of eventual boredom and declining motivation, which Davidson believes is the cause of students dropping out of school. In “Project Classroom Makeover,” Davidson details her visit to a middle school and highlights her observation of a young green-haired girl who sat absentmindedly while the other students fussed about Davidson’s appearance, both literally and figuratively. The young girl showed no desire to participate and even “[looked] defeated by school,” (61) but by the time she began to draw that all changed. Her attitude is justified by her teacher, who tells Davidson that the young girl has a learning disability and only began to fare better in her studies when she was sent to that school. Her talents and abilities may not make the young girl the best possible candidate to be The One-Size-Fits-All Model of Standards, but it does allow her to create a standard for herself. The untapped potential inside her could not have been reached for more standardization; rather it was reached by taking a completely different turn in how she was learning. Other students seeking to liberate …show more content…
Wikipedia informs researchers, amateurs or not, of whatever it is they may be inquiring about by using countless genius minds who put a collective effort in including what is in their scope of knowledge to whatever topic may be at hand. However, crowdsourcing is not just prevalent in the digital world. It can also be found in the smallest of towns, specifically in the technique of teaching used by Davidson’s own mother-in-law, Mrs. Davidson. By using games to aid her students in further understanding the lessons she taught previously, Mrs. Davidson uses a form of entertainment to retain the attention of her students in order to promote learning. Her use of games caters to the way she knows students want to keep learning: through acquiring and retaining attention. In both the iPod experiment and the way Mrs. Davidson teaches, the common factor is how the system was altered to fit the needs and thoughts of the individual student. Both methods help the cause of reinvigorating

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In John Taylor Gatto’s essay, “Against School,” Gatto writes about his perspective on the American public school system that he believes is not as beneficial as it is expected to be. He begins by explaining that teachers and students are bored inside classrooms simply because students are not taught better qualities such as critical thinking or curiosity. Instead, they are “schooled” rather than “educated” so students only learn how to conform. Gatto goes on to describe the goals of school as, “making good people, making good citizens, and making each person their personal best” (117). He later comments on Inglis’ interpretation of the functions of modern schooling.…

    • 1581 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In her iPod experiment, Davidson worked with colleagues and Duke students to modernize the traditional, standardized classroom educational paradigm. Davidson describes one of experiment’s objective, “it was also an investment in student-led curiosity … interactivity, crowdsourcing, customizing, and inspired inquiry-driven problem solving. At our most ambitious, we hoped to change the one-directional model of attention” (54). By effectively executing the iPod experiment challenge, Davidson initiated social change and successfully equipped students with competencies necessary in the 21st Century digitally centered workforce. Furthermore, in this example the technology and the collective efforts to implement it into the Duke classrooms can be classified as social change by challenging the status quo of how to teach and what to teach students; this experiment helped pave way for a new educational paradigm shift away from standardization and towards digital student lead…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    At the turn of the digital era, it is crucial for the educational system to acclimate and prepare students for new progressive career opportunities. In Cathy Davidson’s essay, “Project Classroom Makeover,” the use of personal, professional, and cultural anecdotes are used to strengthen her argument for the use of more innovative, collaborative, and technological teaching methods in the classroom. Davidson’s relevant organization and incorporation of the Duke iPod experiment and United States job market and educational history illustrate the need for educational renovation and greatly advance her claims. However, the second half of her essay complicates her main argument for digitalization and instead focuses on the need to replace the dehumanizing standardization of education and combining play into the classroom by focusing on children whose talents fall outside of the system’s norms and her mother-in-law’s outdated teaching methods. Davidson and other esteemed…

    • 1369 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    New Era, New Education In the excerpt “Project Classroom Makeover,” Cathy Davidson, a distinguished member of Duke University’s faculty, strongly advocates for the disposal of the “one-size-fits-all” education standards, despite her standing at an Ivy League school. Through Davidson’s more personalized approach, there could be a rise in greater individual success as traditional and out-of-date techniques of teaching are replaced by more interactive and modern ways. However, a complete eradication of traditional ways of learning as Davidson prefers has its limitations when compared to an education that incorporates the new with the old.…

    • 1051 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A crowd-sourced, collaborative education is a smart alternative to top-down learning, but it can easily become counterproductive. “Project Classroom Makeover” by Cathy Davidson showed the success of collaborative education with Apples Digital Campus. “The Naked Citadel” by Susan Faludi showed the destructiveness and failure of crowd-sourced education at The Citadel. In the case where crowd-sourcing failed, it was because of a lack of supervision. When crowd-sourcing succeeded, a professor was involved from the beginning.…

    • 1692 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    There are so many different types of institutions, ranging from religious institutions to work institutions. But in Karen Ho’s article “Biographies of Hegemony” she talks about educational institutions and how “smartness” is not just knowledge based, but also appearance based as well. Karen Ho dives into the study of the new educational system and how manipulative Wall Street is, starting with Ivy League schools. The discussion of Wall Street shows exactly how much power it has over the student’s minds and their decisions. The concept of standardization, student inequalities, and the conformity in a school environment are all explored in the pieces “Project Classroom Makeover” by Cathy Davidson and “Biographies of Hegemony.”…

    • 1749 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This experiment served not only to show the effectiveness of the iPod, and other electronic devices, as learning supplements in an education environment, but also inadvertently showed off the ingenuity of students when not confined to the rigidity of standardized education. Davidson writes, “The real treasure trove was to be found in the students’ innovations. Working together, and often alongside their profs, they came up with…

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Her youth allows her not to care about fitting in with her peers and society. Furthermore, this youth allows her to question something that has widely been considered acceptable by…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This piece of work shows that although these students may possess many great features such as being intelligent, respectful and hardworking, all the effects are not so positive. Students should be respectful but not be afraid to challenge their authoritative figures, they should not be forced to learn a variety of things against their will nor be walked through life instead of being independent, and if they do have to learn certain subjects then they should also be taught how to build character. We live in an age where everyone is okay with being ordered around just to get that good grade or promotion. Society is so used to being told what to do that at times they may not even realize that most decisions they make are not their own. Also though students may be getting more intelligent, knowledge and following rules does not make someone a great person, character does.…

    • 1679 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How I Used Public-School While reading the essay “I Just Want to be Average,” by Mike Rose, I noticed how his schooling experience was opposite of mine, there were similarities that lied within our home life, as well as coming from poverty and then making it in the end. During my time in high school, I had my own battles to fight every day, I was homeless, had a hard time finding the courage to make it through class and was stealing the bare necessities to make it week to week. I overcame this with sports, finding my own courage and believing in a school official who didn’t let me down. Eventually, I found my place in high school, despite how unpromising it looked for me in the beginning.…

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Velcro: The Glue That Holds Our World Together In “Generation Velcro”, Dorothy Woodend discusses the issue of society’s lack of knowledge, caused by things like Velcro, video games, and a general “lack of suffering” (Woodend 207) experienced by generations past. She compares the lifestyle of farmers to that of the modern generation, who she criticizes for not having the same work ethic, self-sufficiency, and practical skills. The essay presents a flawed opinion on the abilities and upbringings of today’s youth, based on the author’s disdain for modern technology and her extremely narrow definition of “practical knowledge” (206).…

    • 602 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “Doing School” by Denise Clark Pope , a senior lecturer and alumni at Stanford Graduate School of Education, Pope explains her thoughts and research on different school dynamics and what kind of students they are producing. First of all, what does “Doing school” even mean? According to Pope, Doing school is a term she uses for students and teachers finding ways to succeed without putting forth as much effort. Likewise most students are achieving high test scores and grades, but at what cost? Health, Social, and Mental stability is being sacrificed for the sake of what we consider “succeeding”.…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Running Head: GAME BASED LEARNING Game-Based Learning (GBL) DANIEL MCDERMOTT (10090112) UPU0002 Academic Writing Off Campus 9 Oct. 15 Essay Question 1: Game-Based Learning (GBL)…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Collective Learning

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Collective Learning Technology has brought huge influences on everyone’s lives. The Duke University had brought iPod as an academic device and educational experiment to all the first-year class students. The iPod inverted the traditional role of technology, which has many new functions. Students not only can listen to music, but also use the iPod as an academic device to collaborate with others. This concept can be seen in Project Classroom Makeover, by Cathy Davidson.…

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    S. stated that feels that the common core standards are very important and she likes them, but she feels that students that are…

    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays