Summary Of Cathy Davidson's Project Classroom Makeover

Improved Essays
What holds society’s social structure together? Man-made and ever-evolving institutions such as race, laws, gender, practices, and religion are foundational in human social life. Cathy Davidson analyzes the educational institution structure and call for transformation in her essay Project Classroom Makeover; she discusses how the customs of educating students impacts their future skillsets and current attitudes and also critiques the outdated hierarchical classroom paradigm for obstructing students from reaching their brightest potentials. Furthermore, Karen Armstrong in her selection Homo Religiosus writes about ancient through modern eastern religious practices and reflects on their cultural purposes and significance in human social life. …show more content…
In her iPod experiment, Davidson worked with colleagues and Duke students to modernize the traditional, standardized classroom educational paradigm. Davidson describes one of experiment’s objective, “it was also an investment in student-led curiosity … interactivity, crowdsourcing, customizing, and inspired inquiry-driven problem solving. At our most ambitious, we hoped to change the one-directional model of attention” (54). By effectively executing the iPod experiment challenge, Davidson initiated social change and successfully equipped students with competencies necessary in the 21st Century digitally centered workforce. Furthermore, in this example the technology and the collective efforts to implement it into the Duke classrooms can be classified as social change by challenging the status quo of how to teach and what to teach students; this experiment helped pave way for a new educational paradigm shift away from standardization and towards digital student lead …show more content…
Skillsets that fall outside the curriculum of standardized education, such as arts and music, are implicitly deemed inferior to traditional skills assessed by standardized tests, such as mathematics and english. In a visit to a magnet arts middle school Davidson encountered a female student with eccentricly dyed hair who, despite being diagnosed as learning disabled, was an incredibly gifted drawer. Reflecting on the young girl’s artistic talent, Davidson acknowledges the student’s hovering institutional crossroads,
This girl’s talents don’t count on those tests, and yet she has a special and valued ability that cannot be replaced by a computer program. The problem is that her fate is to a large extent controlled by her performance on the EOG tests, and unless adults in her life---teachers and parents---are resolute in shepherding her along a path where her talents are valued, they may ultimately wind up underdeveloped

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    In Cathy Davidson’s, “Project Classroom Makeover”, Davidson analyzes and elucidates upon faults she observes in the American education system. In particular, Davidson introduces her own experiment, the iPod experiment, in which she distributes free iPods to all first-year Duke University students and all other Duke University students who have the iPod incorporated in at least one of their classes. Through the experiment, the iPod upgraded itself by having its learning experience enhanced. Similarly, in Jonathan Lethem’s, “The Ecstasy of Influence: A Plagiarism”, Lethem argues that individuals who have successful ideas should allow up-and-coming artists to use their ideas and build on it to make a unique, albeit heavily inspired, invention.…

    • 1592 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In both the iPod experiment and the way Mrs. Davidson teaches, the common factor is how the system was altered to fit the needs and thoughts of the individual student. Both methods help the cause of reinvigorating…

    • 1597 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Sharon Draper’s novel, Out of My Mind, the theme of the story is that you can do anything you want even if people around you are biased against you. It can overcome your difficulties and fears. When Melody was ready to take the test, she went to Mr.Dimming’s classroom to take the test. “You know I don’t think it’s appropriate for Melody to be here…” Melody types in,” I’m here to take the test.…

    • 242 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Cathy Davidson’s “Project Classroom Makeover,” Cathy discusses about how unlearning can lead for the positive change of education. Three example she uses to show unlearning are Duke’s introduction of the Ipods, the girl who had special abilities and talents, and lastly Inez Davidson’s unique classroom teaching styles. All these stories showcase that unlearning plays a huge role in education. Unlearning completely changes the way of how education functions and allows student to be more engaged into learning and create challenges that they have to think through. Duke and the iPod completely changed how an iPod could serve as a purpose to learn.…

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    At the turn of the digital era, it is crucial for the educational system to acclimate and prepare students for new progressive career opportunities. In Cathy Davidson’s essay, “Project Classroom Makeover,” the use of personal, professional, and cultural anecdotes are used to strengthen her argument for the use of more innovative, collaborative, and technological teaching methods in the classroom. Davidson’s relevant organization and incorporation of the Duke iPod experiment and United States job market and educational history illustrate the need for educational renovation and greatly advance her claims. However, the second half of her essay complicates her main argument for digitalization and instead focuses on the need to replace the dehumanizing standardization of education and combining play into the classroom by focusing on children whose talents fall outside of the system’s norms and her mother-in-law’s outdated teaching methods. Davidson and other esteemed…

    • 1369 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    New Era, New Education In the excerpt “Project Classroom Makeover,” Cathy Davidson, a distinguished member of Duke University’s faculty, strongly advocates for the disposal of the “one-size-fits-all” education standards, despite her standing at an Ivy League school. Through Davidson’s more personalized approach, there could be a rise in greater individual success as traditional and out-of-date techniques of teaching are replaced by more interactive and modern ways. However, a complete eradication of traditional ways of learning as Davidson prefers has its limitations when compared to an education that incorporates the new with the old.…

    • 1051 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A crowd-sourced, collaborative education is a smart alternative to top-down learning, but it can easily become counterproductive. “Project Classroom Makeover” by Cathy Davidson showed the success of collaborative education with Apples Digital Campus. “The Naked Citadel” by Susan Faludi showed the destructiveness and failure of crowd-sourced education at The Citadel. In the case where crowd-sourcing failed, it was because of a lack of supervision. When crowd-sourcing succeeded, a professor was involved from the beginning.…

    • 1692 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Karen Ho describes the smartness found in students not creative or intellectual, but is rather standardized and generic. On the other hand, Cathy Davidson seeks out to find individuality in order to help her students reach their full potential. In “Project Classroom Makeover,” the girl with the striped hair, had the inability to pass any of her end of the year exams, but discovered she had a talent where she could draw high detailed images. The hierarchies within the education system set a standard that an abundant amount of students cannot achieve, limiting students to certain skill sets. Similarly to Ho’s case, she describes the elite students as “standardized and generic.”…

    • 1684 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After reading the chapter “Project Classroom Makeover”, readers may have spotted that expert knowledge and collective knowledge, as well as crowd sourcing, were mentioned in the story, and more importantly, were being labeled as two completely different forms of knowledge acquisition that are in constant battle with each other. In fact, Cathy Davidson, the author of the story, stated how “crowd sourcing is suspicious of expertise, because the more expert we are, the more likely we are to be limited in what we even conceive to be the problem, let alone the answer” (Davidson 51). Basically, she is trying to communicate the idea that crowd sourcing is the better alternative to expertise on a given problem. Collaboration with different people…

    • 1652 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Cathy Davidson’s article, Project Classroom Makeover, one can easily see how biased and unrealistic the majority of her ideas and opinions are towards creating a new education paradigm. She has many valid points, but the amount of holes in her plans outweighs the benefits. What Davidson wants is an education to be interesting, while providing children with a successful start to life. While her intentions are possible, she is hoping for the wrong things to be changed in order for her scenario to work. Cathy Davidson strongly believes that standardization is inhibiting the ability for students to show their true potential outside of what is deemed important by the school.…

    • 1676 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This experiment served not only to show the effectiveness of the iPod, and other electronic devices, as learning supplements in an education environment, but also inadvertently showed off the ingenuity of students when not confined to the rigidity of standardized education. Davidson writes, “The real treasure trove was to be found in the students’ innovations. Working together, and often alongside their profs, they came up with…

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Cutting Edge Classrooms In Cathy Davidson’s piece “Project Classroom Makeover”, she voices her concerns about the lack of quality of todays education system. She thinks that America’s classrooms haven’t evolved enough to prepare students for our advanced society full of new challenges and networking. She argues that by adding more game play into curriculum, learning could become more engaging and interactive for the young students of the twenty-first century. Games are a way to add a whole new level of interaction in the classroom.…

    • 1531 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It’s through educational that we first come to understand the structure of society and the ways that power relations permeate them. Educational systems are thus one of the most important vehicles for hegemony, the process by which a society inculcates and maintains dominant ideas by portraying as natural and normal. As Habermas (1972) indicated, Adult education is a moral and political endeavor as much as it is a technical practice. Thus it is affected by its role in maintaining or challenging the social…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Sci/621 Research Paper

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages

    As teachers we have to equip our students to live in this kind of world. According to Sousa, “…children who spend their early years in front of screens will eventually have adult brains that are hardwired to process information at a frantic pace” (Sousa, 679). Technology has many positive aspects, but often gets a bad rap. According to Wedlock & Growe, “The problem is that technological innovations need to be transformed from tools of obsession into tools of education”…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Collective Learning

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Collective Learning Technology has brought huge influences on everyone’s lives. The Duke University had brought iPod as an academic device and educational experiment to all the first-year class students. The iPod inverted the traditional role of technology, which has many new functions. Students not only can listen to music, but also use the iPod as an academic device to collaborate with others. This concept can be seen in Project Classroom Makeover, by Cathy Davidson.…

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics