Private Vs Private Education Essay

Good Essays
Public vs. Private Education: When Interests Collide
Proper education is becoming increasingly accessible with each passing day, with parents who want their children to learn about the importance of a proper education. The parents/guardians want to have the choice to send their children to a reputable school that they will enjoy attending and where the children can improve their cognizance. However, not every child has this opportunity: some lack the funds needed to choose what school they want to attend while others simply don’t have any other choice. Recently, House Bill 2949 was passed in a 9-8 vote by the House of Representatives (Plemons) that would allow students this luxury of choice between private or public education. However, this
…show more content…
The bill has garnered a fair amount of controversy, and both sides of the argument predict different outcomes should this bill eventually be passed. Opponents of the bill say that it will ultimately cause public schools to lose funding, as more and more students would be admitted to private schools when given the choice. Those in favor of the bill believe that giving the students the ability to choose while excluding financial woes will ultimately benefit the student, as they can choose the type of education that best suits their academic inclinations (Eastes). Alternatively, those in opposition of the bill have listed their grievances, saying that when given the choice, more parents will choose a private institution over a public school, which means that the public schools will lose funding. Instead, the opposition believes that more money should be put into public schools, where there is a sort of “accountability.” In other words, there has been no proof that attending private institutions equals a higher quality education, whereas public schools have that credibility (Eastes). Correspondingly, the bill does not elaborate on how the parents are responsible for this account, only that the money in the account must be applied for academic purposes

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Since the 1980’s school uniforms is a topic that has been debated a lot. when schools and districts adapt or create a school uniform policy they have to look at the history, costs, statistics, court rulings and scientifically proven changes. Some of the pros of wearing school uniforms is it creates a safer school environment, higher academic grades, decreases discipline, and diminishes socio-economic barriers. A few cons of wearing school uniforms is it violates students rights, the policies can sometimes interfere with the government laws and rules and some of research is not 100% accurate. A compromise that could be made is having a dress code instead of a school uniforms or getting more accurate data and doing a fundraiser to help the pay some of the uniforms.…

    • 1123 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It is possible that the students are just disinterested in homeschooling. It is possible that the student would prefer to be educated in traditional schooling system and be able to experience it because most students in that age group are in public/private schools. Parents should not have the full authority on how their children should be educated because the children’s opinion matters too. If parents force their children to be homeschooled, it does not necessarily mean they will enjoy it and strive to do their best. Parental pressure on their children is a real issue and pressuring their children to only aim for A’s is stressful on students.…

    • 1636 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Generally, the charter school is known for going there because students choose to. Stereotypically, some people think that it is a type of school for people with a lot of money. Some might even think that it is a school for kids that get kicked out of public schools and have nowhere else to go. Controversial and experimental teaching styles. It has also been thought that charter schools have more funding than public schools, but little do they know that it is the other way around.…

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Narayan implies that quitting and moving to another school to get a diploma means that you care about simply going to school, rather than learning more about what you are passionate about. Unfortunately, this lack of passion is true for many students because to them, the goal is to get that piece of paper that proves they graduated, rather than leaving with knowledge and application of skills. Because of this, public education needs to be restructured in a way that will let kids understand what they are being taught in order to further their understanding later in life. Instead of making schools that create machine like students who are able to memorize and perform at the drop of a hat, schools should be encouraging…

    • 1252 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The intention of the education vouchers is to allow students from a poor performing school to have the ability to attend another school that can provide better education. The vouchers can act as a scholarship, allowing low income family to pay their children tuition at private school. Even though the voucher system has been around for sometime in some parts of the United States, its system and the effects is rather unknown to most of the public. With the voucher system becoming a heated topic, I would like to inform the readers the positives, the negatives, and the impact that it might have in our nation. The voucher system is a continuous debate whether it is positive or negative to our society.…

    • 1650 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Galen, the author of Home Schooling: Political, Historical, and Pedagogical Perspectives, provided good points behind why parents choose to homeschool. One of the reasons mentioned was that parents have more control over what their children learn. Some of the things that children learn in public schools proves to irrelevant and a waste of time, if a student is homeschooled their parent can decide what is and is not important enough for their children to learn about. Another reason was to reduce the effect of peer pressure. Public schools tend to be very over populated, which leads to more student interaction and in turn can lead to greater peer pressure among individuals; that could be reduced or even eliminated with homeschooling.…

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In fact, they might assist their child throughout all their assignments; making sure it is well-written, organized, and most importantly, correct. In return, this causes the child to understand and learn more at home while they are away from school. However, that act alone does not directly cause better grades. As a student who’s had their parent become involved with the school, it is suffice to say that parent involvement does cause grades to go up. This is because when a parent is truly involved with their child’s school, such as knowing the student’s teacher, it ultimately creates a high expectation for the student that pressures him or her to work harder in that class.…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The statement, they expect their children to have much, much more than training in basic skills, immediately makes parents realize that they want their children to receive a full and balanced curriculum. The parents can then realize that they do not want their children to become mindless drones who cannot come to a logical solution on their own. Ravitch uses pathos more in her essay when she is talking about the difference in education between public and private schools. “In affluent communities today, such schools are the norm in the public sector, not just the private sector. They were once the norm in ordinary American public schools.…

    • 1041 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Charter Schools receive public funded like traditional public schools, however; they can me more flexible and enact their own rules and techniques for teaching. Charter schools are most commonly found in low-income areas with failing school systems. They offer a choice for low-income individuals who would have other wise had to send their child to a public school. Critics of charter schools, most notably the teachers unions, argue that charter schools waste money that could have otherwise been spent on traditional public systems. They also believe that this “choice” that is now available, creates competition amongst schools, which will not have a positive overall effect.…

    • 1839 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    They want to remain the current policy and see Devos as someone who is disruptive to their position of power. They want to keep their dues money flowing and keep children trapped in failing schools. Besides, other politicians and parents also cast doubt above Betsy Devos’ vision. Devos’ reform can give parents more choices but will also lead to less funding for public schools. As a result, public schools are going to face huge difficulties on hiring good teachers.…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays