Non-Human Animals Have A Theory Of Mind

Superior Essays
“Describe some research studies which have addressed the issue of whether non-human animals have a “theory of mind ', and explain what these studies have allowed psychologists to conclude in answer to the issue.”

Chimpanzees are humans closest relatives and therefore are a good animal to study when attempting to assess whether non human animals have a theory of mind. This essay will attempt to first define what is meant by theory of mind, then will look at three studies and their approaches to researching theory of mind in non- human animals. It will briefly summarise, in turn, what each study attempted to achieve, how the study was conducted, and the subsequent finding of each study, specifically looking at areas of theory of mind which relate to chimps ' understanding of human problem solving and visual perception in both humans and other chimpanzees.

“Theory of mind” refers to the way in which people understand other humans as thinking beings. Hewson. C. (2015)A human can understand that another human has thoughts, wants and desires, for example, that are different to ones own. Hewson refers to this as a form of “mindreading”. Simply put, theory of mind refers to the way in which a person can understand that
…show more content…
(Hewson. C, Ramsden. P, Turner. J. (2015).p.85) One such study involving chimpanzees was conducted by David Premack and Guy Woodruff (1978) cited in Hewson. C, Ramsden. P, Turner. J. (2015) p.86. This study involved showing chimpanzees videotaped footage of humans attempting to solve problems of varying difficulty “mostly involving inaccessible food”Hewson et al. (2015).p.86)( The chimpanzees were then shown two photographs per problem, one with the correct and one with an incorrect solution. Premack and Woodruff 's findings showed that the chimps would consistently select the image with the correct solution to the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Chimpanzee Culture Essay

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Introduction This paper analyzes the question of culture in Chimpanzees. It also sheds light on how imitation in different communities can give rise to "culture." In the end, I have tried to extrapolate how imitating language could have given rise to different cultures in human societies, just as imitation in chimpanzees gives rise to chimpanzee culture (assuming it exists). While reading Chapter 4 of "The Talking Ape–– How Language Evolved," I found an interesting paragraph on imitation in Chimpanzees and how it could give rise to culture. This was an interesting fact because Burling was using this to point out that imitation plays an important part in learning a language, which is generally the basis of culture and social identity.…

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The article tries to prove the SBH by explaining brain development in birds and pair bonds in primates. Finally, the article turns to Microneurobiology to relate hormones to social bonding. Summary of the…

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When mentioning the perspective of how primates have changed over time, Ian Tattersall says that the “diversity in the natural world and the search for origins, however difficult, or perhaps ultimately futile, is worth pursuing for he insights it offers regarding how extant species, including our own, came to be the way they are” (Fleagle, 2012). The way scientists have been able to observe how these primates have evolved and their origins is through fossils. According to Erik Seiffert, they have been able to discover the primates’ evolution in between the locations of Africa and Asia. The scientists in this region have observed the transformation of the primates’ bones which has helped us to better understand really how much they have evolved over the years. Not only have scientists observed the fossils of the primates, but they have tested the evolved reproduction of them as well.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I carried out the visit in form of a field excursion that enabled me to carry out my own tests that helped verify my findings as well as finding more information from the expert O’Leary. I talked to the zoo worker in charge of the chimpanzees and this helped me get more information on their general way of life comparable to the human beings’ way of life. I carried out the field research so as to gain more evidential knowledge on the chimpanzees so as to be certain of the final details. The information that I have achieved from the databases and people as well as written materials may be obsolete and may have little validity thus the need to establish a field research to have well updated and validated data. I had a chance to interact with the chimpanzees and thus learn more about them assisting me in…

    • 809 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In another article written by Whiten and his studies group “Cultures in Chimpanzees”, Whiten does another research to see whether some cultural aspect in chimp communities are practiced through social contact and in this specific research Whiten and his study groups include social behavior within the chimp groups other than focusing on just tool use. Whiten and his studies group concluded in this research that “our data agree with experimental studies thathaveshownthatchimpanzeescopy themethodsusedbyothers to manipulate and open artificial ‘fruits’ designed as analogues of wild foods” (Whiten et al. 685). Whiten and his group concludes that chimps does not have a teaching system like humans but, chimps just copy and learn what other chimps do through social interactions. In addition, Whiten also observed with his group that the social behavior within the chimp groups are also acquired through imitation for example chimps scratching each other’s backs.…

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Culture is a society’s shared and socially transmitted ideas and characteristics used to generate behavior and reflect behavior and other primates besides humans, like gorillas, chimps, and orangutans do, in fact, have culture. Chimps copy each other into adulthood developing cultural behaviors by imitating their peers and research on gorillas, chimps and orangutans have shown they use tools, communicate with each other and even mourn the deaths of each other. This research paper will explain how and why chimps do things like, imitate each other, mourn the deaths of their peers, communicate with each other and with humans, and create and use tools. Chimps verbally communicate with each other with a series of different calls. They use alarm calls, mating calls, and greeting vocalizations (“About Chimpanzees,” n.d.).…

    • 1773 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Chimpanzees Abilities

    • 1480 Words
    • 6 Pages

    A controversial study conducted by Sana Inoue and Tetsuro Matsuzawa has shown that young chimpanzee have high capabilities in remembering numerical components. Three mothers and their 4 year old offspring were used in this experiment. Using a touch screen monitor connected to a computer, they were taught arabic numerals from 1-9. Unique trials were used with both numbers in order and in adjacent positions. All chimpanzees accomplished the task of touching the numbers in numerical order.…

    • 1480 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    As he speaks, the screen behind him features a slide show including photos of the animals that have been studied and videos from the experiments to show the proof to the audience. The first example Waal shows is a photo of chimpanzees observing Waal’s book he published regarding the behavior of chimpanzees (Waal par. 2). Waal comments on the photo in a comedic manner suggesting that the chimpanzees appear to be interested in reading the material. However, his comment may hold some truth.…

    • 1690 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Snake Species Essay

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In Figure 1A, Kvon et al, showed a mouse embryo with human ZRS enhancer activity to express where in the embryo ZRS expression is located. To highlight the differences in the ZRS region and when they may have occurred evolutionarily, Figure 1B and 1C show a comparison in the ZRS region amongst the species and the phylogeny of these species, respectively, to better comprehend the progression of the loss of the limb enhancer. Through this it was found that the basal snakes ZRS enhancer was similar to limbed lizards and the substitution rate correlated with the other vertebrates, but the ZRS in the advanced snakes showed an increased number of substitutions compared to the other vertebrates. Overall every species of snakes has a ZRS enhancer and it was further exemplified that the separation between the basal and advanced snakes was based on the evolutionary constraint on the…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For his experiment, Yamanaka used four transcription factors to see if they will induce pluripotency in the somatic cells. The goal was to take somatic cells, cells like tissue or organs and reprogrammed them using the 4 transcription factors mention earlier. These four factor will force the somatic cell to express genes important for maintaining the defining properties of ESCs. In the experiment Yamanaka used 24 embryonic cells transcription factors which were introduced to mice fibroblast by retrovirus vectors(Yamanaka,2006). After different experiment where these factors was induced to find their exact functions, only 4 of them was essential for the induce pluripotent transformation.…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays