NYFD Statue Analysis

Improved Essays
September 11, 2001 was a tragic day for Americans all over the US. The fall of the Twin Towers not only tore us down emotionally, but also allowed for our country to be rebuilt with a stronger resolve. Countless firemen, businessmen, and innocent civilians died, but in the end “our flag was still there” being held up by those who swore to help us when we were in need. A statue was later made in order to remember this date as well as to remember those who lost their lives. Despite the statue being inspired by a picture where three white firemen were lifting the US flag from amongst the World Trade Center’s rubble, the staue did not contain three white males but rather one white, one black, and one hispanic figure. Many individuals consider this as an act of disrespect from the NYFD towards the firemen that held the flag up and desire to tear down the statue, when in reality the statue should be preserved as it has more of a symbolic meaning and is property of the NYFD to do as they please.
Even though the statue is
…show more content…
Their reasons include the disrespect of firemen as well as historical inaccuracies that were made in order to make the statue. Despite making a compelling argument with those two pieces of evidence, the statue shouldn’t be taken down just because of those reasons. The NYFD contains at least 6% of black and hispanic firemen, some of which were part of the 9/11 response teams. Having that in mind, wouldn’t the multi-racial statue be more of an accurate representation of what happened overall? Furthermore, what about those who lost their lives but were never acknowledged for their bravery and sacrifice? By taking down the statue due to its “historical inaccuracies” and “disrespect,” those who were never found or shown in pictures as well as those who were would truly be disrespected as they would no longer be publicly acknowledged for their

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Creating a memorial can be complicated. When choosing a way to symbolize an important part of history, there are multiple factors that play an important role. A group or agency should consider the cost and properly symbolizing the event or person within the creation of the monument. The cost of a dedication is a necessary aspect.…

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tinker vs. Des Moines This court case took place in the December of 1965, in Des Moines, Iowa. A group of students at a local high school decided that to protest the Vietnam war, they would wear black armbands from December 16 until New Year’s at school. The principals at the high school learned of the protest, and established a new rule on December 14th.…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    September 11th 2001, left a huge impact on people’s lives all over the country. Michael Burke, a wall street journalist, talks about 9/11 in the article, “No Firemen at Ground Zero This 9/11?”. He explains how brave the firemen were on the attack of 9/11. On the 10th anniversary of 9/11, the firemen were not invited to ground zero to watch the remembrance ceremony, they were told they could watch it at another area on tvs. They were told there wasn’t enough room at ground zero for them, but invited politicians instead.…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Monuments are a way to capture an understanding of an iconic person or event in history and cast it in marble, granite, and bronze, so when erecting memorials, people should research the subject intensively, as well as, gauging the feelings of the citizens so that the ideas it represents will not be disputable or controversial. Furthermore, the location, the medium, and the design are essential elements of a monument, as all aspects represent embedded meanings. To start, before erecting a monument, the builders must carefully choose the site, building materials, and the design to ensure that its message will be beyond dispute. Furthermore, in America, we celebrate heroic people and just wars to commemorate their achievements and honor their…

    • 887 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Not for Admiration, but for Commemoration: Keeping the Confederate Statues Erect With less than one hundred years since it was established, the United States of America split gravely during the historical Civil War. Over the course of four long years, America witnessed the bloodiest battles fought on American soil. After the war was won by the Union and Reconstruction was in full swing, African Americans were given rights previously unavailable to them due to their status in the American social landscape. Yet inequality among colored people versus white people has still raged on for centuries since. Despite the Confederate defeat and shameful shadow left on the South for the decades to follow, Confederate statues remained and more were built to commemorate the fallen Southern generals and soldiers.…

    • 1731 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The third reason why I would vote to remove a Confederate monument in my town’s museum is because those who argue to uphold Confederate monuments are not telling the whole story. Their argument is weak. They say they fly the Confederate flag because of their heritage and want to honor their ancestors. However, when asked who their ancestor was, or what they fought for, they cannot answer. As stated on Backstory, one man, who used to do reenactments of the Civil War, quit after discovering what his Confederate ancestor had done to his slave.…

    • 595 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Other states such as Alabama has confronted the issue of racism and their racist heritage and came up with a solution such as taking down four flags that represent racist past. The mayor of New Orleans wants to remove the statues and consider replacing them with symbols that reflect the culture, unity, hope, and future of the city. The mayor and city councilmen would like to remove the status because they do not want anything to happen in New Orleans like it did in South Carolina. Not only are the flags or status being took down in New Orleans they are also being taken down in other places like Alabama and Mississippi. New Orleans local government have attempted to replace the confederate and slavery symbols such as the federal flag and the monuments to help lower racial…

    • 684 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Other than the Gettysburg National Battlefield and small, privately owned museums, statues of Confederate generals are the only way municipalities remember slavery. During the class discussion about the ways in which we remember slavery in the United States of America, I was frustrated that the country is in denial about slavery even existing and how bad it really was. In my head, I was thinking that instead of discussing whether to remove or keep statues, everyone needs to really talk about ways to remember slavery. The colorblind society of the United States is part of this denial of slavery and its effects on our society. As a history buff, I understand that societies that cannot hone and accept their mistakes of the past are doomed to repeat those…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Additionally, firefighters who rushed up the stairs of the World Trade Center’s Twin Towers rescued hundreds from inside the towers and brought them down to safety as well as rescuing others trapped by rubble at Ground Zero. Firefighters who left made the trade of a lifetime, sacrificing their lives to save those of others and preserve families. The children of 9/11 victims have been forced to grow and live their lives without grandparents, parents, brothers, and sisters. Reuniting and keeping families together lets memories to continue being created and cherished, allowing families being able to witness milestone events together instead of having those joyful moments abruptly ended by the death by a loved one. The National September 11 Memorial Museum commemorates the legacy of those perished in the attacks as well as the heroes that displayed countless acts of…

    • 356 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Displaying the Confederate flag is bigoted and sour grapes, in my humble opinion. The Confederacy lost the Civil War, yet a few southern states there were part of this failed rebel government hold onto this part of history by displaying the losing flag on their state banners. The first amendment protects individual citizens right to display the flag of the Confederacy on their car, or in their home, but this emblem should not extend to state buildings. Some historical revisionists have tried to down play the great roll Abraham Lincoln played as president in signing the emancipation proclamation, and some pro Jefferson Davis fans are pushing to show the valor of this man, who was essentially a traitor. Sorry, I do not support the southern cause from hundred and fifty years ago, and it is a cause that said women were inferior to men, and who wanted slaves counted as 3/4s of a person for suffrage purposes, but which would never give these individuals rights to be equal citizens.…

    • 944 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Confederate Monuments Dbq

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages

    (Doc B) In the United States, Confederate statues and monuments are being removed. These monuments should stay, like the Colosseum, these monuments are important pieces of history that can’t just be removed or destroyed. For example a statue of Gen. Robert E. Lee doesn't represent hate or Confederate ideologies, but it honors the general who lead and served the Confederate…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The articles I have analyzed for the past few weeks discuss the controversy over Confederate Statues. In the article "Confederate Statues and American Memory" by Roger Cohen, he presents a solution to the question of what should become of these statues; suggesting that the statues be removed from pedestals and placed in museums. While in the article "Confederate Statues and "our" History by Eric Foner, he discusses a statement made by President Trump discussing how the removal of these statues will destroy "our" history and heritage. Foner questions exactly whose history is being destroyed and who is included in "our", while elaborating on why these statues should be removed. A reminder of white supremacy, misleading history, slavery and the mistreatment of African Americans by those represented in confederate statues are causes of why many want to see these statues removed.…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “We are not going to allow this symbol to divide us along longer. … The fact that it causes so [much] pain is enough to move it from capitol grounds. It is after all a capitol that belongs to all of us.” (Ewell, Zach. Newsmax.…

    • 674 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Cfas Influence On America

    • 105 Words
    • 1 Pages

    I personally stand for this being considered, and added. Reason being I understand people want to invoke their freedom of speech, however when you burn a flag that many Americans fought and died in order to protect. It becomes nothing more than disrespectful. Not to mention when you burn an America flag in the middle of our streets, what does that show other countries around the world about America? The main way the CFA can help to influence this legislation is by lobbying state lawmakers, and by even trying to get member's of their own group elected in order to help push this agenda through.…

    • 105 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “American Flag Stands for Tolerance” takes inspiration from…

    • 883 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays