Mark Edmundson's Analysis

Great Essays
People are taught how to read at a young age. They progress through school learning various techniques to help read the material more efficiently. One way is learning to how critique their assigned readings, and helps the young adults develop a better understanding of the text. A student assists their reading skills this way, because they are now able to apply different applications to the text. This opens their minds to understand different ways to interpret the reading rather than just form an opinion, which is important because not every child is taught how to read in the same school or under the same level of criticism. The concept of having a “critical lens” is what is said to have been taught to students for reading, and is what Mark Edmundson has taken an issue with. Mr. Edmundson believes that teachers should simply just assign a reading, rather than attempt to teach them more critical ways to interpret a reading. …show more content…
Whether Mark Edmundson or others alike him realize it, teachers are still going to teach through their critical lens. It is something that is going to be impossible for anyone to change. Edmundson even applies his critical lens to the schools of criticism that he does not agree with. For example, he states “By a reading, I mean the application of an analytical vocabulary- Marx’s, Freud’s, Foucault’s, Derrida’s, or whoever’s- to describe and to judge a work of literary art” (1). Using the formalist school of criticism, he is trying to denounce the importance of intertextual school of criticism. He does not want people to criticize reading, but it is still a part of the education system, and that it would be extremely hard to change. Teaching to add a critical lens when reading is essential in schools. The teachers influence on a young student’s growth is key, because they are now able to share different perspectives based on the critical lens concept they are

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Hollander argues that school should give more importance selecting text that students should read in school. She argues that Current Common Core State standards focuses more on the skill student needs to learn to read and write rather than what they should read. Selecting the text according to student preference is more crucial than those skill, because those skills are of no use if the text the students read doesn’t interest them. The students should read the literature that would keep them engage with reading or piece that they would read with seriousness. Hollander states this in a quotation, “I like it when my students cry, when they read with solemnity and purpose, when the project of making meaning becomes personal.” (Hollander 1).…

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Williams goes on to talk about how this makes it hard to deny that popular culture in entering the classroom and is influencing students, even if professors aren’t covering it in their lessons. If teachers are going to incorporate multimodal writing into their…

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I think option number one is not an appropriate method because it deals with asking teachers that you respect to review your ideas. Just because you respect a person or colleague, it does not mean they are experts in evaluating a discipline system. All the options that I selected during the simulation were focused on helping students learn how to behave appropriately, providing opportunities for them to grow and succeed in the school environment. Some options provided were not appropriate. For instance, some options given were not effective methods such as writing the student’s name on a…

    • 1113 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Reading Reflective Essay

    • 2338 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Accordingly, having the students understand their reading through lessons in comprehension is a vital component of my curriculum. Additionally, I would like to label various aspects of the classroom, such as the door and the windows, to show that reading has use in everyday activities. Pointing out the ubiquity of letters and words in the world around them proves to children just how essential it is to learn to read. Lessons and Activities It is vital that students realize the purpose of learning, and when teachers teach through assessment and drill, the students cannot find the meaning or application of their learning. Strickland (2005) explained, “Children do need to learn by reading, but what teachers need to do is support them as they read, so they can learn what real readers do.…

    • 2338 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Literacy In Teaching

    • 477 Words
    • 2 Pages

    As the teacher you will have to incorporate literacy into your curriculum, because various students will not do the homework of reading or writing. Many students don’t see the importance of the literature they are assigned to accomplish on their own. Literature is the basis of every subject. This being said, as a teacher, you have to know your content thoroughly, so you can connect different ideas together to help your students understand the content. Moreover, to be an effective teacher, you have to acknowledge your students level of understanding and how well they comprehended the content.…

    • 477 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Shared And Guided Reading

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The use of both shared and guided reading is an important part of developing a child’s literacy in early childhood, they both allow the students to interact and be involved in the reading process, however they do have some fundamental differences in structure and classroom use. Shared reading for example is when either a small group of students or sometimes a whole class sits in with the teacher using a large text. The structure of a shared reading lesson involves multiple readings; the first for enjoyment and by the teacher. The experienced reader will read the whole text to the students ensuring to point to each word as they speak it. The teacher must use expression and emphasis where necessary in order to show the children how it’s read,…

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The reading process is a very important part of the learning process. As educators our main focus should be teaching our students to learn how to read. If the students can master reading they will have difficulties relating with content in the curriculum. We need to identify any problems with literacy in the early grades before it gets more complicated for the students. Although language acquisition begins at birth some students may not have a variety of experiences such as alphabetic principle and phonetic awareness.…

    • 1005 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Young children, like elementary students, need to express themselves in order to determine who they are as a person. When schools discourage creativity it hinds the students’ individuality, but also the teachers’ individuality. Having confidence in oneself allows educators to move away from the standard style of teaching and embrace new learnings, like creativity. Lastly, Davis says that schools can be an uncomfortable place for creativity. It elementary school teachers’ job to make the schools a comfortable place for creativity.…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Chris Crutcher argues in his article, “How They Do It”, that school systems should not become easily persuaded by the parents’ complaints to censor books that should be a part of the curriculum that their children benefit from due to the fact that the students can relate, learn, and build off of the books that are censored. Crutcher builds his argument throughout his article by including the use of personal anecdotes, pathos, and repetition. Due to the fact that Crutcher includes the use of personal anecdotes, he supports his argument. He builds his argument with the use of personal stories in hope to engage the readers. Crutcher describes an experience where one of his books, Whale Talk, was added as an all-school read for a school in Michigan.…

    • 1165 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this course we had to annotate an article over modeling in reading and writing. One of the areas that modeling needed is for guided reading. “Guided reading involves supporting students as they flexibly apply a range of strategies to processing text at graduated levels of difficulty.” (Jamison, 2011). When teachers model using a text or book this is unfamiliar to their students, it helps students learn, reading strategies, such as using context clues, letter and sound knowledge, and syntax or word structure. The goal of guided reading is for students to use these strategies independently on their way to becoming fluent, skilled readers.…

    • 1078 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays