Gerald Graff's Story Of Disliking Books

Better Essays
In “Disliking Books” (an excerpt from the 1993 book, Beyond the Culture Wars: How Teaching the Conflicts Can Revitalize American Education) Gerald Graff tells his story about growing up as a middle-class Jew in Chicago (22). He grew up disliking and fearing literature, history, and other advanced books. His explanation for his disdain towards reading was his fear of being bullied by the other boys in the working-class. Reading at the time was only acceptable for girls. When entering college, he entered the noncommittal territory of liberal arts and majored in English (23). The fear of flunking out of college replaced the fear of being beaten up. However, he still continued to find serious reading difficult. What caught his interest was when …show more content…
Graff states, “The moral I draw from this experience is that our ability to read well depends more than we think on our ability to talk well about what we read”(26). Literary teachers today do not understand the struggles of students that have not obtained critical vocabulary. The reason for this is that English professors got their education so long ago, that they do not even remember learning how to discuss books. This reason is why Graff likes to think he has an advantage as a teacher who can relate to the students who have grown up disliking books. Graff is persuasive in his argument, which is that he has an advantage with teaching literature. He states his argument in both the beginning and the end of the excerpt. He uses his real life experiences to persuade his audience that he can relate to students who experienced the same dilemma. He also cites books that can help his audience relate to what he felt when reading college assigned books. Education today is failing to teach students to be intellectual speakers and thinkers. Students struggle to keep up with class discussions due to the fact that they are often embarrassed when called on because they do not know …show more content…
I agree that Graff can help students to become more engaged and feel less bored when reading books. Having something to respond to can help students be on the closest possible terms with the text (26). Though I do not know Graff personally, his excerpt helps his audience feel connected to his life. In this day and age, a significant amount of teenagers do not see the importance of books. Since he knows how it feels, he can address this problem, and help figure out a method to solve it. This generation can be distracted while they are doing something that requires all of their attention. Phones and various social media cause students to lose focus while doing homework. Addressing and responding to issues can help readers feel more involved in the text. Feeling that their opinion is important can help students gain confidence in their feedback on literary works. Therefore, if students grow up disliking books, educators need to do something to fix it. Professors and teachers should educate their students on reading and thinking like an intellectual. Teachers should be more patient with students who have not yet

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    "The more that you read, the more things you will know. The more you learn, the more places you 'll go," said Dr. Seuss. These famous words by a great author show that the love and understanding of reading are important parts of learning. Both of these issues are part of the struggle educators now face: let students choose their own books to foster a love of reading or select books for their class to teach the skills necessary to understand the material they read. Some teachers believe that students who are limited to the books they choose will not be engaged and therefore not learn as much from the material.…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Hollander argues that school should give more importance selecting text that students should read in school. She argues that Current Common Core State standards focuses more on the skill student needs to learn to read and write rather than what they should read. Selecting the text according to student preference is more crucial than those skill, because those skills are of no use if the text the students read doesn’t interest them. The students should read the literature that would keep them engage with reading or piece that they would read with seriousness. Hollander states this in a quotation, “I like it when my students cry, when they read with solemnity and purpose, when the project of making meaning becomes personal.” (Hollander 1).…

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In this course we had to annotate an article over modeling in reading and writing. One of the areas that modeling needed is for guided reading. “Guided reading involves supporting students as they flexibly apply a range of strategies to processing text at graduated levels of difficulty.” (Jamison, 2011). When teachers model using a text or book this is unfamiliar to their students, it helps students learn, reading strategies, such as using context clues, letter and sound knowledge, and syntax or word structure. The goal of guided reading is for students to use these strategies independently on their way to becoming fluent, skilled readers.…

    • 1078 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    His opinions is that the books studied in literature class should challenge students’ curiosity, and engage them in the classes’ discussions, but foremost, the students should be able to relate to these books and understand them better. In order to support his point of view, the author uses facts and personal/anecdotal stories as evidences. Okun used the inductive reasoning to support his argument. In effect, he goes from very specific premises, in this case, his own experience as a literature teacher and the bad experience he had with classic readings, and draws out a more general conclusion that more simplistic and easy-to-read books might be better to ignite students’ interest for literature. Also, Will Okun tells the stories of how the reading of classics in his class makes the lecture boring, and how he caught up some of his students “snoozing” in the middle of the lectures.…

    • 1084 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I like this quote because it is important for students read, but more importantly walk away understanding and learning from the reading. Teacher can use close reading, which is beneificial for English Languages learners because it causes them to focus on pronouns (he, she, it, we). Also fixed expression, which are markers for knowing the language will. Learning a new language can be difficult and expression or pronoun can cause confusion and we as teacher will need to identify how to teach ELL…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    For the most part, our similarities such as goals, amount of comments, and the way comments are written and to praise or criticize became main points for students to learn to read and respond properly and adequately towards a student’s paper. Richard Straub’s reading is advice for students on what to do exactly when responding in order for them to manage a paper without to rely on the teacher; remember the teacher will not always be there to guide you. Writing in full statements and be serious on what you comment is what Richard Straub and I experienced with reading and responding. Small dull statements will lead the writer to nowhere near improving because he or she will be confused and not know what to do. Overall, Richard Straub experiences and mine are the same in terms on how each thing is being done and achieve the goal of helping the writer improve its…

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    But we as students need to read out loud so that we can get a better understanding of what we are reading. I do not believe that when the student fails to comprehend the reading that it scares them. I believe it helps most students to prepare themselves for the next level of…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    That is where we have the opportunity to make the difference in our student’s lives and teach them to become better readers. Teachers these days have to face many challenges in the literacy classroom. We have to concentrate on a curriculum and standards as well as assessments. But teaching is also getting to know our students and looking for ways to help them improve their reading skills. Finding what interest them or motivate then to learn, background and culture.…

    • 1005 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    One implication is the use of class discussion of books to enrich further understand and engage all students in the assigned reading. Socratic seminars and mock trials would be adequate strategy of these implications. These tactics get students involved and talking with each other, encouraging social constructivism. Another implication that I learned from my interview is that students need more explanation when reading more difficult texts to encourage enjoyment. These texts, like those of Shakespeare, as Walker mentioned are more difficult and make students not enjoy them.…

    • 915 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Shared And Guided Reading

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The students are then given the opportunity to read the story individually and are generally asked to look for answers to questions during reading, the teacher is able to prompt them if they lose meaning. After reading the teacher guides the students in a discussion relating to the text and the specific learning goal of the lesson. The session is concluded by a related follow up activity and some form of assessment. Guided reading has many benefits as it allows for a more individualised learning experience. It allows the students to interact in a scaffolded environment and discuss aspects of the text and help each other create a deeper meaning to the text.…

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays