John Hick's Soul-Making Theodicy

Improved Essays
John Hick a British Philosopher was born in 1922 in the United Kingdom. Hick also is credited as a profound religious epistemologist, philosophical theologist, and religious pluralist (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2015). Hick contributed largely to the world of theology, writing one of his more famous works, Evil and the God of Love, where the chapter Soul-Making Theodicy is included (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2015).
The attempt to explain the presence of evil, pain, and suffering has been asked and investigated throughout the centuries by philosophers, theologists, and lay man alike. The modern world is raw, yet pure, full of evil, yet full of beauty. The western belief in a God as an all-knowing, omnipotent, and beneficent
…show more content…
According to Hick, the Augustinian approach hinges solely on man’s fall from morality, which has led to the disharmony of nature (pg.358). The free will defense strives to support the view that God, the omnipotent being he/she has been constructed to be, has granted man the freedom to choose between “right” and “wrong”, no longer holding the responsibility of the occurrence of evil. The man’s choice to “choose” evil and has given rise to the misuse of this freedom furthering degrading the society in which we live. Hick describes the “fall from grace” or temptation to commit evil acts is labeled by Augustine as the flaw of man lacks plausibility and speaks to the inconsistency of the free will defense. Arguably, the question arises that why would a God that is all-powerful allow for the decay and death of his creation, permitting evil to enter the physical …show more content…
The Irenaeus belief that the creation of humankind in God’s likeness is an evolutionary process that takes continuous growth and development. Further, the complex struggle for survival and hostile environment in which we live requires spiritual and intellectual maturity to navigate the moral social demand. In other words, people were created as spiritually and morally immature creatures, only in the beginning stages of a long process of growth and development (p. 359). According to Irenaeus, humankind has committed youthful errors rather than an infinite crime that has ruined the whole of creation (p.359). If we accept the Irenaeus perspective we are accepting the fact that at righteousness and grace were lost, nor was there ever a fall from grace, but think of an unrealized future of good

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    This chapter covers all the basics of what Christians ought to believe about creation, what the Bible says about creation, and about how the world was good before sin ruined it. The next chapter in this book is about the Fall. In this chapter, Wolters covers what Christians should think and know about the fall, how creation is not identified with the fall, and that world is perverted due to the fall. The third chapter is about Redemption. In this chapter the main issues that are covered are how redemption encompasses creation, Jesus’ ministry, and the basics of what a Christian should believe about redemption.…

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Swinburne offers a free will theodicy. Before explaining his theodicy it is important to note the two types of evil. Natural evil, which is caused by disease, unforeseeable accidents, and natural disasters. Then there is moral evil, caused by humans intentionally doing actions they should not be, or evil caused out of negligence. God offers free will, humans have the power of make significant choices between good and evil.…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Commentary” Response “Commentary” is an article written and presented by Ben Stein, a comedian who doubles as a political and cultural activist. This article was written specifically to discuss the issues in today’s Western culture concerning religion and the way it is perceived by the general population. Stein seeks to defend religion in the face of an endless torrent of unacceptance and blame from society, and tries his best to convey his message for change to the audience. Ever since the beginning of recorded history, humans have shown a natural instinct to learn. Our very nature dictates that our curiosity must always be satisfied, and that for every answered question two more must rise to take its place.…

    • 1381 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The sermon “Sinners in the Hand of an Angry God” was given by Mr. John Edwards, a well-known minister, during the Great Awakening to a church congregation in hopes of educating them about the horrors of hell and alerting sinners that in order to be saved they need to turn to God for forgiveness. One idea that characteristically appears in the work of Edwards is that of human limitation. Mr. Edwards believes in the idea of human limitation and that no man is perfect or incapable of committing a sin, therefore we need to look to God for forgiveness and the opportunity of salvation. According to Mr. Edward’s beliefs, we as humans do not have the authority to judge a person’s soul or redemption as only God has this sovereignty. The Great Awakening can best be described as a time of revitalization of religious devotion that swept through the American colonies.…

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Augustine mirrors this belief of separation between the mind and the body almost exactly. Throughout his life, Augustine has committed multiple sins in which he perceives as deadly. Such as, jealously and greed, stealing pears merely for the pride of being “bad,” and the lust of sexual desires of being an adult. “Let them fade away from your gaze,” God- as the “empty talkers and mind’s perverters’ fade from it- who, assenting that there can be two wills hesitating over a decision, assert that there are two minds in a man, with two different natures” (Book 8, Chapter 5). This quote emphasizes the belief that Augustine has dealing with the separation of the mind and the body.…

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since mankind has the free will to make wrong decisions, evilness will run its course. In conclusion, Hick is saying in order for God to be who he is portrayed as, evilness must exist. If evilness did not exist, then mankind would not have free will and therefore, our universe as we see it today would not exist the way it does (The Soul-Making…

    • 1098 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Society creates many illusions of the world, some good, and some bad. But what about the way you perceive the world around you? Are you seeing the truth in the world or is it just a mere illusion of how you want to believe the world actually is. In the works Young Goodman Brown written by Nathaniel Hawthorne and Harrison Bergeron written by Kurt Vonnegut, one focusing on the evils of perceptive religion and the other focuses on the evils of the idea of a perfect political systems.…

    • 1607 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Perhaps the free will argument cannot apply when people die in a natural disaster, but it does apply when a person decides to commit a crime. Some evils may even be a combination of reasons; for example, imagine a firefighter that died while saving people from a burning house. This death can be justified by the fact that he was given free will to choose to risk his life for other people, and it also shows higher virtues, such as selflessness and bravery. Different kinds of evil can have different reasons for existing; a natural disaster killing hundreds of people is a very different scenario from a murderer killing a person out of spite. It seems odd to even group these kinds of “evils” in to the same category.…

    • 1221 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Satire In Brave New World

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Samuel L. Jackson once said, “We’ve come a long way in our thinking, but also in our moral decay.” This quote holds true today as society stays rapidly changing and people become more and more desensitized to the horrors of the world. The line between right and wrong fades and turns to a larger gray area, and many things that happen in society today make us question how we, as a collective people, ended up where we are and how we acquired the customs we have today. Aldous Huxley, in his novel Brave New World, uses a great deal of satire and exaggeration to express his concerns for the society he was born into and bring attention to the problems of moral decay, drug dependency, and brainwashing, among other things, in the world.…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hart thus engages with this thought and successfully forces the reader to consider his or her view of God and goodness in relation to evil. Hart earned his BA from University of Maryland, and went on to earn an MA and PhD from the University of Virginia in philosophy. Since, he as taught at the University of Virginia, the University of St. Thomas (Minnesota), Duke Divinity School, and Loyola College in Maryland. The book in review is his second full work, though he has written many articles. In fact, The Doors of the Sea is an expansion on articles he wrote; one for the Wall Street Journal, Tremors of Doubt, and the other for First Things, Tsunamis and Theodicy.…

    • 991 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I believe that Hick’s argument is definitely a compelling one, but I would have to disagree with the notion of the soul-making is a good reason for God to allow evil. In the Christianity doctrine God created a world without evil. with that in mind, it became evident that evil became part of this world when Adam and Eve disobeyed God by eating the forbidden fruits which ultimately lead to a world of chaos around us. I would agree however that evil in society lead mankind to continuously questioning if there is God as most atheist already have indicated. If the doctrine of Christianity is correct; therefore, mankind created evil not God.…

    • 264 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An analogy that we discuss in class to better understand Irenaeus point of view is Immunization shots at first when a child or person receives a shot it produces pain, but the pain is necessary to achieve a greater good. When a parent takes a child to the doctor they are not intentionally trying to cause pain to that child, but they know that if they do not receive the shot the change of them getting sick increases, or if they get sick the sickness is often times greater than it would have been if they had gotten the shot. The person or child receiving the shot is not the only one benefiting from it. Other people that come in close contact with the person benefits from the shots too. They shot would help to decrease the spread of the sickness from one individual…

    • 1492 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction John Hick, the British Philosopher was born in 1922 in the United Kingdom. Hick is credited as a profound religious epistemologist, philosophical theologian, and religious pluralist (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2015). Hick contributed largely to the world of theology, writing one of his more famous works, Evil and the God of Love, where the chapter Soul-Making Theodicy is included (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2015). The attempt to explain the presence of evil, pain, and suffering has been asked and investigated throughout the centuries by philosophers, theologian, and layman alike.…

    • 1508 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    All our life we grow up thinking the world around us is just peachy keen. Didn’t you? As children we think everyone and everything is good, we would like to hope this is the same case as we mature into adults. As we develop into adults we gain more knowledge, we learn not everything is going to be perfect. Adults gain a more pessimistic viewpoint in life, similarly how Shirley Jackson the author of “The Possibility of Evil” felt.…

    • 1057 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To reach happiness, Augustine says that a person needs to have God’s grace, which they are not able to obtain on their own. In this way, Augustine tells his audience, that human reason is not enough to reach happiness. Augustine uses his own life as an example of how a person can earn God’s grace: a sin, or a bad habit, which leads to despondency, leading to feelings of helplessness and guilt. At the lowest moment in his life, Augustine was finally able to realize that he had made all the wrong decisions in his life, beginning around the time that he stole pears from an innocent neighbor for no reason other than to steal them, and he finally turned to God’s grace. Then he repented, and he was able to perform contrition for all the things that he had done before he had received God’s grace.…

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays