John Hick's Soul-Making Theodicy Analysis

Improved Essays
Introduction
John Hick, the British Philosopher was born in 1922 in the United Kingdom. Hick is credited as a profound religious epistemologist, philosophical theologian, and religious pluralist (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2015). Hick contributed largely to the world of theology, writing one of his more famous works, Evil and the God of Love, where the chapter Soul-Making Theodicy is included (Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2015).
The attempt to explain the presence of evil, pain, and suffering has been asked and investigated throughout the centuries by philosophers, theologian, and layman alike. The modern world is raw, yet pure, full of evil, yet full of beauty. The western belief in a God as an all-knowing, omnipotent, and
…show more content…
Hick hits many points within the piece, some of which I have come to recognize and accept in belief. The fundamental Augustinian school of theology no longer supports the complex modern society in which we live. Hick introduces an alternative idea, including the frequent misuse of the Free Will Defense and the common idea of “the fall” of morality and righteousness. The idea that we have fallen from grace is a longstanding misconception perpetuated by western Christian theologians, however Hick provides a more rational defense for man’s inability to be in God’s likeness, our immaturity. After the reading, I have chosen to side with Hick’s assessment that “our fall” is more so an evolutionary process, one that develops man’s moral maturity. Man, as a moral and ethical being, in a hostile and uncivil world is contradictory and leaves us with little resources in the way of making morally “right” decisions. Hicks adds that we should not consider righteousness and grace as a far-gone conclusion, but the potential for an unrealized future of

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    This chapter covers all the basics of what Christians ought to believe about creation, what the Bible says about creation, and about how the world was good before sin ruined it. The next chapter in this book is about the Fall. In this chapter, Wolters covers what Christians should think and know about the fall, how creation is not identified with the fall, and that world is perverted due to the fall. The third chapter is about Redemption. In this chapter the main issues that are covered are how redemption encompasses creation, Jesus’ ministry, and the basics of what a Christian should believe about redemption.…

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Why We Hurt: The Natural History of Pain is written by neurosurgeon, Dr. Frank Vertosick, who transforms the vast subject of pain into an exciting and enlightening discussion that is highly engaging. Dr. Vertosick examines many types of pain including migraines, phantom limb pain, tic douloureux, ruptured discs, rheumatoid arthritis, carpal tunnel syndrome, angina pains, and cancer. Each chapter presents a clinical case, the different ways in which cultures viewed the disorder and the biology related to the disorder. The clinical cases of each patient give a personal touch and depicts just how these disorders can affect patients not only physically, but emotionally and spiritually as well. Dr. Vertosick introduces his response to pain by challenging C.S. Lewis’ statements involving the inseparability of religion and pain and how God intended for the pain of individuals as to create a way in which he was worshiped and looked upon to end suffering.…

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Richard Swinburne’s “Why God Allows Evil” tackles the concept of the Evidential Problem of Evil, justifying the existence of evil within the world we live in. He has a plethora of reasons on why God allows evil to exist, and one, in which seems to be pausing for the audience at a glance, is that he believes that the extent of suffering humans are capable is within the limits of the right God has to cause humans to suffer (Swinburne 93-94). In other words, Swinburne states that the suffering in which humans are capable of enduring is, in the end, all for a greater or better purpose. What Richard Swinburne fails to address is that this is not something that is widely accepted by everyone. There are those who suffer for all their lives, those…

    • 1023 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Philo's Argument Analysis

    • 1700 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Philo begins his argument from the existence of evil by introducing a few examples on why God has either not willed humanity’s happiness or that He does not believe that happiness is an essential component to the human condition. In his first argument, he asserts first that God is a moral being who values traits such a justice, kindness, and mercy. He then states that God’s scope is infinite, and he can perform whatever deeds he so wishes. Finally, he says that humanity is unhappy. This leads to the conclusion that God must not wish for the contentment of mankind.…

    • 1700 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The question - Why do I suffer? – functions as one of the foremost features of the human condition. As individuals, we habitually question the purpose of our own suffering and seek to rationalize it. Though universal and inevitable, this suffering may often appear unmerited or unjust. Throughout time, many have claimed a monopoly on this answer. In fact, one would be hard pressed to find a religion or philosophy that neither addresses nor justifies human suffering.…

    • 1367 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The modern world is raw, yet pure, full of evil, yet full of beauty. The western belief in a God as an all-knowing, omnipotent, and beneficent…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Individuals often ask, “Why do people suffer?” Possible answer is blaming Satan or even in some cases God, for the cause of suffering; a better answer is holding humans responsible for the reason people have to suffer. Satan is blamed for everything evil, which is true to a certain extent; however, not a lot of individuals take their own actions into consideration. Humans tend to blame other individuals for their actions because it takes away their feeling of guilt. I will show that it is in fact humans who cause a lot of the suffering in the world.…

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Johnathan Haidt is a Professor of Ethical Leadership and social psychologist at NYU’s Stern School of Business. He wrote the book, The Righteous Mind to “at least do what we can to understand why we are so easily divided into hostile groups, each one certain of its righteousness.” He states: “My goal in this book is to drain some of the heat, anger, and divisiveness out of these topics and replace them with awe, wonder, and curiosity.” In light of America’s increasingly unreasonable political polarity and developing shared mistrust, it is obvious that Haidt has a lot of work on his hands.…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    God’s power through this article also talks about how free will is still a factor in everything and so God can only make such an environment to thrive and so it is still human ambition to try to make a better life. Having said all this it seems that their suffering (humans) is created from their own makings when they don’t look for the overall impact of God. Therefore, this means that the “free-will theodicy” being one of the most frequent forms is the answer here to why there is suffering in the world. This can be distinguished based on the statement, “to create a creature freely capable of doing what is morally right, therefore, God must create a creature who is also capable of doing what is morally wrong” which relates to Emerson’s line of “Religion includes the personality of God”. Along with the answer of where suffering comes from it also gives the reasoning behind nature, “as a plant upon the earth, so a man rests upon the earth” therefore stating that it is to help out…

    • 635 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    3. The redemptive meaning of suffering in Salvifici Doloris Pope John Paul II addresses his apostolic letter Salvifici Doloris on the view of Christian meaning of human suffering. He specifies under the aspect of human suffering has salvific meaning. For the question of why do we suffer?…

    • 2072 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Human beings too often avert their eyes from suffering. We choose to avoid our afflictions in an attempt to deny the necessary evils within humanity. By not confronting the truths surrounding the worst in us, however, we become ignorant of a vital and possibly beneficial aspect of human nature. Both Dante’s Inferno and Shakespeare’s King Lear seek to bring attention to human suffering, illustrating our griefs and sorrows as consequences of our own agency. This pain that we cause ourselves can be handled in different ways that further define human suffering; each narrative profoundly explores both approaches, as Dante and Shakespeare portray suffering not only as a method of further inflicting pain on ourselves, but also as an opportunity…

    • 1472 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Biblical Worldview Essay Jimena Renteria Dietz Liberty University Introduction Theology is more than a pile of beliefs to memorize. Theology is the study of God’s being, and it is applicable to each aspect of people’s lives. In this essay I will share how God’s truths can be applicable in my vocation as a future psychologist. While the majority of people think that a science cannot be related to Christianity, Liberty University provide us classes with a biblical-worldview that prove that psychology can be an opportunity to let god uses us.…

    • 1209 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pain is a blessing. Philip Yancey, author of Where is God When it Hurts? (Zondervan, 1990), proposes many thoughtful illustrations of suffering in our lives. He describes pain in a curious fashion, but offers multiple points and recognizes various situations that commonly occur in our lives. Philip Yancey introduces life-changing ideas that involve the purpose of pain, where it comes from, and God’s role in suffering,…

    • 966 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The presence of unnecessary evil in the world has sparked controversy about the existence of an omnipotent, omnibenevolent, and omniscient being. The problem of evil, in its most basic sense, claims that the evil in the world is unnecessary and contradictory to the existence of the Abrahamic God. In this essay I will briefly summarize both the logical problem of evil given by Mackie and the evidential problem of evil provided by Rowe. I will then argue that these arguments cannot be made because humans are incredibly limited and cannot even comprehend the thoughts of God. I will then present a critique to my argument which will claim that despite not knowing God’s true intentions humans have defined suffering and as such an all good God…

    • 1614 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Suffering And Suffering

    • 1092 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Suffering is in the world all around us, it is a fact of life (2) and it can teach us many things that help us to become better human beings. People often blame God for all of the pain and tragedy in the world; if we are going to learn from suffering and allow it to teach us about the world whilst remaining faithful to God, we must understand that God created a good world and good human beings, His creation has been infected by the introduction of sin, which resulted in the creation of evil and suffering (4). Man was given the option to accept or reject God, Man chose to reject and that is what has caused him to sin and therefore create suffering (5). Part of learning about the world is understanding that people are not perfect, we learn this…

    • 1092 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays