Racial Discrimination In Gary Geddes 'Medicine Unbundled'

Improved Essays
For over a hundred years, Indigenous people have endured injustices and segregation in Canada’s Health Care system. In the book Medicine Unbundled, author Gary Geddes brings awareness to a shocking national story unfamiliar to many non Indigenous Canadians. The book includes heartbreaking interviews of Elders and their nightmares of unimaginable abuse and racism committed against Indigenous people in segregated hospitals and residential schools across Canada. In a country that prides itself on its diversity and inclusivity, the gap that lies between the rights of non-Aboriginal and Aboriginal Canadians is shocking. Looking into the future as an aboriginal nursing student and proud member of the Indigenous community, I am empowered by the …show more content…
Three different kinds of racial discrimination experienced by Canada’s Indigenous population are individual, institutional, and epistemic. To begin, individual discrimination refers to the behaviour of individual members of one race/ ethnic/gender group that is intended to have a differential and or harmful effect on the members of another race/ethnic/gender group (Pincus, 1994). It is an individual's racist assumptions, beliefs or behaviours and a form of racial discrimination that stems from the conscious and unconscious (Henry & Tator, 2006). For hundreds of years, the Indigenous community has endured acts of individual racism being viewed as savages, mentally inferior, abusive, violent, drunk, and untrustworthy. In Geddes book, he shares memories of Indigenous patients who faced this kind of discrimination in Indian hospitals across the country. One particular story of individual racism that stands out comes from Joanie Morris, a Songhess Elder. She tells Geddes that she endured racial slurs like being called a squaw by her colleagues in the Indian hospital where she worked as a nurse’s aid. She also recalls a visit to the doctor …show more content…
Institutional discrimination differs from individual discrimination because the discriminatory behaviour is set in social institutions like hospitals and schools. Institutional racism is made up of the rules, procedures and practices that deliberately prevent minorities from having full and equal involvement in society (York U, …). To examine this we need to investigate the quality of medical treatment and care Indigenous patients received in segregated federal funded Indian hospitals. The Indian hospitals had to run cost efficiently therefore it is not surprising that they were inadequately staffed. The hospitals were not intended to aid Indigenous people; rather they were established to segregate them from the white society. Furthermore, these Indian hospitals were fueled by economic and political systems that performed dangerous experimental treatments for tuberculosis, shock therapy, and forced sterilizations by poorly trained health care workers all fueled by economic and political systems (Geddes, 2017). The Elder Joan Morris explained how experimental treatment for tuberculosis at Charles Camsell Hospital was a near death sentence. This unnecessary primitive experimental procedure involved permanently collapsing a lung and removing ribs often resulting in death or badly disfigured survivors (Geddes, 2017). Another story profiles Kim Recalma-Clutesi whom

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Institutional racism is “racial discrimination that derives from individuals carrying out the dictates of others who are prejudiced or of a prejudiced society” (Henry & Tator, 2006, p. 352). Structural racism is “inequalities rooted in the system-wide operation of a society that excludes substantial numbers of members of particular groups from significant participation in major social institutions” (Henry & Tator, 2006, p. 352). The type of systemic racism most clearly represented within Donald Marshall’s case would be structural racism because the entire criminal justice system is involved. . Before this case occurred Nova Scotia already had a poor system of people who treated Blacks and Natives differently therefore this relates to the definition of systemic racism.…

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Racial categories should have no role in healthcare and research. First of all, race deters health care research because it adds an unnecessary element in the study. Including race distracts researchers and may cause miscalculations. This is because “both historical evidence and contemporary genetic research suggest that ‘racial profiling’ in medicine can lead to serious medical errors” (Rondini et al. 2007: pg.…

    • 1209 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Racial discrimination occurred before and after World War II and the African American community was treated unequally in every aspect. Jim Crow laws oppressed colored people even when federal and state…

    • 520 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The article claims first that it endangers the weak, despite failing safeguards with evidence that in three countries in Europe, “thousands” of cases have been found of doctor’s killing patients without a request. The second claim is that PAS corrupts the use of medicine as a tool for healing, and warps it into a tool for causing harm, further damaging the trust between doctor and patient. The third claim is that it would damage intergenerational family relationships, causing society to view the elderly as weak and…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Summary Of Healing Histories

    • 2269 Words
    • 10 Pages

    For centuries the Aboriginal peoples of Canada, comprised of the First Nations, Métis, and Inuit populations, have been the victims of gross inequity relative to immigrants of European descent. After an era of colonialism left them decimated, these ‘Indians’ were then subject to explicit, often violent assimilation endorsed and enforced by the Government of Canada. State and church-run institutions profoundly damaged Aboriginal culture, perverted family and community ties, and resulted in loss of life. This mistreatment also transpired for Aboriginals in poor health. Within the scope of recent memory, tuberculosis (TB) ravaged Aboriginal communities, and the disease continues to be problematic today.…

    • 2269 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Daschuk, the aboriginals felt like “this was a white man’s disease, and they hated the whites” (Daschuk 86) The medical techniques to constraint the disease were proven not to be very effective as diseases still took many lives (Daschuk 80). In addition, the author states that aboriginals were outraged that the government sold their land to the Hudson’s Bay Company without getting their consent and without giving them any financial compensation (Daschuk 93). In the second chapter, the author examines the federal government’s action in regards of the many health issues, mainly malnutrition, tuberculosis and smallpox, within the Native community. He…

    • 1070 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    One mechanism to counteract the impact of structural violence and mistreatment in the ILLC institution is protest. An example of this is when Yessenia belts herself and her wheelchair to a sapling at the building's front entry holding signs that say, “They abuse and kill children here” (Nussbaum 259) in protest after Teddy’s death with other patients by her side. However, this method did not bring any justice to the protesters because even though they landed a story on the Channel 5 news, Howard Anderson, an ILLC board member, counters by saying “Does...any rational person…really believe our society would be able to function if places like ILLC were suddenly no longer available? Imagine the death rate under those circumstances” (Nussbaum 261-262). Here, we see the recurring theme of being “rational” by the hierarchy to justify any action or event no matter how tragic or inhumane it is, and they continue to repress the outcry of the oppressed group.…

    • 1229 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    I Call It Murder Analysis

    • 1414 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Ansell’s writing in County. It directly showed the issue of patient dumping, the patient population it serves, and the problems with the current American health care system. The doctors in the documentary explained that patients at County are one’s in the worst condition, they are poor, black, brown, and are the ones that gets transferred to them from other hospitals. The reasons for transfer ranges from the other hospitals not having beds, but is secretly because the patient involved is black and/or does not have insurance. The patients at Cook “represents society as an illness,” and these patients are the ones most oppressed by society (I Call It Murder).…

    • 1414 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Ebola Crisis

    • 1664 Words
    • 7 Pages

    When the distrust lead the sick to avoid hospitals, they fled to their local communities, infecting others. The effect the distrust of the government had on its own people is difficult to measure. One truth is that the West African government let down its people. In the United States, “one of the primary purposes of the government is to ‘promote the general welfare.’ Health and safety, together with economic well-being, are the major factors that…

    • 1664 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Due to their lack of knowledge this would cause infection and many were killed because of infection. The way they would treat the infection was by bloodletting and according to wikipedia.com bloodletting is, “the withdrawal of blood from a patient to cure or prevent illness and disease. John Henry later passed from a stroke according to ibiblio.org. The Killer Angels is a very interesting book about the Civil War and the people who fought it. It was during a time where many lacked knowledge of cleanliness and many other medical practices.…

    • 693 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays