John Mill Why We Lie Analysis

Decent Essays
There are various reasons why people lie, some people lie to hide information and avoid harming their loved ones even though it is more likely to bring consequences that might not be reversible. Humans by nature are scared of being judged, feeling shame, or feel some type of rejection for being who they are or by having certain believes; most of the time all we want to do is impress and make our loved ones proud of who we are. Other people lie because they feel like it is giving up control, others because control or power over others to make us feel good about themselves. Immanuel Kant and John Mill have different views on the reason why we lie. According to Kant’s concept ideals of reason do not fit very well because all human beings are not …show more content…
According to Kant, the only important action is a good will, the rest of our actions only have a conditional value. Kant thought that other people could not relate to other people actions because they cannot take the same position or act the same way in a certain scenario, where someone might be able to contain himself or would end up lying to others because he is not in a position not to. So we end up making our own decisions according to what we think is best at that moment. What makes my action wrong not only depends on what I am thinking, it also includes what others might think of my actions. Depending on our actions we end up using people as our mere means which is not a valid excuse for lying, in the heat of the moment we do what “feels right”. This argument not only shows why lying is not acceptable but that is fundamentally the worst thing you can do to others. In the view from a Kantian lying is wrong in all ways, regardless of the intention and the person who does it, this means that if one person is able to do it then everyone else could try to do the same, there are no exceptions for a Kantian. The question persists on a case when someone is being accused of murdering someone, is this person is innocent, is there a witness who saw the person murdering another, perhaps the witness is lying because he has some personal issues with the accused. Is the so called witness trying to get even with the accused by accusing him of murder? There’s where the question takes place, is it valid to lie about something just because we have certain issues with someone when this lie will end someone’s life, when we know we are the only ones who can prevent this, as we are the only ones who know the truth. How can someone live with this type of action? Is it valid to let someone die because we are selfish and irrational human

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    This is where burns theory falls apart, because I don’t think burns himself could even answer this question without making, some sort of loophole in his theory. If we kill anyone of these people we are saying that the justice system can be wrong, and if that is true then burns idea, that the justice system is always right is flawed, and that the justice system is killing innocent…

    • 1468 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    You can’t be so sure if a victim is guilty. You cannot assume that the victim has information without the proof. You can’t really take any action without the evidence otherwise the person you tortured might end up becoming innocent. You have already made this man’s life miserable. His life is taken away.…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Particularism Vs Pluralism

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages

    For example lying to someone is seen as morally impermissible in most ethical principles such as deontology and Rule consequentialism. But if we add that I’m lying to a murderer because he wants to kill my brother, I am sure the perspective of people assessing the morality of the action changes. The problem with moral principles is that a single principle leaves out too many valid moral concerns, which leads to the inability to give concrete moral procedures. If we brought this problem on a larger scale, as we do with pluralism, it leads to complex and conflicting viewpoints. Going back to my previous example, If a pluralist were to tell me , "Don’t lie ", but in the same action say consider the principle that you shouldn’t harm your loved ones ", I know I would be confused and less inclined to follow this ethical principle.…

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Stephen reclaims that we as humans have respect for human dignity, we can punish people for their crimes but we can’t deprive them of everything, which the death penalty does. With the death penalty it’s basically saying to that convict that your life is basically worthless and has no human value. Nathanson believes we are not in any right position to affirm that to anyone. The main reason why this is such a big dispute is that people think a murderer has forfeited is rights as a human being, or morally free to kill him or her. To me though they do forfeit some of their rights but at the same time they are still a human being like the rest of us.…

    • 1274 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Some people get so caught up in their beliefs that they are blind to investigating their belief for good reason. In the case of some people, emotions and thoughts control their beliefs and that overpowers the duty to find good reason. While it is wrong to hold an unsound belief it is also immoral to act on these beliefs, as the ship-owner did in the example. Once someone believes something their ability to evaluate the belief becomes harder. Clifford’s central idea that a belief is not morally correct because of the issue of right or wrong but rather if the belief had been founded on proper grounds or if it was entertained on improper grounds is displayed in the text through fictional…

    • 706 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Sometimes people lie to themselves to cover up parts of their lives that they are not proud of in hopes that if they lie to themselves enough that they will believe the lie. This is not healthy. There are many different ways to get over a situation that would be better for a person than lying to themselves. This may not be considered an immoral form of a lie, but it is an example of how a lie could be unhealthy. Many people who lie do it to protect another person or to save a person from getting offended (160).…

    • 1018 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Kant's Morality Of Lying

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages

    For Kant, lying is always wrong. It does not matter the situation someone is, as long as someone does the right thing for the sake of duty. However, there are paternalistic lies, which are lies that human being uses for protecting other people’s lives. Kant thinks if we do so, we are taking away their human rights. He says that lying affects our “intrinsic worth”, would threat people as a mean and not as an end, and would hurt people’s feeling.…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When lying comes into play, negative feedback or responses are well needed. We may have a bad day or need to do a service better, and if we are continually lying to others, we cannot fix something. By continuously being lied to does not fix a situation, for example in a marriage if your spouse continues to lie over and over again to you and one day you learn the truth, you are more upset then if you had known the truth the…

    • 856 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Simulating Murder Summary

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages

    On this note the experimenters responded that people who do perform such actions of harm lack empathy towards the victim. Killers lack the moral compass that supposedly is integrated on everyone. Perhaps is their egotistical nature or their unwavering confused thoughts justified their actions as morally right. Is it ok to murder someone, even if that person potentially planning on creating an atrocious act. We can bring self-defense into play to justified killing someone but not for the better good of saving other people’s lives.…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Why Do People Lie Essay

    • 1453 Words
    • 6 Pages

    People who have a big heart or cannot stand the thought of hurting someone or embarrassing them typically will lie to the other person by leaving out the more displeasing details. This same type of kind hearted person is also going to be more likely to cater to what the person wants to believe to aid in the other person’s self-deception (Ford 95-98). It is always a good thing to consider other people’s feelings, and people will often tell a lie if they think that it will save someone from hurt feelings. Lies, of good intentions included, tend to destroy a person’s trust in the liar (Firestone). Constructive criticism is a good and necessary thing for people to be able to become better citizens.…

    • 1453 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays