Civil War Argumentative Essay

Great Essays
What led to the American Civil War is a topic of debate which lacks a simple answer. There is heated debate whether the war was fought for emancipation or to preserve the Union. Historians can advocate for either argument since both sides have ample evidence to support their respective standpoint. Both Hollywood and scholarship agree that the Civil War is a war to preserve the Union. While the issue of slavery was a massive factor in the war, it was not the defining factor. The Union army never declared war to coerce the South into abolishing slavery, but to keep the country united. The Union Army fought to maintain the Union, and the emancipation proclamation serves as a means to end the war. Like many scholars, Glory, Gods and Generals, Gettysburg, …show more content…
African American troops were allowed to enlist to serve in the war following Lincoln’s emancipation. The 54th Massachusetts was the first colored Corp, and its bravery in the battle of Fort Wagner paved a path for other colored corps to be established. An increase of troops would always be welcomed in a war, and most of the troops keeping guard in the Confederacy following the Union victory were African American. While African Americans were allowed to serve in the military following the Emancipation Proclamation, in reality only Confederate slaves were emancipated. It was enacted as a war act in regions of rebellion; essentially it made freeing the slaves a goal in the war. Slaves in the areas of controlled by Confederacy were freed as Union troops occupied those areas. The Emancipation Proclamation served as a bonus in the fight to restore the Union. The Emancipation Proclamation, however, was a military ordinance, and thus held little weight as law, it also did not apply to the remaining slave states, Kentucky, Missouri, and Maryland, that did not secede from the Union. Something more was needed if Lincoln wanted to abolish slavery.
The scholarly pieces openly support the Union fighting the war to preserve the Union. Hollywood in the majority of the films surveyed presents a similar message. With the exception of Glory, every film presents a Union army fighting the Confederates with
…show more content…
Following the passage of the Preliminary Emancipation Proclamation, and the later passage of the actual Emancipation Proclamation, Union troops were not satisfied with serving in the war to abolish slavery. The response by the Union Soldiers in the film is remarkably similar to scholarly pieces, such as the letters in The Soldier’s Pen, as argue that the soldiers did view the Proclamation with a positive mindset. George Tillotson’s letter demonstrates the negative opinion of the Proclamation by Union troops, and the scene in the film where the Union troops act displeased about the Proclamation are essentially mirror images of one another. Both reflect the initial negative response by Union soldiers to the Preliminary Emancipation

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Lincoln sought to unite the nation once more, upholding the nation and reestablishing the power over the South. Even in the slave letter did he point out that neither side really pursued to free them. The South wanted to keep them as slaves and the North wanted the slaves only for their army. Neither side sought for their independence from enslavement, only the slaves themselves fought for their own liberty and freedom. Even at the end of the war the South did not see the slaves as a free group of people, they resented the Union, the damage they inflicted on their homes and land and they abhorred the new working structure the government created.…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Choctaw Indians Case Study

    • 1771 Words
    • 7 Pages

    This is not what most Americans today remember being the main purpose of the war. c) To many, the Civil War was fought for the preservation of the Union. President Lincoln’s purpose in fighting the war was to reunite the shattered halves of the Union. I believe President Lincoln freed slaves for the good of the Union, not necessarily for the slaves. In fact, he even said that if there was a way to save the Union without freeing slaves, he would do it.…

    • 1771 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If he could’ve saved the Union without the emancipation, he would’ve done it. But because of the disadvantages the Union was facing at the time, he need to go through with the emancipation to guarantee the northern victory and ensure that the Union as a whole was kept intact. Also, the emancipation didn’t remove slavery from all the states. It only had an effect in Confederate areas still under rebellion. For the border states and all the areas conquered by the Union throughout the war, slavery was legal.…

    • 1561 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Civil War was one of the bloodiest wars in the history of the nations, this war not only shaped the nation, but it changed the face of America by abolishing slavery. Tension began to rise in the territories whether or not to permit slavery west of Mississippi, this became controversial because both the North and the South viewed this in a different perspective. The South was pro-slavery and they believed that it maintained their economy. Slaves helped them cultivate the land and made it easier for the southerners. In contrast, the North was against slavery and they believed that slaves were not needed, the North depended on manufacture and industrial work.…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He is correct to say that the South is not alone in its sin against Blacks. The North was indeed responsible as well. However, as Tindall and Shi point out slavery was the main reason for war. They state, “To argue that the Civil War was primarily a defense of liberty and the right of self-government…ignores the actual reasons that southern leaders used in 1860–1861 to justify secession and war” (Tindall and Shi 497). The leaders of the south wanted to keep slavery and they went to war over it.…

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    However, the Emancipation Proclamation applied to Blacks in the Confederacy, and it excluded the slave states that remained loyal to the United States (Delaware, Kentucky, Maryland, and Missouri). The Emancipation Proclamation did not provide any benefits to African Americans in the United States with the except of being able to serve in the Army. More importantly, it turned the war into a moral crusade for Northerners and Southerners fear of a Republican abolitionist president was proven to be true. The significance of the Emancipation Proclamation on the Civil War was it sparked the conflict and increased the importance of the war…

    • 1291 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Up until the Emancipation Proclamation, there were many different reasons for why the Civil War was being fought, because no one would acknowledge the real underlying cause. The Union was anti-slavery and the Confederacy was pro-slavery, but neither acknowledged that this was a cause of the war. The Emancipation Proclamation “freed” slaves in rebellious, Confederate, territory. Many southerners disagreed with the Emancipation Proclamation and kept their slaves because it was not a law that they were free. President Lincoln was under serious fire for the document, but he said it was “a necessity of war, to weaken the enemy.” The blacks that were able to escape slavery found refuge in the Union army.…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The South fought for freedom and the North fought for ideals for the constitution. This war would determine which path the United States would take whether to abolish slavery or to split into two different countries. The Civil War was important, but the war itself was not as important as the events that caused it.…

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gary W. Gallagher didn’t believe that the war was over slavery but, that the war was over the Union. He provided solid evidence on why he believed that the Civil War was not over slavery but over the Union. I provided evidence also that joined Gary W. Gallagher that the war’s primary focus was the Union. The war was fought for the Union but, the Union attacked slavery because they knew that slavery was a dominant tool that the Confederates used. Moreover, if the war was fought over slavery then slavery would’ve ended when the war did not months after.…

    • 1928 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nevertheless, after the Republicans took control of the Reconstruction, harsher punishments was come face to face on the Southern states to make them agree with new legislations protecting blacks. In many Southern states, governments were established till the states agreed the terms of re-join into the Union. Included acceptance of the 14th and 15th Amendments, undertaking the right of citizenship and vote to black American males. Moreover, the Radical Republicans have begun the first United States prosperity agency, the Freedman’s Bureau, clothing, education for freed slaves and proving food. In spite of their good intentions, however, Bureau failed to set up the freed slaves as landholders.…

    • 746 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays