Benevolent Lies Analysis

Decent Essays
Hill brings up a series of principles of autonomy and three specific cases of benevolent lies in order to show that how those principles of autonomy reject the benevolent lie in the specific cases. In the ideal of autonomy, it is against benevolent lies by claiming that benevolently lying restricts people to acquire the real information about their situation (Hill 264), so benevolently lying infringes the autonomy of the one who is deceived. Then, his lists out two possible objections of his claim. One of the objections is that an agent needs to lie in order to make the deceived one living autonomously. This objection implies that telling the truth can sometimes infringe others’ autonomy, so a benevolent lie is needed in these situations. I think that this objection successfully provides a reason to make benevolent lies permissible, since telling the truth can also infringe one’s autonomy. …show more content…
This is the kind of benevolent lies which Hill wants to focus, and telling this kind of benevolent lies is life-affecting to the deceived, which means that the lie can deeply influence the life of the deceived one. Hill tries not to discuss the unimportant benevolent lies what he calls “little white lies” (Hill 253). By narrowing the area of discussion of benevolent lies, Hills can focus on how this specific kind of white lies can infringe the autonomy of the deceived

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Truth Is Good Analysis

    • 1528 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Lynch begins by defining lying, “To lie, rather, is to assert something you believe to be false with the intention of misleading or deceiving”(Lynch 148). Lynch then defines deceiving as the aim to pass oneself as believing what one does not believe and to keep this intention from the listener. Lynch uses this definition to refute the automatic judgement that deceiving someone is absolutely wrong. After defining lying, Lynch puts it in a category called prima facie bad. In this Lynch states that lying is bad and truth is preferred over falsity, but there are instances where those roles can become reversed.…

    • 1528 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Moreover, lying is an aspect of reality that should be embraced, but still at times avoided. There should be a balance between what is reality and what is not; so lying is only acceptable when people do it “lovingly and well”; otherwise, it is bad and should be eschewed. When people make false assumptions,…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    They prefer to lie without being lied to. “It is crucial to see the distinction between the freeloading liar and the liar whose deception is a strategy for survival in a corrupt society” (23). Freeloading liars are rather selfish and only wish to lie for their personal gains, but some other liars may be in a situation where their hands are tied where the best option is to lie whereas telling the truth can do harm. The outlook of the liar tends to disregard harm to themselves and harm to society. A liar breaks his integrity, credibility and respect for his word are both damaged.…

    • 1429 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    If we take in bullshit and accept it as truth just because it satisfies our current set of beliefs then we will spout it to others and it will continue to spread. Bullshit in, bullshit out. If we do not reduce the amount of confirmation bias in our lives, then it will only lead to the pollution of our beliefs as a society and cause us to have an incredibly distorted view on the world. It is something we do not enjoy doing, but we must expose ourselves to contradictory ideas just as readily as validating…

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The three main types of lies are : white lies, Lies to protect the liar , and lies to cause harm. Experts like Brad Blanton expresses that lies are sometimes justified but it complicates relationships, where as Immanuel Kant believes that all lies are unjustified. Teens in the article exhibit lies as being sometimes justified when mothers lie about the cartoons. Lying to others is sometimes justified when lies have a cost, lies to protect others and relationships, and lies to protect others from harm. First of all, Lying is sometimes justified since all lies have a cost to the lair.…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Essay On Right To Lie

    • 1711 Words
    • 7 Pages

    If the right to lie is established based on proponents’ arguments, it can be easily manipulated to contribute to increased unethical behaviors in the society and cause harm on individuals. Actually, some of these arguments relate to the development and maintenance of sense of self as well as promoting human dignity, which can be accomplished without the right to lie. The dangers of the right to lie on individuals and the society seemingly outweigh its benefits, which imply that lying should not be justified or excused. Every individual who tells a lie should be ready to face the consequences of his/her action regardless of whether the action was fueled by good intentions or not. Truthfulness and honesty is a duty that must be considered as the basis of all duties, actions, and…

    • 1711 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This law prescribes that rational, autonomous agents should only perform actions that would maintain their function if adopted universally. If one were to tell a lie, they would be conforming to the rule that “Lying is acceptable.” Such a rule would prove to be self-defeating in the context of universality; lying would lose its purpose since everyone would expect deceit and be cynical of one another. As a result, Kant argues, lying should never be acceptable. One may be inclined to argue that rules should have exceptions and specific circumstances of forgiveness. A rule that states, “Lying is acceptable when one is lying in order to save a life,” may pass the universality test without contradiction.…

    • 1554 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Be truthful to yourself – People, when consumed by their desire to feel happiness, resort to rationalization, denial or repression when in stressful situations. When you practice rationalization, you try to justify situations according to conditions that are favorable to you. By doing this, you are filtering parts of the truth and only acknowledge those that will make you feel good about yourself. That distorts the truth and it will give you a skewed version of reality – one that is selfish. When you are in denial, you refuse to accept the truth and convince yourself that it is actually a lie.…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    While normally we would look at lying to a friend as morally wrong, if we are lying to protect their feelings and the overall net result is positive, then Act Utilitarianism supports lying. Lastly, Act Utilitarianism support moral flexibility. While many ethical theories have hard rules about never acting in certain ways, Act Utilitarian find that it is immoral to be bound by a rule if the net result of breaking that rule is for the positive benefit. The example Shafer-Landau gives is the Donner Party, where cannibalism enabled the survival of people who would have…

    • 825 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It seems to me that you should lie because no matter what the circumstances are it might still save your life. Yes Blanton did say only lie if a life is in danger, but there are many things, why our life could be in danger and it could be little lies that will become bigger later on. I believe you should lie even if it's a white lie. In other words I picked that lying is okay because sometimes you have to lie in order to not cause any harms way. There are many terms and definition of lying, but there are all the same.…

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays