For What Reason Is the Problem of Evil a Problem for Religious Believers?

644 Words Feb 2nd, 2013 3 Pages
a)For what reason is the Problem of Evil a problem for religious believers? (9)

Probably the most powerful reason against the existence of The Classical God of Theism (hereafter referred to as God) is evil and suffering in the world. The problem of evil is an ‘a posterori’ argument, established from experience based on empirical senses. It is also synthetic as evil and suffering can be seen around us daily. There are a number of possible reasons for the problem of evil and why it causes a problem for religious believers, making it an inductive argument also. In his book Philosophy of Religion John Hick defined evil and suffering as “physical pain, mental suffering and moral wickedness”
“The Rock of Theism” is what David Hume called
…show more content…
The problem with this is that it seems to contradict our own experience of the world where there is obviously evil and suffering.
Another problem for religious believers is that for atheists the problem of evil is convincing evidence against Gods existence as they claim that a loving God wouldn’t have created a universe so full of evil and suffering. “I cannot imagine any omnipotent sentient being sufficiently cruel to create the world we inhabit” (Iris Murdoch.)
There are many problems religious believers face to do with evil and suffering. If God created the world ex-nihilo (out of nothing) then he is totally responsible for it. If He was all powerful then He would have to power to stop evil and suffering, but it still exists and if He was all loving then He would want to stop it, but evil and suffering affects everyone. As evil and suffering exists, either God isn’t all powerful and all loving or He doesn’t exist.
In 1955 J.L. Mackie proposed the Inconsistent Triad. He furthered the work of Epicurus and Hume and constructed the inconsistent triad. Epicurus first proposed the dilemma as a riddle and Hume furthered his theory and concluded that “the Omni qualities of God and evil cannot exist simultaneously but as evil does exist, then the Classical God of Theism cannot”. Through the triad Mackie said “the conjunction of any two entails the negation of the third”, so logically the triad doesn’t hold up. The theist must recognise what Basil Mitchell

Related Documents