Duty To Violate Confidentiality Case Study

Improved Essays
The case “Duty to Violate Confidentiality?” portrays a very controversial matter. It is a conversation between two therapists, Dr. Tad Knowles and Dr. Susan Thomas. Dr. Knowles was disclosing his patient, Ben Therman’s information and stated that Therman has been his patient for five years and concluded that he is HIV positive. Munson states that “AIDS is the disease produced by the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). People infected with HIV are diagnosed with AIDS when the number of CD4 cells of their immune system falls below two hundred cells per cubic millimeter. CD4 cells, also known as T cells, are specialized white blood cells that are crucial to the immune response. HIV destroys CD4 cells. The lower the cell count, the weaker the immune …show more content…
Some questions one might ask themselves regarding this case are: Is it ethical for Knowles and Thomas to discuss about their patients’ health information? Now that Dr. Thomas understands Therman’s health condition, is it part of her duty to disclose the information to her, even though Therman isn’t her patient? Does Dr. Knowles have a duty to keep his patient’s information confidential, even though it can promote the wellbeing of another individual? In my opinion, I believe that therapists do have the right to seek the opinions of other therapists, but only to some extent. As they discuss their opinions, the therapist should be keeping the patient’s personal information, like their name, private. Also the patient should be informed and sign a consent form that allows the therapist to disclose their health information to other health care providers. In this case, I believe that it is unethical for both Dr. Knowles and Thomas to discuss their patients’ health information because they aren’t following the protocol for HIPAA. The second question can be controversial. I believe that it is not Dr. Thomas’s duty to disclose Therman’s information to her patient, Margo. This is due to the fact that Therman is not her patient nor did he agree to disclose his information to her. I also …show more content…
The primary duty of a health care provider is to build a trustworthy relationship with their patients. This includes protecting the patient’s health information and concerns. In this case, confidentiality is breached due to both therapists, Dr. Knowles and Dr. Thomas, because of discussing their patients’ information without their consent. I believe that it is immoral for Therman to not take any precautions when he was engaging with Margo, since HIV is a big deal in the society. He should have taken responsibility and have told her beforehand. It would not be too late to tell her to get tested now. However, I also believe that the therapists should not intervene in their patients’ affairs— they need to respect their autonomies. It is unfortunate we still see cases like this up to this day— where people aren’t truthful in their relationships and are too embarrassed to say something. Everyone has their own opinions on what is moral and what isn’t, therefore what might seem immoral to me, might be ethical to

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Current Ethical Issues in Human Services. QUESTIONS: 1.What happened in your eyes? 2.What made you think it was alright to have sex with a client? 3.Why did you take the client back after he was seeing another therapist? 4.Why didn't you give him a referral when this started?…

    • 421 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    During the first meeting the case manager, adhering to Standard 3 of the National Organization of Human Services (NOHS) ethical code, will thoroughly explain the client right to privacy and confidentiality as well as the limits of both (NOHS, 2015). In addition, discussion about the state’s legal limitations and expectations, as they relate to parental right to know, will occur. Covering these topics with the family is necessary because even though the entire family will take a role in Renee’s intervention she is the primary client, therefore it is essential to take steps that will protect her autonomy. Another point of concern centers on protection of client records. Since the intervention requires therapeutic counseling and coordination for evaluations with Renee’s school great care will be put forth to adhere to Standard 8 of the NOHS ethical code to” protect the integrity, safety, and security of client records.…

    • 1502 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Each scenario in the video provides an example of a violation of the HIPAA Privacy Rule, which was established to protect a patient’s health information while allowing the flow of information needed to provide the highest quality of care to the patient. Scenario 1 The two medical professionals are discussing protected health information in a public area without regard to the other persons in the area. The citizen walking behind the two professionals realized that they were discussing and mocking her mother. Not only is what the two medical professionals did a violation of HIPAA laws, it is also highly unprofessional and unethical.…

    • 253 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Releasing patient information is not only unethical, but also against the law. I could mention meeting Jack Ryan, but there is no need to elaborate. I would state that I am not allowed to discuss patients or any patient information. The significant other should understand and respect the decision to not discuss. Violating HIPAA results in steep consequences.…

    • 139 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    HIPPA Violations

    • 119 Words
    • 1 Pages

    a. If I was the primary nurse for this patient I would inform him that with this specific situation, he might want to tell his wife. That way he would have the necessary support to get through the next steps of the treatment that he is going to have to endure. Also, I would stress to him this is something a person should not have to face by themselves especially if they have someone that is able to be a great help to them. But, ultimately if the patients does not want to tell his spouse it is his decision and I have to honor the fact he does not want to share this information based on HIPPA violations.…

    • 119 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the case of Mr. L, he consented to the thorough medical examination. It further states, “Mr. L otherwise is in good health and is alert, oriented, and mentally intact.” (Kapp, M., 2010, p.28). Mr. L has also not executed a durable power of attorney for health care. It seems to me that the doctor has broken the HIPAA privacy rules by consulting with the granddaughter about the diagnosis and treatment options without getting permission from Mr. L. By researching the question of, “Does the HIPAA Privacy Rule permit a doctor to discuss a patient’s health status, treatment, or payment arrangements with the patient’s family and friends?”…

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As the client and psychologist are in the “ getting to know you “ phase there has come time to talk about the psychologist-client agreement. The Health Insurance Portability Act or HIPPA, is a federal law that provides new privacy protections and new patient rights that deals with the right to the use and disclosure of any Protected Health Information or PHI used for the purpose of treatment, payment, and health care operations ( McGarry, 2015). HIPPA make it so that it is mandatory that the psychologist give you a notice of privacy that will be used and provide information of PHI for treatment, payment, and health care systems. Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California,1976, which was a case where the Supreme Court of California…

    • 1132 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ethical Dilemma- Scenario #1 In the case of Joanne there would be a few ethical dilemmas. The first dilemma would be that I, the social worker, would have a close bond with her and it will be more difficult for me to break the confidentiality rule with her. That would cause for her to be mad at me and most likely leave the program. After leaving the program she would face serious issues, she would have health problems and probability get involve in criminal activities.…

    • 1236 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    According to the practice standards, a nurse plays the vital role in ethical and legal responsibilities to maintain the confidentiality (CNO, 2009). A nurse is accountable to protect the personal health information for the clients, and required by law to disclose information (McGowan, 2012). Prior to disclosing the personal health information, a nurse must ask permission from the client and should respect the client’s decisions whether he/she has agreed to disclose or not. In the practice standards, the nurse should obtain the client’s expressed consent before releasing his/her information outside the health team. For example giving information to family members or friends of the client (CNO, 2009).…

    • 1169 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In 1976, the California Supreme Court ruled in the case of Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California that a patient’s right to confidentiality “ends where the public peril begins.” It was decided that doctor-patient confidentiality could—and should—be broken if the doctor believes a patient will cause serious harm to another person. In his article entitled “A Defense of Unqualified Medical Confidentiality,” Kenneth Kipnis argues that doctor-patient confidentiality should always be kept, contrary to the findings of the Tarasoff case. He presents the fictionalized case of the infected spouse to clarify his argument. In this case, a husband learns from his doctor that he is HIV positive.…

    • 1212 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Breaching Confidentiality

    • 215 Words
    • 1 Pages

    I have not breached confidentiality in this scenario since my disclosure was made in the public interest to prevent the commission of a crime. More importantly, I had proper and specific authority to make this disclosure because I had reasons to believe that the client is going to commit an offence. On the other hand, it could also be the case that I may be held to be in breach of client confidentiality because it is only legitimate professional practice to breach client confidentiality when the client intends to commit a criminal offence and has threatened to do so to the solicitor. Therefore, it can be argued that in this situation I did breach client confidentiality because I am not preventing the commission of a crime as the crime can…

    • 215 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    My Cinematic Social Worker Girl Interrupted is a film that was produced in 1999 by James Mangold. This movie takes place in a mental hospital in the late 1960’s. It is based on an autobiography of an eighteen year old girl named Susanna. At the beginning of the movie Susanna is discussing with her therapist how she took a bottle of aspirin with a shot of vodka, which her therapists believes was an attempt to kill herself, but she denies this as her motive. She is then sent to a psychiatric hospital where she is diagnosed with borderline personality disorder.…

    • 1346 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Before releasing any information the professionals have to make sure they have the patient’s permission. I feel this article’s discrepancy of privacy is…

    • 716 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The informed consent is like a contract that protects both the client and the therapist, it concerns the issues of confidentiality that is of special importance during our therapeutic work. Although psychologist Sean had knowledge that Will was a genius and had a wide range of knowledge, he should not assume that Will had knowledge about therapy and/or confidentiality issues. His failure of providing informed consent to the client and discuss it to make sure that the client understands his own rights violated the ACA code of ethics, as it stated in the code that “counselors have an obligation to review in writing and verbally with clients the rights and responsibilities of both counselors and clients” (American Counseling Association, 2014). In this case, Will is a client who had been mandated for counseling services, Sean as his therapist, should “explain what type of information and with whom that information is shared prior to the beginning of counseling” (American Counseling Association, 2014). Here, I recommend that in the future practice, therapists in this organization always provide clients with informed consent and thoroughly discuss it to make sure that clients fully understands their responsibilities and…

    • 1534 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Therefore, it can be stated that acting without complete confidentiality, would not only be breaking the law but would also lead to negligent of the patients and damage professional standards for both a health care professional or the association they are affiliated…

    • 1013 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays