Does Texting Affect Writing By Michaela Cullington Summary

Improved Essays
In Michaela Cullington’s article, Does Texting Affect Writing, Cullington talks about the debate of texting affecting students writing. The writer uses many sources to back up both sides. Many teachers agreed that texting does inflict bad habits on student’s writing. Other teachers insisted that texting helped with student’s imagination and creativity while writing. In this article Cullington also involves the students themselves by asking them questions about their texting habits. Experts report that they saw no positive or negative effect. Although the author uses many sources from both sides, she seems to argue that even though many sources say that it negatively impacts students, statistics show that it has not influenced students in …show more content…
Some teachers think that texting helps "foster the ability to summarize and express oneself concisely" (Cullington, 2010, p. 4). Another odd statement that teachers are stating is that texting “inhibits good writing” (Cullington, 2010, p. 3). Many students that text and use social media are not forming complete sentences and are using inappropriate or negative words. Something that was discovered that is very bizarre is that teenagers have “created an entirely new language” (Cullington, 2010, p. 5). To think that English is still evolving to this day and has been perfected and changed for so many years and we as young adults can create a whole language is unfathomable. “In response to these complaints that texting is having a negative impact on students writing, others insist that texting should be viewed as beneficial because it provides students with motivation to write, practice in specific writing skills, and an opportunity to gain confidence in their writing” (Cullington, 2010, p. 4). This statement shows that although many people agree that texting has a negative impact, many others believe the other side of the …show more content…
We do it almost anywhere- walking to class, waiting in line at the grocery store, or hanging out at home. It’s quick, easy, and convenient. It has become a certain concern of doctors, parents, and teachers alike. What is it? It’s texting” (Cullington, 2010, p. 1). It seems that majority of the human population has a smartphone and knows how to text. The author uses both sides of the argument of if texting affects writing. In the end, she concluded that even though many people have their positive and negative views on it, that scientifically, there has been no evidence of any kind that texting has any effect on student’s

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Also, she asked some teachers similar questions about themselves, in addition to how they think testspeak affects writing for the students. When she got the answers back she was “surprised at how different the students’ replies and opinions were from the teachers,” (367). She then decided to do her own research and study some sample writing for herself. When doing this she came to find that texting has minimal effect on student writing. Students do realize the difference between writing a formal essay and text messaging.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Therefore, the habits from one can carry from another; some might use this as a counter argument to the previous points made by educators and literary experts, but the fact of the matter is that text messaging has become more common than formal writing, and that is true not only for young students, but for adults as well. This would mean that the behavior of text language, grammar and spelling errors, and abbreviations or acronyms has more time to manifest itself and engrain itself into your mind, cementing the use of these devices almost as a second nature. Text messaging is proven to harm literacy of students, whether they just become lazy or start to make grammar or spelling errors due to relying on digital spelling and grammar checkers. This will continue until we learn to disconnect the two entirely, or learn to write in a more formal way while messaging each other; the latter may take more time to get a message sent, but it will reinforce better habits with grammar and spelling. Until teens learn that school is school and playtime is playtime, this literacy problem will continue to spread until these “textisms” become usable in formal writing, which would perhaps be the worst travesty to hit the literary…

    • 1786 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Included in Cullington’s paper is an interesting and surprising study of research on whether texting is good or bad for writing. She surveyed and studied students, teachers, and teenagers’ writings. Through the interviews and studies in her article, Cullington comes to the conclusion that it is not known if there is a positive effect or negative effect from texting on writing although there are both positive and negative effects. Cullington says that many people argue that they support the idea that texting results in bad writing habits. Others agree that texting has a positive effect and it allows students to have more practice and grow as writers.…

    • 1643 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Michaela Cullington authors “Does Texting Affect Writing” which addresses the primary challenge to formal writing in the form of texting. With the invention of texting many professionals and teachers feel that it negatively impacts the formal writing of the populace. Michaela Cullington goes into detail in this essay on why text speaks does not affect formal writing negatively and in some cases even affects formal writing in a positive light. The author stresses the amount of support each side has a constant emphasis on positive and negative effects. Negatively, Cullington states that many teachers believe that texting prevents students from learning how to display emotions correctly through writing.…

    • 1329 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As reported by Campbell, the exposure to an informal and carefree online environment is, unfortunately, leading students to an unconcerned style of writing. For instance, students are forgetting about punctuation rules, capitalization, and even spelling. In accordance with the author, it has been noticed that those teens are having a hard time while switching from a colloquial context to Standard English. I personally understand that this can happen; being that young, students are likely to adapt themselves with the ambiance they are. Nevertheless, I also believe that parents, the ones responsible for their children, could be administrating these students’ time on the social media and hence requiring of them a little more maturity on what they post.…

    • 830 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In this article, Selfe quotes Anne Wysocki, who says “To be responsible teachers, we need to help our students (as well as ourselves) learn how different choices in visual arrangement in all texts (on and off screen) encourage different kinds of meaning making and encourage us to take up (overtly or not) various values.” She is saying that she believes that good teachers are teaching students to write for not just the page, but for all forms of writing. Education is not just about learning as much as possible. Students shouldn’t just become walking textbooks. Instead they need to be able to take what they’ve learned in the classroom, and apply it to their daily lives. This is something that multimodal writing does.…

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With technology advancing at a rapid rate there is the question on what impact will it have on the classroom. The general consensus is that technology can be a very useful tool in the classroom however it can also prove to be a distraction if it is used by students for things other than educational purposes. In the article “Can College Students Resist the Lure of Facebook, Twitter during class.” The author Barbara King uses several different sources to make her point that technology is a distraction to students and affects their learning. In the article she states that “…at the University of New Hampshire revealed that only 20 percent of them said they send no texts during a “typical” class (King).” It appears that the vast majority of students…

    • 1050 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, wanting a more intimate understanding of how texting influences writing and to formulate her own opinions on how she perceives texting to affect writing, she decided to conduct her own research which included interviewing several of her close, but diverse friends, as well as two former teachers. The two former teachers both asserted that texting was hindering students’ ability to write efficiently, however, their unsubstantiated asservations were founded on subjective perceptions gained through impositions, as opposed to extensive…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She states that the decline of proficient writing abilities is caused by the increased popularity of texting and increased use of abbreviations. Cullington uses a couple of teachers more than several times that crack down on the use of acronyms, and some teachers pointed out some examples that are commonly used like 2 instead of to, gr8 for great, dat for that, and wut instead of what (2). In addition to, teachers say they end up spending more time editing papers and having to remind their students that it is not acceptable using both slang and abbreviations in their writing. Another teacher added that her students have become so custom to using acronyms and slang terms that they don’t even notice that they do it. To add more supporting details to texting affecting writing is punctuation.…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Dansieh states “There is no doubt that text messaging has some impact on the way people talk and write-some negative; others positive depending on the content and context” (Dansieh 222). Upon completing his research and based on the data he collected from various educators, it was concluded that texting has a negative impact on student’s writing skills. Also, based on his research he collected,…

    • 1017 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays