Our Semi-Illiterate Youth? Not So Fast Analysis

Improved Essays
Not Dumb Just Different Is technology making us dumber? When social media users abbreviate or utilize “slang” does it instantly qualify an individual as being lazy, illiterate, or unintelligent? One of the major misconceptions about technology is that it distracts individuals from actually learning. That the use of social media is creating a generation of users who lack grammar or proper sentence structure. In her article “Our Semi-Literate Youth? Not So Fast?” Andrea Lunsford sheds some understanding of why these misconceptions exist. Through years of intense research, she ultimately concludes that technology is here to stay, that naysayers should not jump to the conclusion that it is intellectually damaging. Rather, they should understand …show more content…
That perhaps the taboo of technology creating a dumber generation is in fact a misrepresentation. This is explained when Lunsford expresses that, “Young people are for the most part aware of the context and audience for their writing” (Lunsford 572). In other words, students are choosing on their own free will to alter their writing style. That the decision to not use proper punctuation or sentence structure isn’t because of the effects of technology, but more of a deliberate and calculated decision to express one’s character. It is further explained that regardless of the various types of writing styles, ultimately students are learning more through what she called “life writing” or writing outside of school curriculums. That perhaps the real problem with technology may lie with some teachers and their inability to …show more content…
That although it might have presented new challenges since it’s debut, like being reliant to spell-checkers, calculators and GPS. It has also without a doubt also solved some challenges in the past, like spelling, quantum physics calculations, and helping mom with getting to her destiny accurately. But we can all agree, regardless of which position you take on this matter, that technology and social media has brought upon a whole new level of writing engagement. I’m sure English professors across the world would agree, that a student writing with or without errors, is much better than a student not writing at all. So, is technology making us dumber, lazy, unintelligent or illiterate? My personal answer if not obvious by now is no. I believe, social media and technology is an extension of man himself and overall a good thing. Good in the sense that it has allowed users to continuously engage the act of writing or as Lunsford stated, “The participatory nature of digital media allows for more-not less-development of literacies” (Lunsford 573). That regardless of technology’s faults it essentially is doing more good than harm and when it comes to social media messaging and the lack of proper usage of grammar and sentence structure. Ultimately, It is no different than engaging individuals verbally on a physical level, as both forms have multiple variations of styles when it comes to the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    “Be ready to hear teachers getting upset once again about how kids are unable to write and this is blamed on technology” (Thompson, 2009). Here the author brings out an element of concern and pity over the situation that is prevailing as a result of technological use. He notes that technology has created excessively self-centered people and further notes that technology has contributed greatly towards murdering language. Lunsford’s quote, “I think we are in the midst of a literacy revolution…” (Thompson, 2009), is also another example of emotional appeal.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The basis of Michelle Cullington’s article, "Does Texting Affect Writing" has been viewed as a hot topic throughout the academic community. Cullington’s article pieces together inquiries from professionals in the academic sector, opinions from individuals in which her topic applies, and conducts detailed analysis of collegiate papers - searching for signs of "textspeak" to generate the research basis for her claim (361). Though her works ' effort was published in numerous journals, the structure of her article allowed for both her message and credibility to falter. Inadvertent contradictions and poorly executed research created holes for her readers to see through--allowing for her ethos to come into question.…

    • 1120 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While many strive for technological advances, others are worried that technology can take over cognitive skills in human beings. From watching television to strolling on the Internet, humans are starting to depend too greatly on technological devices and are losing the importance of the malleability of the brain. Because we depend too greatly on technology, people will start to lose the concept of face-to-face interactions, enhancement of relationships, critical thinking processes, and writing abilities. Michaela Cullington’s neutral perspective on technology in his article, “Does Texting Affecting Writing,” gives a plausible argument: that texting has minimal effect on students’ writing through their awareness of knowing not to use the “texting language” in their formal papers. I argue that people should not use text messages as the main source of communication –since texting affect negatively towards young students’ ability to write a concise, formal paper due to the excessive use of…

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The controversy of technology either having a positive or negative effect depends on the type of person. This controversy has existed from the early 1990’s, possibly earlier. (Pinker 1). The creation of various types of technology has brought on the fear of technology taking over and controlling people’s minds. No one really paid too much attention to the effect of technology until Carr wrote his article “Is Google Making Us Stupid?”.…

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Michaela Cullington’s essay, “Does Texting Affect Writing?”, discusses three hypotheses on whether texting carries a negative, positive, or no effect in academic writing. While she was undergraduate student at Marywood University, she wrote this essay in 2010 in response to the bias held by teachers, authors, and students on the effects of texting. Perhaps during the year of 2010, the significant increase of texting led her to write this article. Because technology and electronics perpetually keeps on upgrading and updating its efficacy up until today and texting is increasing its popularity among young adults, this topic is relevant for her readers. As an undergraduate student and a frequent texter myself, I can clearly perceive where Cullington…

    • 1433 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Technology is a wonderful thing at time but over the years it has proved itself to cause many problems. We have discovered that technology has many negative consequences that attempt to ruin our society. Some of the negative consequences of being too dependent on technology are that it has taught us to seek convenience rather than using our minds and doing something the way it is meant to be done. We have also allowed technology to influence our minds too much. Technology has been able to influence our minds too much, this is shown in both Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury and then article “Is Google making us stupid?” by Nicholas Carr.…

    • 693 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In order to do this, she questioned seven of her students asking a series of questions: how long they had been texting, how often they texted, what type of abbreviations they used most and how often they used them, and whether they noticed themselves using any type of textspeak in their formal writing. In order to get another viewpoint, she interviewed two high school teachers as well, but she asked them slightly different questions: had they noticed their students using textspeak in their writing assignments, and, if so, how they dealt with it. She also asked if they believed texting had a positive or negative effect on writing, if they texted too, and if they knew what should be done to prevent teens from using textspeak. Her answers from the students were so vastly different from those of the teachers that she decided to take a sample of twenty college students’ writing to see if textspeak was found. She concluded through their answers, as well as the writing samples, that texting had a minimal to no effect on a student's writing; students do in fact know not to use textspeak in formal writing assignments, and this was proven when no textspeak was found in the student…

    • 1287 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are many researchers, and teachers especially, who are expressing their concern about the lack of writing skills of high school and college students in today’s technological era. The sources express how the see the most problems in the areas of spelling, punctuation, and emotion, Students become so familiar with using textspeak that it is second nature. The teachers are having to take extra class time to explain that “it is not acceptable to use text slang and abbreviations in writing” (363). They also say that students are forgetting how to use the simple things like commas and capital letters when writing because of the fact that these grammatical necessities are not typically used when texting. In texting emotions are not conveyed through words, but through emoticons.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article Does Texting Affect Writing? Michaela Cullington argued the sides for and against texting affecting writing and gave examples from many sources such as teachers, articles, books, and magazines. In Cullington’s article, she included many literary devices trying to gather the reader’s attention to help support both sides of the argument allowing the reader to understand the two sides of the argument. Cullington starts her paper by opening it up to draw the reader’s attention by asking “Does Texting Affect Writing?” and in fact, that is her title.…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, now because of technology people write on an everyday basis whether it be updating their Facebook status, sending a text message, or uploading an Instagram photo. This writing that our generation is constantly doing stimulates our brains and makes us more critical thinkers and analyzers unlike the generations before…

    • 507 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    We live in a word that is changing by the second, and it has been that way for the past twenty years. Technology has ultimately integrated itself into today's society, because of its necessity in the majority of American lives. Mark Bauerlein, the author of “The Dumbest Generation”, believes because of these advancements in technology, young Americans have lost the basic “intellectual habits” of the previous generation. However, social life is not the same as it was in the previous generation, effectively changing the way young Americans learn in today's era. The world is rapidly changing, and society’s expectations are following suit.…

    • 1195 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Technology has vastly improved how we go about our daily lives. From the early civilization days of handwriting letters to someone to now, when we can send that same message to the person in a text message, faster than ever before. It seems now, almost everybody in the world has a cell phone, computer, and possibly multiple ones per household. Technology has helped improve the standard of living in America. With the rapid growth with technology, is there a price to pay?…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How Texting Is Wrecking Society In modern times, texting is a huge part of our society. But it has changed how people communicate for better or for worse. Author John Humphrys, explains in his passage “I h8 txt msgs: How Texting is wrecking our language”, how society is changing because of texting. The main arguments in his passage is “They are destroying it: pillaging our punctuation; savaging our sentences; raping our vocabulary.…

    • 648 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The article of concern here is Does Texting Affect Writing? by Michaela Cullington. The research paper examines the effects of texting on students’ academic writing. In Cullington’s findings, she concludes that texting has a minimal effect on writing.…

    • 974 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Michaela Cullington’s article, Does Texting Affect Writing, Cullington talks about the debate of texting affecting students writing. The writer uses many sources to back up both sides. Many teachers agreed that texting does inflict bad habits on student’s writing. Other teachers insisted that texting helped with student’s imagination and creativity while writing. In this article Cullington also involves the students themselves by asking them questions about their texting habits.…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays