Does Memory Determine Personal Identity

Improved Essays
Many may believe that they are the same person throughout all their life. However, can one really say that the person who is reading this essay right now is the same person 10 years ago? Many philosophers have wondered if one’s memory can effectively determine personal identity. Well, in what follows, I will argue that memories do not determine one’s personal identity over time. In fact, there is no enduring self that would define personal identity.

One way of determining personal identity is memory. In philosopher John Locke’s view, he proposed that what makes a person remain the same over time is their memory of past events (Velasquez 94). For example, if one, now 30, remembers something from when they were 5, if one remembers being that

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Spotless Mind Identity

    • 1483 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In essence, memories are the core to all identity. Without an identity, all individuality is lost and everyone would be indistinguishable. Eternal Sunshine of a Spotless Mind illustrates…

    • 1483 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This extends personal identity to more than memory, to accommodate for lapses in memory…

    • 1449 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From the collective opinions of our relatives and others around us, we are given our initial identity. As we grow up, other factors can similarly affect our lives. From our own choices that place us in certain environments, such as imprisonment, to environments in…

    • 1009 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    You gain more independency as you grow older. People learn to respect you more, you know yourself better as you grow up because of everything that you have been through. How is identity created or formed? People create their own personality as time goes by.…

    • 543 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “The Psychological Criterion”, Derek Parfit tests the definition of identity by analyzing metaphysical hypotheticals, and presents the theory of psychological continuity. Faced with the issue of defining identity, Parfit seems to prefer the psychological continuity theory, seeing that it excludes the least amount of scenarios which fall outside the category of narrower theories. The psychological continuity theory stands as a revision to Locke’s experience-memory theory, which states A is identical to B years later if B there exist “direct memory connections” of being A - therefore, if B lacks memory of being A, then they were not the same people. However, there lay a few inconsistencies within this theory, as illuminated by the sophisticated forgetting objection.…

    • 459 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thus, theories of personal identity attempt to answer the question of personal identity by giving examples…

    • 1193 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Personal Identity is a very debatable subject. How do you know you are you, even growing up are you still the same person you were at age 5. I believe in the psychological continuity theory the survival of the psychology makes the person them. There is the opposing argument called the duplication argument, this argument says it “Relies on the transitivity of identity: If A is numerically identical to B and B is numerically identical to C, then A is numerically identical to C.” But your psychology is impossible to be duplicated there can only be one you at one place at a time no one can have your exact memories.…

    • 950 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    John Locke believes that personal identity across time involves and relies on identity of consciousness. Locke’s view explains the continuation of consciousness across all personal states, such as living or dreaming, while also managing to persist across time. In his examination of personal identity, Locke analyzes the close connection between consciousness and the concept of a person. He judges that two or more substances may be considered to be the same person if they share and partake in an identical, same consciousness. It is not true, according to Locke, that personal identity across time is reliant on the identity of the substance of a mind, soul or body.…

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    As it is stated in The Identity Function of Autobiographical Memory, "...self-identity depends on autobiographical memory, but the nature and strength of the association depends on qualities of both the self-identity and the memories. Moreover, the relation is reciprocal: People 's recollections influence their self-views and vice versa." (pg. 137, Identity Function...) This is the essential relationship between memory and self-identity. Paul Brok establishes a similar idea in All in the Mind with references to relevant theories of John Locke and Hume: “...John Locke famously identified the self with memory: arguing that a person’s identity includes whatever of his past he can remember...…

    • 2162 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    People have always been interested in the idea of finding out about personal identity, what makes you the same person as you were when you were five and what will make you the same person when you are eighty. Derek Parfit summed up this idea by saying “Whatever happens between now and any future time, either I shall still exist, or I shall not. Any future experience will either be my experience, or it will not.” (Parfit- 186), which is what personal identity looks into. This essay will discuss whether personal identity is a matter of physical or psychological continuity, taking into account the famous ideas of philosophers such as John Locke, Derek Parfit and Bernard Williams.…

    • 1500 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Memory and personal identity are an integral part of our lives. These characteristics and traits assist us in the way we make decisions and approach situations. Memory in relation to personal identity is a topic that has been studied by several Philosophers. The question of whether or not memory presupposes identity is a circular one, and therefore makes this question important. To study this, I looked at Parfits theory of Psychological continuity, and how it was seen as problematic due to its circularity.…

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1968: Music As Rhetoric In Social Movements In 1968 social movements sparked rhetorical discourses which occurred in many nations and on hundreds of colleges and in communities across the United States. These rhetorical discourses ultimately changed the direction of human events. Sometimes these points of ideological protests shared views on specific issues, especially demonstrations against the Vietnam War, but each conflict was also its own local conflict. There is no evidence that any specific group organized the protests, or that speakers motivated demonstrations, or that the rhetoric of one protest caused other protests.…

    • 9890 Words
    • 40 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    One problem in Locke’s ideas is whether or not consciousness alone is a necessary condition for sameness of personal identity, meaning that an individual is only the same person if they have a conscious memory of an action performed by them. By Locke’s logic, any individual in the future could have a conscious memory of an action performed by another individual from these times, and therefore be the same person, but not the same human – and therefore would not be punished for any negative actions performed by the individual from the past. However, Locke also wrote that it is possible for substance and personal identity to transfer to other humans, which would mean that in the future another individual could be punished for the other individual’s actions even though they have no conscious memory of ever having performed it. These reasons suggest that unlike Locke argues, having a conscious memory of the past alone, cannot be the only necessary condition for being the same person. This is because there are many scenarios where most would consider an individual the same person, but they may not be conscious of it, and there are many scenarios where a person appears to have a conscious memory of being someone else, but is not the same person.…

    • 1617 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Personal identity is a common philosophical struggle that humans face. What makes us who we are, and why are we here are two crucial questions we have debated over since the dawn of civilization. From birth, we are constantly gaining experience and knowledge not only to survive but also to create our own world-view. Even though we are complex creatures, we have a tendency to categorize the world around us into simple boxes. When a new topic is introduced which doesn’t already fit in one of our boxes, we are offset by this idea.…

    • 1341 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Hume vs Locke What is personal identity? What is the “self”? There is a great debate that surrounds this subject in philosophy. So, which philosopher has the right idea? Is it David Hume with his theory of impressions?…

    • 1303 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays