Plutarco Elias Calle: The Russian Revolution

Superior Essays
For a ruler to maintain in power, the most important action he should take is to let the counter-elite circulate and get some power for them not to rebel against his government. When this does not happen, the counter-elite is not happy and this can lead them to organize the non-elite and start a revolution. A revolution is a radical change lead by violence.
The Mexican Revolution ended with a the 30 year dictatorship of Porfirio Díaz and since then there has not been a dictator. The 1917 Constitution was created; it defined the 3 powers of the nation and many things are still in our actual constitution.
Zapata and Villa made it possible for giving power to the people, made a fair government giving the lower classes a voice and establishing their ideas in plans.
Plutarco Elias Calles radically changed politics forever, creating the PNR, the first political party which institutionalized the revolution. And his main purpose was to have a better organization for politics. Also, he created a sense of nationalism among the people using as his principal tools education and art; muralists as Diego Rivera and David Siqueiros. We can still see that in the way mexican history is taught to us at schools, in a way that makes us feel honoured and proud. The Russian Revolution was an extremely influencing event which later inspired many other events.
…show more content…
After it ended, Lenin wanted to expand the communist/socialist ideas throughout Europe but Stalin, after taking power, industrialized the country.
The government that he established after the revolution was great for economics and politics and leads to a powerful and economically strong country, with just leaders. But it also lead to the Cold War and many other internal conflicts.
Both, the Mexican and the Russian Revolution had many evident differences. I believe that both revolutions had many similarities in its process and development but the way they ended was different.
These two nations, were similar in the part that the lower class lived awfully, and had terrible working conditions, they were tired of the government and wanted a change, which lead them to rebel. The people were the ones who really made this possible, as Alan Wood mentioned in his book The Origins of the Russian Revolution: “Russian intellectuals constantly wrote and talked about it; activists organized for it; the government legislated against it (...) But it was the masses, the Russian people, who eventually made it.” They wanted to have the power in hands of the people. “The most indubitable feature of a revolution is the direct interference of the masses in historical events.” (Trotsky L. & Shawki A., 1930) This three authors agree on the same fact. It started off with Porfirio Diaz, a dictator that was unjust with the people; “ Mexico had experienced a lengthy period of relative stability under Porfirio Diaz (...)” mention Richmond D & Haynes S. in their book The Mexican Revolution : Conflict and Consolidation, 1910-1940.And in Russia with Nicholas the II that took very poor economic and political decisions.Throughout both revolutions people stabbed others in the back, just to get to power. Such as Plutarco stabbing Obregón in the back, or Stalin locking up Lenin just so they could have control over the nation. Russia

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    If one were to have asked a Russian peasant what revolution means to them, they might answer samovol’shchina, or, translated “doing what you want.” In Sheila Fitzpatrick’s book The Russian Revolution she traces three broad themes through the course of the revolution that existed before 1917 and would continue until about the time of 1934. She examines the class struggle that was an important part of the revolution as well as the leadership that lead the Russian citizens through these tumuloous decades and she also examines the modernization that Russia experienced. Fitzpatrick breaks her book down in a chronological order in which she spends her introduction writing about the immediate events that happened prior to the outbreak of the revolution so that the reader, whether an undergraduate student, graduate student or just a fan of Russian history, can gain a true understanding of the air of change that was happening in…

    • 1258 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Just because he has authority doesn’t mean he should be a dictator, he should let people feel free to oppose him and say what they want. This is similar to Santiago’s example because he wasn’t given permission to leave the camp even though he requested to leave many times. Also, it is similar because he was tortured by giving him a ‘Code Red’ in order to improve his performance which was something he wasn’t capable of. This also happens in our region, as the government imprisons people who oppose them and their orders. Moreover, many villains which killed people in the revolution are either still free or the verdict isn’t out yet.…

    • 952 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Russian Revolution Dbq

    • 1641 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Russian Revolution succeeded their chant more than the French Revolution Diego De La Cruz Towards the end of the 1700’s there was a revolution that started all revolutions. The American revolution showed many people that anyone can win a revolution and this revolution started many revolutions in the future. The French revolution another example of corrupt government that was to be overthrew by the people. The same goes for the Russian Revolution where Nicholas II had many events that made the people of Russia not trust Nicholas II and the ideals of an absolute monarchy anymore.…

    • 1641 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Russian Revolution occurred in a series of separate revolutions in 1917. After people grew more and more unhappy with the autocrat government, Nicholas II decided to step down from his position of being Tsar leading into him being the last Tsar of Romanov rule. After this, a Provisional Government as well as the Petrograd Soviet political groups were created after Tsar Nicholas II stepped down from his autocrat position. Both of these groups had forms of authority as well as power but, to a great extent it is true that the Provisional Government had “authority without power” through the military, while the Petrograd Soviet had “power without authority” from the support of the people. Both the Petrograd Soviets and the Provisional Government…

    • 960 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Haitian Revolution DBQ

    • 1077 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Although revolutions are led by different groups and social classes, they all have a common goal of escaping an oppressive government that restricts the rights of the people. The oppressive governments and the lack of rights during this era inspired people to revolt…

    • 1077 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The French Revolution took place in France from 1789-1799. It was a period of time when the people overthrow the government and took over to create a better leadership for the country. The Mexican Revolution for Independence lasted for 11 years from 1810-1821. It was a bloody battle between the Mexican people and people who were loyal to Spain. The French and the Mexican Revolution are similar in that they both were motivated and inspired by Enlightenment ideas.…

    • 856 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This caused a significantly less radical change in Mexico because they were not faced with the same time scale as Russia. Another big factor explaining the less radical conclusion in the Mexican revolution was the differentiation between the resulting types of government. Both revolutions resulted in a rise of the lower class and more equality; Mexico remained a corrupt republic lead by a president through most of the 20th century. Russia took an entirely new approach and implemented ideas of Marxism into their newly formed communist government. Mexico was able to increase levels of equality between the rich and poor but they were not able to radically change how the country was governed.…

    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Source A shows a painting based on a terrible day in St. Petersburg January 9th, 1905. Analysing this painting, we can see the lined-up palace guards, many firing at the protestors while they collapse, and scramble for safety. Bloody Sunday started an attempted revolution for great change. This protest ended in a catastrophe and gained Nicholas II the name; ‘Bloody Nicholas’ due to his palace guards opening fire on the protestors upon confusion and chain reaction further impacting the lives of Russians. Such an event where Nicholas wasn’t around would give a terrible nickname.…

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Russian Revolution was a failure because there was many economic issues and a change of government. Stalin also murdered millions of Russians with the help of his secret police. Many Russians starved to death and lost their rights. In conclusion this proves that the Russian Revolution was a failure because many of the Russians were mistreated by Stalin instead of being taken cared of. One of the main reasons why the Russian Revolution was a failure was because the loss of speech, press, and rights the Russian citizens suffered through.…

    • 965 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Dillon Sutton 11/20/2014 HIS 112 Assignment Five Assignment # 5 Chapter 25: East and West in the Grip of the Cold War Compare and contrast the cultural and societal changes that occurred during the Cold War Era in Russia and China. Make sure to discuss repressive agendas that was portrayed the Communist governments in China and Russia; any restrictions in the media and literature; and any societal changes that includes higher education, the role of men and women in Russia and China. Was equality even possible in Russia and China during the Cold War Era? Explain. BE VERY THOROUGH IN THIS ESSAY.…

    • 1507 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Russian and Iranian Revolutions have very similar causes: an ignorant leader. In Russia, the Tsar was taking Russia into a dead end. His first mistake was to take personal control over the Russian army, which lead to the people blaming the Szar for every defeat that occurred in World War 1 (Class Discussion). Following WW1, the loss of precious resources and the sacrifice of countless lives lead to Russia to be in a state of extreme famine and poverty (Jerry and Ziegler, 1). The crumbling army, food shortages, numerous uprisings, and taking away people’s right of speech and press in the proletariat class lead to a very successful February Revolution in 1917(Jerry and Ziegler, 1).…

    • 1056 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Mexican Revolution was brought on by tremendous disagreement among the Mexican people over the dictatorship of President Porfirio Díaz, who stayed in office for thirty one years. Under his rule, Mexico went through a period of modernization and economic expansion. But along with the good came a lot of bad. Most people lived in poverty .There was a policy of no reelection but he ignored that rule and kept running for president. Soon a group of political reformers led by Francisco I Madero began to speak out against Diaz.…

    • 333 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Revolution according to the Webster Dictionary "is a sudden, extreme or complete change in the way people live work etc". During the World War 1 Russia witnessed the transition to a different and renewed that brought with itself some good and bad consequences; however it is necessary to analyze and understand each phase of the process in order to create a concept and a point of view. The Russian revolution has three main causes: political, social and economics.…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Russian Revolution took status in 1917 during the last stage of World War I. It separates Russia from the war and transported about the alteration of the Russian Empire into the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics substituting Russia’s old-style realm with the world’s first Collectivist state. The revolution occurred in stages crossed two separate coups, one in February and one in October. The new government ranged by Vladimir Lenin would harden its power only after three years of civil war that ended in 1920. The revolution unlocked the door for Russia to completely enter the developmental age.…

    • 1399 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    "In general, the art of the government consists in taking as much money as possible from on class people to give it to the other." (Voltaire) In the allegory Animal Farm written by George Orwell, they experience many things away from them and making them starve. The Russian revolution was in the same vote they had many government take over the people and left them struggle which is about the same thing they did in Animal farm. In the allegory Animal farm Farmer Jones had been taking advantage of the animals.…

    • 914 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays