Battered Women's Right To Self-Defense Analysis

Improved Essays
Source II: Wallace, Shana. “Beyond Imminence: Evolving International Law and Battered Women's Right to Self-Defense.” The University of Chicago Law Review, vol. 71, no. 4, 2004, pp. 1749–1781.
In this article author, Wallace objects to the use of battered woman syndrome as a self-defense. Wallace also explains that as of 2004, battered woman syndrome statistically is the most widely used self-defense plea by abused women who kill their attackers. She provides two major criticisms on justification of battered woman syndrome. The first critique comes from feminist scholars, explaining that by diagnosing battered woman who act in their own defense as mentally ill under this syndrome, doctors are performing a disservice to the women as they are

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    R. V Lavallee Case Study

    • 1753 Words
    • 8 Pages

    In law, it is the duty of judges to be objective and have the same rules be applicable to all its subordinates, but is it fair to expect men and women to behave the same way in certain circumstances? In many cases judges must apply the objective standard of reasonableness to understand the actions of the appellant in the case. Women who are in an abusive relationship have a different state of mind therefore perceive and react to threats in a different manner. Such conditions may cause the women to suffer from battered woman syndrome. Thus, in such cases if a woman was to kill her abusive partner as a result of her fearing for her life, it should be justified in court as a valid self-defence claim.…

    • 1753 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Feminist consciousness raising groups, social workers, women’s advocates and therapists have already done the difficult work of de-pathologizing women’s responses to violence and abuse. Where a therapist without an understanding of VAW might identify Nadia’s “symptoms” (suicidal ideation, depression) as the presenting concerns and attempt to treat Nadia individually, a therapist working from a feminist or relational perspective would rightly identify Nadia’s symptoms as commonly occurring responses to living with violence or abuse. If I were working with Nadia, I might wonder about how to attend to the imminence of both, suicidal ideation and the potential for violence being directed at Nadia from people other than herself. Do individual “symptoms”…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Kiara Rivas Philosophy 25 Due Date: 5/6/2015 Mock Trial: U.S v. Dominique Stephens The case I am presenting today is about a woman who admits to having killed her husband and is being charged with first degree murder. The woman’s name is Dominque Stephens and Mrs. Stephens claims that she has acted in self-defense after suffering many years of domestic violence in her marriage.…

    • 2831 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    “I closed my eyes and put my hands on my ears, so there is nothing more to describe but what I couldn’t block out: those yells from Russell, Fleur’s hoarse breath, so loud it filled me, her cry in the old language and our names repeated over and over among the words (Erdrich, 1988, p. 26). After beating a few men in a game of poker, character Fleur Pillager is physically and sexually assaulted. Violence against Native American women does not only exist on the written page. However, because of the lack of knowledge and inclusion of Native Americans in mainstream society, many are unaware of the struggles Natives encounter daily. Though it began hundreds of years ago, Native people are still experiencing the vehement effects of colonization and…

    • 1785 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Introduction Domestic violence is everywhere around us and for some of us it is not something new. It comes in many forms physical, emotional, and psychological. The abuse is very real and when it starts we are the last to notice it. Nothing is worse then being the person on the outside looking in watching mothers, sisters, and friends go through it without being able to do anything is hard.…

    • 1505 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Men are often expected to be assertive and dominant, while women are often portrayed as vulnerable and emotional. These gender roles suggest that men are more likely than women to turn to aggression during times of anger, which has correlation to abuse against their female partners (Campbell and Muncer 286). As a result of domestic violence, women often suffer from mental and health problems such as chronic pain, traumatic brain injury, eating disorders, diabetes, asthma, and if the abuse is severe enough, even death (Tremer). Although there are already certain programs and laws that exist to help women who have experienced domestic and sexual abuse such as the Violence Against Women Act, women’s rights activists work to change traditional gender roles, educate women on how to prevent or cope with abuse, and provide support groups for individuals and families that have been victimized by abuse (Zimmerman, et al.…

    • 1304 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Battered Woman Syndrome is a term that is used when a woman, after long periods of abuse, whether physical, sexual, mental and/or emotional, kills her spouse without the act of self-defense because at the time of the homicide they were not attacking her. This was first used as a defense in the 1970’s and now it is connected with Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). Jury nullification is the occurrence when a jury declares that a defendant is guilty in regards to the law, but they, the jury, are ignoring that because the feel that the law is wrong in this instance and/or in general. This law has been practice as a way for the American people to push back against law they find unpopular or morally wrong. An example of this is how in the 1800’s…

    • 1601 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Victim Rights These passages present a discussion about arguments concerning victim rights. This is an important debate to victims of violent crimes since victims deserve justice for the crimes perpetrated against them. The two positions argue whether or not a victim's rights should take priority over the rights of the accused. Both viewpoints have valid points warranting consideration; for example, evidence indicates that criminals should be held accountable for crimes they have commited. In contrast, evidence suggests that the accused are not always guilty, therefore, they need more protection from the law.…

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The law acknowledged that women who were violated or killed lived in fear of their lives. The law uncovered that law enforcement agencies and the laws that govern the country failed to protect the women affected by domestic violence and other criminal acts they endured. The law also provided an opportunity to deal with societal issues that have plagued women such as, violence perpetrated against women is no longer a family matter, but a crime and the history of discriminating against woman in the legal system. (Sack, 2004, p.…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay Outline and Annotated Bibliography Does Article 51 of the UN Charter violate the customary law of anticipatory self-defence? Where does the Bush Doctrine of pre-emptive self-defence fit in? Introduction The United Nations was created to prevent another world war, and to maintain peace and cooperation in the international system.…

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Angelique Lavallee was a 21 year-old woman, who was charged with murder after shooting her spouse in the back of the head while he was leaving the bedroom. Kevin Rust, her spouse, had threatened to kill her that night and loaded the gun for her. But instead Ms. Lavallee ending up shooting him that night with the intentions of missing. The psychiatric, Dr. Shane, did an assessment stated her as being terrorized by her partner such as physical, sexual, emotional and verbal abusive. Therefore, in the psychiatrist’s opinion the killing was a final desperate act by a woman who seriously believed she would be killed that night, which would refer as a victim of Battered Woman Syndrome.…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Leslie is volunteers for the National Domestic Violence/Abuse Hotline, and is also on the DC Volunteer Lawyers Project. This article supports my thesis by showing the why behind the silence that many abused females choose to…

    • 1681 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When Susan Glaspell wrote Trifles in 1916, Dr. Lenore Walker had not yet coined the term “battered woman syndrome” in her book, The Battered Woman; the United States’ court records contained no precedent for the use of battered woman syndrome as a defense for murder (Rivers-Schutte 7). It is, however, a fair assumption to suggest that Mrs. Hale, had she been privy to the research and studies on battered woman syndrome, would believe that Mrs. Wright suffered from battered woman syndrome, and her potential role in the murder of her husband is defensible—justified even. While Glaspell’s short play did not give all the necessary information to judge Mrs. Wright’s guilt or innocence fairly, she did offer more than enough information to decide if…

    • 1150 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both men and women suffer greatly from abuse whether it be verbal, emotional, physical or financial abuse. Intimate partner violence is usually referred to as domestic violence, which is a real world problem since the dawn of time. When abuse is spoken of usually the first gender to come into someone’s mind is a female and not a male, but in all reality anyone can be a victim of abuse. Battered men and/or women are beings who feel that they are in danger or are in a life threatening situation and the only two choices are to kill or be killed, their lives are on the line. Their self-defense instincts kick in and they act on it and sometimes that results in the death of the abuser.…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Congress has passed two main laws that relate to domestic abuse. These two laws are The Violence Against Women Act and The Family Violence Prevention and Services Act (“Violence Against Women” 1). Although these law have provided some protection for the domestic abuse victim including prevention programs, hotlines, legal aids and shelters, it has not reduced the number of occurrences. Studies show that “every nine seconds a women in the U.S is assaulted or beaten” (“Domestic Violence Statistics” 1). Furthermore the BJS, Bureau of Justice Statistics states that “domestic abuse accounts for 21% of all violent victimization and only half of all cases are actually reported” (“BJS” 1).…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays