All I Asking for Is My Body Essay

1381 Words Jan 23rd, 2011 6 Pages
Reading Response Paper for “All I Asking for is My Body”
1. “Someday you’ll have your punishment. You’ll have an unfilial son like you,” mother said. “At least I won’t saddle him with a “$6,000 debt,” Tosh said. “And I’ll send him to high school and college. You people are upside down. The parents should owe the children, not the children the parents. Look at the haoles. Obligation is to the children. Traditionally, “filial piety” has been greatly stressed among the Eastern culture for a long period of time. Filial piety basically means to care and support one’s elderly parents; it has been a top priority in part of the children’s upbringing. The novel All I Asking for is My Body
…show more content…
Kiyoshi’s mother also claimed that “Everything in the first seven years of marriage was handed over to grandfather. Years of frugal living and saving wiped out in less than a day” (Murayama 17). In this case, this problem is definitely fated for this Japanese family to deal with and there is no one to blame. Along the way, Tosh and Kiyoshi’s family also incur some debt of their own caused by the unexpected incident of “the Depression” (Murayama 89). This was due to the overfishing by fisherman at that time, which caused their family to earn nothing. However, the incoming expenses continued for the sum period of three months. After hearing his father’s story, Kiyoshi had grown to be a more understanding son, as he realized that it was not his father’s fault. Kiyoshi even stated that “I felt sorry for him. It wasn’t all of his fault, grandfather had got him into debt and once you went in the hole it was hard to get out” (Murayama 89). This shows that Kiyoshi was more able to comprehend what his parents had gone through and how hard it was to predict what kind of disaster would happen to a family. Therefore, Tosh and Kiyoshi should not cause more misery to the family and ought to be more supportive by helping the entire family to overcome the debt they currently have to pay. It is morally ethical for the children to play a role in resolving family problems. Exodus 20:12 reads, “Honor thy father and

Related Documents