Unequal Freedom Summary

Improved Essays
While America has always claimed to be the “land of opportunity”, it has also remained a society in which gender and race determines opportunities. In Unequal Freedom, Glenn explores inequality in the U.S. through citizenship and labor. She uses three non-white groups in three settings: the south, the southwest, and Hawaii to explain her analysis of interactions among race and gender relations. The struggles of minority groups to received economic freedom and full political rights has always been problematic. This book seeks to identify the challenges of the oppressed, while discretely acknowledging the abusing tactics of the oppressor.
Glenn says (pg. 1), “Citizenship has been used to draw boundaries between those who are included as members
…show more content…
Hawaii was a hot commodity for sugar and just as in the south, field owners saw profit from cheap labor. Once Hawaii became a U.S. territory so did the laws, which also as in the south excluded Haloes from social, civil, and political rights for the interest of free white men. Glenn says (pg. 192), “Privatization of land enabled the nascent Anglo American oligarchy to establish a plantation based economy relying at first on Native Hawaiian labor and later on imported Asian labor.” The emergence of property rights also arise here. What the Hawaiians had once owned was now taken by whites and as usual the whites or Anglo Americans could do what they want because they were the only ones who had a say so since non-whites were not citizens and most definitely could not own property. One contrast between black slaves and haloes was that haloes were paid for their labor, while slaves worked for free until whites in the south also began to pay them little money for more work. Hawaii consisted more of Native Hawaii and little whites, so when Japanese were imported into Hawaii there group became the “other” or “un- American.” This meant that Japanese were not considered citizens. Glenn says (pg.196), “Asian workers were treated strictly as laborers, not settlers and potential citizens.” There was also a psychological stigma that Japanese and Chinese workers were an ideal labor force and just better off as laborers. Education was also a barrier for both blacks, haloes, and Japanese. Glenn says (pg. 234), “Americanism in public schools, and the expansion of vocational education designed to track Japanese boys into agriculture and girls into domestic work.” Education was strategically place in non-whites life for a higher purpose to keep them from becoming more educated. Because they could not read, they were also excluded from

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    In today’s society, most schools, both elementary and secondary, don’t discuss Asian or even Asian American History. African American, Native American and even European histories are all extensively covered in history classes. Many students have at least some knowledge of African American slavery, forced cultural assimilation of Native Americans, and the civil rights movement. From an early age, children are taught that the U.S. is a country created by immigrants; however, American history classes have shown a trend of teaching that excludes Asian Americans from the history of this country. At most, the topic of Asian American history is lightly touched, only introducing San Francisco Chinatowns or the large influx of Asian immigrants looking…

    • 1254 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The book Overthrow by Stephen Kinzer is a collection of stories describing different events in which the U.S. overthrew foreign and oppressive governments, or simply governments that were not beneficial for America. One of the stories he included was America’s annexation of Hawaii, a massive turning point in our country’s history. However, The way Kinzer writes and retells the story is slightly biased towards the side of the Hawaiians. This makes for a story that may change peoples perspectives on an important piece of history. The Majority of the accounts and sources he credits are Hawaiian, and the U.S. is not as well represented in his bibliography.…

    • 580 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the book, “American Citizenship: the Quest for Inclusion,” by Judith N. Shklar, Shklar places emphasis on the fact that America was founded upon the principles of freedom and equality, yet excluded various groups of people based on economic status, gender, race and religion, and many people were enslaved. Shklar recounts the circumstances these people endured in order to gain citizenship, economic independence and ultimately the right to vote. Born to Jewish parents in Latvia, Shklar immigrated to the US when she was 13. She went on to attend McGill University and Harvard University and later became a professor and political theorist. Shklar provides a unique perspective on citizenship because she, like many other Americans, faced challenges…

    • 441 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When the Mahele was made, it was supposed to make it easier to own land, but instead it was harder for Hawaiians to own land. The land was auctioned off and was sometimes rigged, The Mahele was originally made to give the Hawaiians the land they were demanding. This made things unfair because the hawaiians got a little portion of land compared to the foreigners. The People who spent their lives on farms growing crops have to sit and watch their crops get pulled from the ground.. The Mahele was unjustified because Hawaiians were not able to get land, their crops were pulled, and there was no resources for houses.…

    • 381 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In history, there has always been inequality; otherwise there wouldn’t be any pushes to make a change. A great portion of inequality has been evident among those identified as minorities. Specifically, the United States being such a melting pot has not always been the case, for many people have accounted for the challenges they faced while living in a society where race and culture defined where they stood on the social chain. A woman who became the first Navajo surgeon, Lori Arviso Alvord, wrote a piece on her experience of being in a college that was meant to promote Indians being on campus, and her story had power among the way she saw her situation. In her piece, she recounted that she “walked around the campus in awe, like a peasant visiting the castle of a great king” (Alvord, Lori Arviso, 303).…

    • 1833 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The United States of America was a nation built upon the notion of freedom and equal opportunity- in which all peoples have impartial opportunities and rights. However, these principles did not always have their right of way. From the first ship of enslaved African Americans to arrive in the early seventeenth century to modern times, discrimination and racial segregation has always been an issue. In both “Sympathy”-- a poem about a caged bird’s fight for freedom after being liberated from slavery-- by Paul Laurence Dunbar and A Voice That Challenged a Nation --a biography which spoke about Marian’s struggle for equal rights after she had experienced the harshness of the South --by Russell Freedman, the two parties faced the challenges of…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Peripheralization could also be found in Hawaii at this time. Peripheralization is the “differential distribution of power, interest, labor, and capital across space and the domination of local 's areas and cultures by the mandates military-industrial time” (Wilson, 2000, p. 522). Hawaii became a plantation resource, military outpost, and tourist site for Americans. The territory was treasured by the United States. President William McKinley said, "We need Hawai 'i just as much or a good deal more that we need California.…

    • 1809 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many foreigners exploited this law and bought off Hawaiian lands to be manipulated themselves, where they could gain opulence. What made this even more advantageous for the haole was that they already had capital prior to this act, in which they could buy off more land (Borreca). In fact, it was so simple for foreigners to acquire land, that, when auctions were conducted of Hawaiian lands, they simply bought it at cheaper prices than what was offered (Kuloku). After buying land, foreigners would make a profit by growing sugar and various other crops, where they would buy even more land and gain more affluence. It was a cycle, buffered by the loss of land from Hawaiian commoners.…

    • 544 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Over the years North America has become the home to many immigrants, resulting to this continent to become a big melting pot of cultures. People from all over the world moved to America to find their own American Dream. Nancy Lee Johnson, a senior at George Washington High, had a passion for Art and contested to win a scholarship, which she thought would be her way out to a better life. Nancy Lee’s displeasure to not winning the Artist Club Scholarship due to her being a “Negro” made her to rethink the true meaning to the Pledge of Allegiance that she said every week at the assembly’s. Nancy Lee was a proud “Negro American” even though she knew that “A Negro in America was often hurt, discriminated against, sometimes lynched…” she still believed in her American dream.…

    • 301 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Japanese were also slaves to the whites. The Japanese, or "Japs" (as the whites referred to them as) were forced…

    • 736 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Annexation Of Hawaii

    • 660 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The acquisition of Hawaii can be described as a bitter over throwing of the queen, Lydia Kamakaeha Liliuokalani, and her government by a group of American planters who were interested in nothing more than creating a fortune. The issue brought in many figures including United States soldiers, Presidents Benjamin Harrison, Grover Cleveland and William McKinley, Sanford Dole, and nonetheless, congress. Although Hawaii was interested in sugar trade with the United States, they were not typically pleased about the conspired annexation that the U.S claimed as manifest destiny. However, the acquisition of Hawaii did benefit America as it was a ‘“stepping-stone to the growing trade of the Pacific,’” according to Grover Cleveland (Tindall and Shi 696).…

    • 660 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Building Freedom: The Freedmen and Their Quest for Egalitarianism The foundation of the United States of America was constructed upon the corpses of Native Americans. Cemented by institutionalized white superiority and racism, African American slaves were the bricks by which were used to erect this great nation.…

    • 1206 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Derrick Bell’s After We’re Gone: Prudent Speculations on America in a Post-Racial Epoch reminds us how minorities have suffered oppressions from white supremacy, and that even our Constitution provides only limited protection from such oppression. Thomas Jefferson “expressed the view that blacks should be free, but cannot live in the same government.” During the civil rights movement, African Americans’ goals were to end the racial segregation and discrimination. After blacks won their equality, they were considered separate but equal.…

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The text, Privilege, Power, and Difference by Allan Johnson, is a 156-page detailed account of Johnson’s views on American society and how social class, race, sexual orientation, gender, disability status, and privilege causes a “difference” in the way we view each other. Johnson’s personal views on how these factors affect the way members of the minority live and survive in current day United States is aimed at raising social awareness. The text, written by Johnson, identifies the social principles that form the belief of privilege and entitlement, often making jest at the very serious issue of inequality. This was a quick and easy read, yet was packed with valuable information and valid arguments. Johnson delves into American history,…

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What is freedom? Is it the right to vote, the right to express your own opinions, the right to live your live as you please? In American Politics and the African American Quest for Universal Freedom written by Hanes Walton Jr., and Robert C. Smith, they answer and discuss these questions as they pertain to African Americans today. They explain how challenging the journey of freedom was and still is, “given their status first as slaves and then as an oppressed racial minority,” (Walton, 92). The book not only highlights African Americans usage of coalitions, interest groups and the media throughout the centuries to support their natural right of freedom, sometimes without prevail.…

    • 1343 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays