Advantages Of Longhand Over Laptop Note Taking

Improved Essays
“The Pen Is Mightier Than the Keyboard: Advantages of Longhand Over Laptop Note Taking”
In recent years, taking notes by using a laptop has become increasingly common among students attending lectures. It is evident from previous studies that if laptops are used for note taking while surfing the web or for other distractions, it will impair the learning process. However, this study aims to show that even without these distractions, students will perform worse than longhand note takers because they have the tendency to write the notes verbatim, instead of making into their own words. This is a vital part of learning because this means that students are processing the information that they are given, instead of writing exactly what they hear.
…show more content…
The room that the students were experimented on had either laptops or notebooks, depending on the condition and they were shown a 15 minute TED talk lecture. They were told to use their normal note-taking strategy, while the experimenter left the room. Afterwards, they were taken to a lab in which they carried out two 5 minute distractor tasks. They then answered factual-recall questions and conceptual-application questions about the lecture. The results showed that on factual-recall questions, the students performed equally well across both conditions. However, on conceptual-application questions, the students who took notes longhand did significantly better than the students using laptops. Furthermore, students who hand wrote their notes had less words than laptops users and laptop users had an average of 14.6% verbatim overlap with the lecture compared to 8.8% for the longhand note takers. This study was significant because even though laptop notetakers had more information due to their lengthy verbatim notes, since they were not processing the information while writing, they performed …show more content…
There were 4 groups: laptop with study, laptop with no study, longhand with study and longhand without study. They watched 4 lectures and were told to return the following week to take a test on what they have seen so they were required to take notes. When they returned, the study group were given 10 minutes to study their notes before taking the test and the non study group took the test immediately after returning. The test consisted of 10 questions from each lecture for a total of 40 questions. The questions were either factual, conceptual, or combined. The results showed that students who took notes longhand and studied performed better than the other conditions across all the question types. Similar to the other studies, longhand people used fewer words than people who typed, and there was more overlap of the words in people who typed than people who wrote longhand. There were no significant differences in the amount of words or verbatim overlap between the study and non study conditions. All in all, there was not a difference between laptop and writing when the students were unable to study before the test, most likely due to the delay of the test. However, when the participants were allowed to study, longhand performed better than laptop note takers. This suggests that people who take notes longhand may have better external storage and encoding functions. It may also

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Technology Vs Classroom

    • 1788 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Also, more research shows that notes taken on a laptop are more just copied notes, they have more verbatim to them. If the students didn’t understand in class they won’t understand when they look back in their notes because it’s just copy of what the teacher said. “Content analysis consistently showed that students who used laptops had more verbatim transcription of the lecture material than those who wrote notes by hand.” (May 2) This further more backs up the point on why computers are bad for note taking. Some people may argue that using laptops are a lot easier because you can type faster as well as get most of everything that is said during the lecture, but if the studies say that it makes the notes…

    • 1788 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to many student accounts, typing notes rather than writing is more convenient as typing tends to be faster and also lightens up the weight of their backpack. However, students can easily use the lockers provided by the university in order to store excessive materials not needed for the class which could also lighten the weight of the backpack. In addition, according to a paper published in journal of Psychological Science, two researchers Pam Mueller and Daniel Oppenheimer found that writing notes rather than typing helps by providing students with a better grasp of subject materials being taught in class. This would give the students writing notes far better advantage over those typing it in test taking skills, written explanations, reasoning behind answers, etc. making them more successful in the course.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    While having an easy access to information may seem like a great thing, it can become a real problem too, computers have made cheating easier than ever. Suing computers in the classroom can also create distractions, especially when students use them for personal reasons while the teacher is teaching. Students also develop poor writing skills. A computer can auto correct a wrong word which can be helpful when writing important papers but it’s not a good thing in the long…

    • 1632 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since (4A) the study used verbatim transcription it left a more complete record to help with better studying from those notes taken. Their theory was supported by the data because it showed that the (4A) even when the students were given as much as a week to review the notes, the ones that used their laptops to take the notes stilled scored lower on both the conceptual understanding and factual content as compared to the students who had taken longhand notes. I agree with the results because if (4B) if using the laptop versus taking the notes longhand wasn’t affecting the learning of the students than the results would be the same. The fact that (4B) the majority of the students who took their notes longhand performed at a much higher rate than those who used a laptop proves this study. If the (4B) students using the laptop would have performed just as well or better than the one’s who used longhand than I would disagree with the theory that the pen is mightier than the…

    • 901 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Recent studies have shown that writing notes by hand is more effective than typing notes on a computer. Writing by hand helps students remember the material learned in class. Using too much technology affects important life skills and the way students learn. Researchers have studied the effects of writing notes and typing notes. Even though taking notes on a computer helps with organization and is much faster than handwritten notes, the best option is to write notes by hand.…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    In 2012, William J. Oehlkers and Cindy DiDonato comment on this topic stating, “Technology does not substitute for labor, and efforts to improve the management and deployment of human resources have generally not succeeded.” This is extremely true. Many people do this though. They think just because they can use technology they do not have to work as hard to get the same product. This is the kind of thinking that hurts people even once they are out of schooling. In 2014, 12 Advantages and Disadvantages of Technology in Education states, “Computers make it so easy to find answers that students barely have to look for them.…

    • 1247 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Career In High School

    • 1039 Words
    • 4 Pages

    There wasn 't much work, tests were open-note, and there were plenty of extra credit opportunities, so I passed both years with ease, despite me not fully understanding the subject. It was just good notes and occasional memorization, but hey, what more could a middle schooler want than a good grade and seeming understanding of the subject? Of course, this would not be helpful in the future. When I began to take AP European History my sophomore year in high school, I started off alright, being easy enough in the beginning, like most classes. Once the second month started rolling around, however, I was so completely lost, and my A plus in the class plummeted to a solid C, and I was terrified.…

    • 1039 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Smarter And Nicer

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages

    But, that doesn’t mean people don’t enjoy reading on screen better than a paper book. Students nowadays are actually learning online instead of physically going to a class and they learn better that way. Technology isn’t a bad thing, but, it can affect certain people in specific…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    No Child Left Behind did not have a positive effect on teaching students with disabilities. Having teachers be highly qualified is a positive, but the negative is that there is no clear definition. The testing of special needs students is not right because even with accommodations they may still do poorly. In addition, not having the right professionals to proctor these students puts them at a disadvantage. The Reading First program was a positive idea, but it did not produce better scores on standardized tests in reading.…

    • 1695 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These results could have occurred because participants not only thought the music was a distraction while reading the passage, but because they weren’t interested in the passage, their errors were much higher than the math or recall tasks. According to literature, background noise could occupy some of the available working-memory resources so that the person can no longer fully attend to the reading process. Instead of looking at gender in a broad spectrum, it is better to look at the individual differences (Johansson, Holmqvist, Mossberg and Lindgren, 2012). Results showed that there was no significant effect of listening to music and reading. This result could have occurred because most of the female participants didn’t listen to music while completing educational tasks and most of the male participants expressed that the tasks were hard when they first started to read the text, with the music playing, but later they tuned the music out.…

    • 1100 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics