Judith Thomson Abortion Analysis

Good Essays
Abortion is a big topic that everyone has a different view on it. Such as Thomson who believes that abortion should be a right and that women should not be denied to it because it is their body. Judith Thomson is correct in saying that a woman does not have a duty to preserve the life of her fetus even if it is her genetic child. As the supreme court stated, denying an abortion may lead stressful life and future for the mother. A woman has a right to do what she pleases with her body especially in the case of rape-induced pregnancy. No women should be forced to remember the past, of what she went through even though it's not the fault of the fetus. Everyone should have a right to an abortion.

Abortion should not be denied because if you deny
…show more content…
The violinist is on his deathbed in need of a kidney transplant. If you were kidnaped to help this person which would mean you would be in a bed next to him for about 9 months, you would think that it's outrageous. It is the same thing as a mother carrying a fetus for 9 months that was caused by rape. Letting the violinist die is like letting go of the fetus which is really no different or wrong because a mother has the right to control her body. But if you decide to help the violinist or keep the fetus then that is called a good Samaritan act. As Thomson says, even if the mother knew the risks of sex she is still not morally responsible for the fetus even if she is causally responsible.

Women should be able to abort especially in the case of rape because women don't want to grow up hating their child because they know how their child came to be. Some women become depressed, get into drugs and start resenting life and family. Having the child of their rapist is always going to be a reminder of the past. they won't be able to move forward because they will be reminded of the past every time they look at their child. This kind of life will not be healthy for the mother or the
…show more content…
just like any house people allowed are to do what they please to their house why should abortion be any different? However, either way, someone’s right will be taking away either the mother or the fetus. But, the fetus is of the mother therefore, you can't take away the mother's right to life because she has a right to do what she wants with her body. If the mother says to save the fetus then that is a choice that she has made which means that in this case letting the mother die is justifiable. If the mother does not give that choice in a case of an emergency then the doctors cannot make the decision to save the baby or fetus over the mother. They should save the mother not the fetus because it is her body. It is true that the fetus is not at fault, the mother is causally responsible for the existence of the fetus, however, she is not morally responsible for the fetus. She can be a good samaritan and keep the fetus for nine months and then either keep it or give up for adoption. Adaption will only create more harm than good just as it would if the mother kept the

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Abortion Research Paper

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Women have the right to a choice when pregnant, to birth a child or to abort the fetus. To the pro-life community this is to show the other side of the table. Having an abortion is not a simple matter, a woman who has an abortion should not be considered…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In cases like this it is hard to harm the fetus. As Thomson believes, the baby doesn’t necessarily have a right to the mother’s body because the mother was wrongfully harmed and has no intentions of having a child. In a situation like this, Thomson believes that it would be okay to have an abortion as long as the fetus isn’t…

    • 1137 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Argument On Abortion

    • 1713 Words
    • 7 Pages

    I will argue that a fetus cannot survive on it’s own and that a women should have free choice to her own body. an article I read titled Perspectives on Abortion, the author brings up a pro-choice author named Boonin, who argued that “...the fetus is not yet a person and does not have a moral value yet…if a fetus is considered a person, then a zygote or a woman’s egg is a person as well; and therefore are entitled to human rights.” (Lopez, pg. 515). Boonin is trying to argue that if a fetus has rights, then so does every egg in a women’s body. In the article titled Abortion: A Pro-Choice Perspective, Robert Blake argues that, “We see the fetus as a potential life to continued development is subordinate to the mother’s right to privacy, which includes the right to terminate an unwanted pregnancy.” (Blake, pg.…

    • 1713 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This is an important point for it goes with the fact that even though a fetus has the right to life, it does not necessarily give it the right to use the mother’s body. Especially when the mother is not ready for the pregnancy or not ready to be a mother for any reason. It also shows that it is not wrong for a woman to get an abortion because she has the right to control what goes into or comes out of her body. If a woman has an unwanted pregnancy, she has the right to want the fetus out of her, and to do something about it. That fetus has no more of a right to use the woman’s body to gain life than the woman’s right to get rid of the unwanted fetus.…

    • 1338 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The mother does have a right to life and her will power. Therefore abortion can be right in situations where the mother life is in grave danger because of the pregnancy or if the women was raped. In this case the mother did not choose to have sexual relations knowing the consequence, but was forced too. In the same way the mother did not choose to have poor health. It is more morally correct to save one life then loss two.…

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Essay On Autonomy Of Women

    • 1051 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Protecting Women’s Autonomy Abortion has long been a controversial issue with countless people protesting against it and others just as strongly protesting for women to have the right to choose. I am not going to argue that abortion in itself is morally right or wrong, but I believe a woman has the right to decide if abortion is the right path for her. It is ethical for a woman to choose to have an abortion while she is in her first trimester because the fetus has not yet developed into its own being, leaving the decision fully to the mother. “The principle of autonomy can be stated this way: Rational individuals should be permitted to be self-determining. According to this formulation, we act autonomously when our actions are the result of our own choices and decisions (Munson 404).…

    • 1051 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The ideal way would be for every pregnant women to be able to take care of and want the baby. However, it should be the women’s choice to be able to have an abortion without it being illegal or without them being judged by society. Every pregnant women has a different circumstance and they may not be able to that child even though they wanted to. Giving the idea that having an abortion is morally wrong forces women to risk their lives having the baby aborted…

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    A woman’s right to privacy says that she has the right to make any decision without government interference. The government should not influence women because only they know if they are ready for a child. If a woman becomes pregnant, it is most likely her fault for being involved in sexual activity before ready to become a parent. If she is not ready to be a mother, give the child up for adoption, but do not kill it! Another right guaranteed to woman is the right to decide the number and spacing in between children, so the government has to make abortion legal.…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In 1973, the Supreme Court resolved the unconstitutional law that prohibited a woman to have an abortion for non-emergency reasons. Since then, the controversial case known as Roe V. Wade has divided the people, labeling themselves as either pro-life or pro-choice (McBride). Abortion is not a topic that should be treated lightly, but it is also not a topic that should be ignored all together. In fact, for some, it may be their only option. Abortion should be legal no matter the case because it saves women who cannot have a child, motherhood is a choice, and a child should not come into this world unwanted.…

    • 1592 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Abortion's Moral Debate

    • 1655 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The fetus has the right to life, and thus Yuen Ying should not be permitted to perform abortion, and by having had voluntary sexual intercourse, she should assume responsibility towards the baby, because she has caused its existence. (sentence too long, could separate it) Considering that she was conscious about her pregnancy and her health state, but still decided to keep the baby proves that she has voluntarily accepted to bear the baby, knowing the risks involved. Moreover, the fetus is dependent on the mother, thus she should be “morally responsible for assisting [her] fetus when her voluntary acts or omissions cause the fetus to be dependent and vulnerable” (Abbate 146). Unlike the other analogies, like the violinist, where the two individuals are strangers to each other, the mother is related to the fetus, and thus should be responsible in ensuring its life. Both parents are “compelled by law to provide support for their children” (Thomson 20).…

    • 1655 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays